Skip to main content

Old Cut Diamond Solitaire

7
to
135
1,342
1,264
938
311
305
120
85
79
41
27
8
7
7
2
1
1
17
274
2,013
405
190
209
504
195
107
56
36
21
13
14
12
26
21
21
17
10
1,675
1,033
24
2,729
3
1,662
1,293
1,051
483
480
2,606
278
51
121
13
1119
438
199
85
46
to
Sort By
18ct Yellow Gold Old Cut Diamond Solitaire Ring. Est 025ct.
Located in Canterbury, GB
This unisex old cut diamond solitaire ring is set in 18ct yellow gold. Diamond est 0.25ct and this
Category

Antique 1840s Victorian Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond

Old cut diamond solitaire ring, English, circa 1920.
Located in London, GB
Old cut diamond solitaire ring. Set to centre with a round old cut diamond, D colour, SI1 clarity
Category

Vintage 1920s British Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Gold, Platinum

Georgian Style 4.34 Carat Old Cut Diamond Solitaire Ring
Located in London, GB
band, the face of the piece presents a single oval faceted old cut diamond which has been set in a
Category

Antique 18th Century Georgian Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, Gold, Yellow Gold, Silver

Vintage Circa 1930s Old Cut Diamond Solitaire Ring 15 Carat Yellow & White Gold
Located in Hamilton, AU
interlaced band rising towards a sparkling Old Cut diamond, she is a subtle yet detailed beauty. The Hedda
Category

20th Century Unknown Modern Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, Gold, Yellow Gold, 15k Gold, White Gold

Art Deco 3.00ct Old Cut Diamond Solitaire Engagement Ring, c.1920s
Located in London, GB
This stunning diamond solitaire captures the grandeur of the 1920s. An impressive 3.00 carat, old
Category

Vintage 1920s Unknown Art Deco Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

2.40 Carat Old Cut Diamond Solitaire Platinum Engagement Ring, circa 1920s
Located in London, GB
This spectacular antique solitaire engagement ring features a beautiful 2.40ct Victorian old mine
Category

Vintage 1920s English Art Deco Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

Certified 7.01 Carat Old Cut Diamond Solitaire Ring in Yellow Gold
Located in London, GB
A truly remarkable certified old cut diamond single solitaire ring set in 18k yellow gold. The
Category

Antique Early 1900s British Victorian Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, Gold, 18k Gold, Yellow Gold

Vintage 14k White Gold .45ctw Old Cut Diamond Solitaire Engagement Promise Ring
Located in Montclair, NJ
) Natural Genuine Diamond - Old Transitional Cut - Illusion Prong Set - G Color - SI1 Clarity - 0.37ct
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, 14k Gold, White Gold

GIA Certified 1.04 Carat F VS1 Round Brilliant Old Cut Diamond Solitaire Ring
Located in New York, NY
This timeless solitaire ring features a 1.04 carat F VS1 old cut round diamond, set in a classic
Category

2010s American Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

Hancocks 7.09 Carat G VS1 Old European Brilliant Cut Diamond Ring
By Hancocks
Located in London, GB
A stunning old cut diamond solitaire ring by Hancocks set with a beautiful bright and lively old
Category

21st Century and Contemporary British Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, 18k Gold

Antique Diamond and White Gold Platinum Set Solitaire Engagement Ring
Located in Jesmond, Newcastle Upon Tyne
, fluted platinum setting displays a 0.63 Ct Old European round cut diamond, held within an eight claw
Category

Vintage 1930s Unknown Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, 18k Gold, White Gold, Platinum

1900s Antique 1.14 Carat Diamond and Platinum Solitaire Ring
Located in Jesmond, Newcastle Upon Tyne
representation of this stunning Old cut diamond solitaire ring. Diamond Quality Feature Diamond Colour J Clarity
Category

Vintage 1910s Unknown Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

1920s Antique 3.16ct Diamond and Platinum Solitaire Ring
Located in Jesmond, Newcastle Upon Tyne
detract from the true representation of this stunning old cut diamond solitaire ring. Diamond Quality
Category

20th Century Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

Antique 1.05 Carat Diamond and White Gold Solitaire Engagement Ring
Located in Jesmond, Newcastle Upon Tyne
four claw set 1.05Ct Old European round cut diamond. The elevated, tapering and pierced decorated ring
Category

Antique Early 1900s Unknown Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, 18k Gold, White Gold

Antique Old Mine Cut Diamond Gold Solitaire Ring
Located in Cairo, EG
Antique old mine cut diamond solitaire 14k gold ring centered with 1 old mine cut diamond with an
Category

Antique Early 1900s Russian Art Deco Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, 14k Gold

Antique Old Mine Cut Diamond Russian Gold Solitaire Ring
Located in Cairo, EG
Antique Russian diamond solitaire ring centered with 1 old mine cut diamond with an estimate weight
Category

Antique 1890s Russian Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, 14k Gold

GEMOLITHOS Solitaire Old European Cut Diamond, Est. 1.9 Carat.
Located in Munich, DE
Solitaire Old European cut Diamond, est. 1.9ct I color & Vs clarity.
Category

Antique Early 1900s Unknown Belle Époque Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, 14k Gold

Edwardian 0.45ct Old European Cut Diamond Solitaire Engagement Ring
Located in Boston, MA
An original Edwardian period old European cut diamond ring in 14 karat yellow gold and platinum
Category

Antique Early 1900s Edwardian Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, 14k Gold

Vintage Old European Cut Diamond and Platinum Solitaire Ring
Located in Chipping Campden, GB
This gorgeous ring holds a 90pt old European cut diamond which is G/H colour VS I. The diamond is
Category

Vintage 1950s British Modern Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

Antique 0.59 Carats Old Mine Cut Diamond Solitaire Band
Located in New York, NY
A unisex antique style band showcasing a 0.59 carats old mine cut diamond, secured with six prongs
Category

Vintage 1940s Unknown Art Nouveau Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, 18k Gold, White Gold

Antique Old Mine Cut Diamond Enamel Gold Solitaire Ring
Located in Cairo, EG
Antique Russian blue guilloche enamel ring centered with diamond diameter of 5mm estimate weight
Category

Vintage 1910s Russian Art Deco Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, 14k Gold

Antique Old Mine Cut Diamond Solitaire Ring
Located in Cairo, EG
Antique solitaire ring centered with 1 old mine cut diamond messurments 5.55×4.6mm H color white
Category

Antique 1890s Solitaire Rings

GIA 7.55ct Old European Cut Diamond Solitaire Engagement Ring, Platinum
Located in New York, NY
A platinum solitaire ring with a 7.55-carat GIA-certified old European diamond (K color, VVS2
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Unknown Art Deco Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

Antique Old Mine Cut Diamond on White Gold Solitaire 1900S
Located in Geneva, CH
Antique white gold Solitaire centered by an Old mine cut Diamond 0.45 carat. French assay marks
Category

Antique Early 1900s Art Deco Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, 18k Gold, White Gold

4.62 carat GIA Cert old cut diamond Platinum Solitaire Ring
Located in London, GB
Solitaire old cut diamond ring with diamond set shoulders. Set centrally with a round old cut
Category

Vintage 1910s Edwardian Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

0.88 Old Mine Cut Diamond and Platinum Solitaire Style Ring
Located in Montgomery, AL
This platinum ring is an estate piece. This solitaire style ring features an antique Old Mine cut
Category

Vintage 1920s Art Deco Solitaire Rings

Materials

White Diamond, Platinum

Retro 1.50 Ct Old European Cut Diamond VVS Solitaire Ring
Located in Napoli, IT
quite different from all others Diamond is round old European cut od 1.25 Ct weighted off mount – it in
Category

Vintage 1940s European Retro Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, 18k Gold

Vintage Old Mine Cut Diamond Gold Solitaire
Located in Cairo, EG
Vintage soviet era 14k ring topped with silver flower centered with old mine cut diamond estimate
Category

Vintage 1940s Solitaire Rings

4.84 Carat White Old European Cut Diamond Solitaire Wedding Ring
By Malpani Jewels
Located in Hung Hom, HK
2.58 carat White Old European Cut diamond is set along with 2.26 carat of fancy color rose cut
Category

2010s Hong Kong Art Deco Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Yellow Diamond, 18k Gold

1906 Antique 1.01ct Old Cut Diamond Carved Solitaire Ring 18k
Located in London, GB
spectacular 1.00ct Old Cut Diamond at its centre, with intricately carved shoulders. Dating to 1906, this
Category

Antique Early 1900s European Edwardian Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, 18k Gold

1920s Old Cut 4.01 Carat Diamond Solitaire Ring with Diamond Set Shoulders
Located in London, GB
Solitaire old cut diamond ring with diamond set shoulders. Set to centre with a round old cut
Category

Vintage 1920s Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

Victorian .55 Ct Old Mine Cut Diamond Rare Solitaire Ring
Located in Napoli, IT
decorated with heavy 18 KT solid gold mount centrally set with an Old mine cut Diamond of .55 CT rated as G
Category

Antique Late 19th Century European Etruscan Revival Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, 18k Gold

GIA 1.00ct Old European Cut Diamond Solitaire Ring, VS1 Clarity, Platinum
Located in New York, NY
A vintage-style solitaire ring featuring a GIA-certified 1.00-carat old European cut diamond as the
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Unknown Art Deco Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

Antique Edwardian 0.60 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Solitaire Engagement Ring
Located in Boston, MA
An Edwardian period old European cut diamond solitaire engagement ring. Centered by a 0.60 carat
Category

Early 20th Century Edwardian Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, 14k Gold

Art Deco Engraved 0.52ct Old European Cut Diamond Solitaire Engagement Ring
Located in Boston, MA
A beautiful handmade Art Deco period diamond solitaire engagement ring. Set in a hand engraved
Category

Vintage 1930s Art Deco Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

Antique Old Mine Cut Diamond Solitaire Gold Ring
Located in Cairo, EG
Antique 14k yellow gold ring in solitaire style centered with 1 old mine cut diamond diameter
Category

Antique Early 1900s Solitaire Rings

Antique Old Mine Cut Diamond Solitaire Gold Ring
Located in Cairo, EG
Antique solitaire ring centered with old mine cut diamond estimate weight of 0.70 carats unisex in
Category

Vintage 1910s Solitaire Rings

Vintage 1.29ct Old European Cut Diamond Solitaire Ring, 18k White Gold
Located in New York, NY
A chic vintage diamond solitaire ring showcases a 1.29-carat old European cut diamond, elegantly
Category

Vintage 1980s French Art Deco Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, Gold, White Gold

Antique Old Mine Cut Diamond Gold Solitaire Ring
Located in Cairo, EG
Antique 14k yellow gold solitaire ring unisex in style centered with pear shape old mine cut
Category

Antique Early 1900s Solitaire Rings

18 Karat Gold 7.15 Carat Solitaire Diamond Old European Cut Ring
Located in Firenze, FI
A classic old european cut diamond and 18k white gold , set with a magnificent bright and lively
Category

Early 20th Century Italian Art Deco Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, Gold

Vintage Circa 1970s Platinum Natural Old Cut Diamond Decorated Solitaire Ring
Located in Fatih/İstanbul, 34
In very good condition. Total weight is 4 grams. Totally is diamond 0.62 carat. The diamond is has
Category

Vintage 1970s European Retro Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

18k Gold New Made Natural Old Cut Diamond Decorated Solitaire Ring
Located in Fatih/İstanbul, 34
In very good condition. Total weight is 4.3 grams. Totally is diamond 0.62 carat. The diamond is
Category

2010s Turkish Modern Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, 18k Gold

New Made 18k Gold Natural Old Cut Diamond Decorated Solitaire Ring
Located in Fatih/İstanbul, 34
In very good condition. Total weight is 2.1 grams. Totally is diamond 0.49 ct. The diamond is has H
Category

2010s Turkish Modern Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, 18k Gold

Classic Art Deco Platinum Solitaire Old European Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
Located in Addison, TX
central old-cut gem. Encircling each trio of diamonds is a dainty milgrain pattern, adding a splendid
Category

Vintage 1920s Art Deco Solitaire Rings

Materials

White Diamond, Gold, Platinum

Antique Old Mine Cut Diamond Gold Solitaire Ring
Located in Cairo, EG
Antique 14k gold solitair ring in open work setting centered with 1 old mine cut diamond estimate
Category

Vintage 1910s Solitaire Rings

Art Deco GIA 2.19 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Platinum Solitaire Ring
Located in Beverly Hills, CA
One Art Deco GIA 2.19 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Platinum Solitaire Ring. Featuring one GIA old
Category

Vintage 1920s Art Deco Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Platinum

Old European Cut Diamond 2.24 carats Flanked Solitaire Ring, English, circa 1920
Located in London, GB
Old cut diamond flanked solitaire ring. Set to centre with a round old cut diamond, G colour, SI1
Category

Vintage 1920s Art Deco Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

GIA 17.91 Carat Old Cushion Cut Diamond Solitaire Ring in Platinum
Located in La Jolla, CA
GIA certified 17.91 carat Old Cushion Cut Diamond Solitaire Ring in Platinum Old Cushion Diamond
Category

20th Century North American Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

Old European Cut Diamond Solitaire Ring, 9.62 Carat, I-VS2, circa 1900
Located in Idar-Oberstein, DE
An antique old European cut diamond solitaire ring, ca. 1900. The single diamond weighs 9.62 carats
Category

Antique Early 1900s Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond

1.25 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Solitaire Art Deco Platinum Ring
Located in London, GB
platinum (tested). It is set with an old European cut diamond weighing around 1.25ct with an illusion
Category

Vintage 1920s French Art Deco Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, 18k Gold, Platinum

GIA 1.74 Carat Old Mine Cut Diamond 18k Yellow Gold Solitaire Ring
Located in Beverly Hills, CA
One GIA 1.74 Carat Old Mine Cut Diamond 18k Yellow Gold Solitaire Ring. Featuring one GIA old mine
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Gold, 18k Gold, Yellow Gold

GIA 1.83 Carat Old Mine Cut Diamond 18k Yellow Gold Solitaire Ring
Located in Beverly Hills, CA
One GIA 1.83 Carat Old Mine Cut Diamond 18k Yellow Gold Solitaire Ring. Featuring one old mine cut
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Gold, 18k Gold, Yellow Gold

GIA 2.43 Carat Old European Cut Diamond 18k Yellow Gold Solitaire Ring
Located in Beverly Hills, CA
One GIA 2.43 Carat Old European Cut Diamond 18k Yellow Gold Solitaire Ring. Featuring one GIA old
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Gold, 18k Gold, Yellow Gold

18K Gold & Platinum 1.18ct Old European Cut Diamond Solitaire Open Work Ring
Located in Montclair, NJ
--Stone(s):-- (1) Natural Genuine Diamond - Old European Cut - Bezel Set - L/M Color - VS2/SI1
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, 18k Gold, Platinum

Dated 1927 Art Deco Platinum 1.1Ct Old European Cut Solitaire Diamond Ring
Located in Addison, TX
Finger to Top of Ring: 6.30mm Center Diamond Details: Shape: Old European Cut Carat Weight: 1.1Ct
Category

Vintage 1920s Art Deco Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Gold, Platinum

French GIA 3.21 Carat Old European Cut Diamond 18k Gold Solitaire Ring
Located in Beverly Hills, CA
One French GIA 3.21 Carat Old European Cut Diamond 18k Gold Solitaire Ring. Featuring one GIA old
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Gold, 18k Gold, White Gold, Yellow Gold

Retro 0.74 Carat Old European Cut Solitaire Diamond Gold Ring, circa 1940
Located in Goettingen, DE
Retro 0.74 Carat Old European Cut Solitaire Diamond Gold Ring, circa 1940 This Retro solitaire
Category

Vintage 1940s German Retro Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, Gold, 14k Gold, Yellow Gold

Antique Old Mine Cut Diamond Russian Gold Solitaire Ring
Located in Cairo, EG
Antique 14k Russian old mine cut diamond ring in solitaire style with detailed artnovo work style
Category

Vintage 1910s Solitaire Rings

Old Mine Diamond Solitaire Ring, circa 1900
Located in London, GB
Old mine diamond solitaire ring. Set centrally with a cushion shape old mine diamond, L colour, SI2
Category

Antique Early 1900s Victorian Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, Yellow Gold

New Made 18k Gold Natural Old Cut Diamond And Enamel Solitaire Ring
Located in Fatih/İstanbul, 34
In very good condition. Total weight is 4.2 grams. Totally is 0.43 carat. The diamond is has H
Category

2010s Turkish Modern Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, 18k Gold, Enamel

  • 1
  • ...
Get Updated with New Arrivals
Save "Old Cut Diamond Solitaire", and we’ll notify you when there are new listings in this category.

Old Cut Diamond Solitaire For Sale on 1stDibs

On 1stDibs, you can find the most appropriate old cut diamond solitaire for your needs in our varied inventory. Frequently made of Gold, Platinum and 18k Gold, this item was constructed with great care. Find an antique version now, or shop for 375 vintage or 100 modern creation for a more contemporary example of these cherished accessories. Finding the perfect old cut diamond solitaire may mean sifting through those created during different time periods — you can find an early version that dates to the 19th Century and a newer variation that were made as recently as the 21st Century. For this particular accessory, there are many different carat weights to choose from, but .5 Carat and 1 Carat versions are of considerable interest. There have been many well-made iterations of the classic old cut diamond solitaire over the years, but those made by Hancocks, Single Stone and Antinori Fine Jewels are often thought to be among the most beautiful. See these pages for an old european cut iteration of this accessory, while there are also old mine cut cut and round cut cut versions available here, too. Finding an old cut diamond solitaire for sale for women should be easy, but there are 140 pieces available to browse for unisex as well as men, too.

How Much is an Old Cut Diamond Solitaire?

Prices for an old cut diamond solitaire can differ depending upon size, time period and other attributes — at 1stDibs, these accessories begin at $480 and can go as high as $495,000, while this accessory, on average, fetches $7,838.

Finding the Right Rings for You

Antique and vintage rings have long held a special place in the hearts of fine jewelry lovers all over the world.

No matter their origin or specific characteristics, rings are timeless, versatile accessories. They’ve carried deep meaning since at least the Middle Ages, when diamond rings symbolized strength and other kinds of rings were worn to signify romantic feelings or to denote an affiliation with a religious order. Rings have also forever been emblematic of eternity.

Over time, rings have frequently taken the form of serpents, which have long been associated with eternal life, health and renewal. Italian luxury jewelry house Bulgari has become famous for its widely loved Serpenti motif, for example, and its Serpenti ring, like the other accessories in the collection, began as an homage to jewelry of the Roman and Hellenistic eras. The serpent is now a popular motif in fine jewelry. Jewelry devotees have long pined for rings adorned with reptiles, thanks to antique Victorian rings — well, specifically, Queen Victoria’s illustrious engagement ring, which took the form of a gold snake set with rubies, diamonds and an emerald (her birthstone). Designs for Victorian-era engagement rings often featured repoussé work and chasing, in which patterns are hammered into the metal.

Engagement rings, which are reliably intimidating to shop for, are still widely recognized as symbols of love and commitment. On 1stDibs, a range of buying guides can be found for those in the market for antique engagement ringsvintage engagement rings or Art Deco engagement rings

The most collectible antique engagement rings and vintage engagement rings are those from the Victorian, Edwardian and Art Deco eras. Named for the monarchies of the four King Georges, who in succession ruled England starting in 1714 (plus King William’s reign), antique Georgian rings, be they engagement rings or otherwise, are also coveted by collectors. Pearls, along with colored gemstones like garnets, rubies and sapphires, were widely used in Georgian jewelry. The late-1700s paste jewelry was a predecessor to what we now call fashion or costume jewelry

The Art Nouveau movement (1880–1910) brought with it rings inspired by the natural world. Antique Art Nouveau rings might feature depictions of winged insects and fauna as well as women, who were simultaneously eroticized and romanticized, frequently with long flowing hair. Art Deco jewelry, on the other hand, which originated during the 1920s and ’30s, is by and large “white jewelry.” White metals, primarily platinum, were favored over yellow gold in the design of antique Art Deco rings and other accessories as well as geometric motifs, with women drawn to the era’s dazzling cocktail rings in particular.

Whether you’re hunting down a chunky classic for a Prohibition-themed cocktail party or seeking a clean contemporary design to complement your casual ensemble, find an exquisite collection of antique, new and vintage rings on 1stDibs.

Questions About Old Cut Diamond Solitaire
  • 1stDibs ExpertMay 5, 2023
    How old an old European-cut diamond is varies. The old European cut is a precursor to the modern round brilliant cut. The stone appears circular when looked at from the top (because of its low table or largest facet) and has a high crown (the part above the middle of the stone) with larger facets. The tip of the stone, or the culet, is flat instead of pointed. This style was used predominantly in the 19th century, hence the name. It is best to consult a certified appraiser for assistance with dating and identifying antique jewelry. On 1stDibs, find a variety of European-cut diamond jewelry.
  • 1stDibs ExpertApril 5, 2022
    Mine cut diamonds are up to 300 years ago. Mine cut diamonds were popular around the 18th century during Victorian times and are still in high demand today. You’ll find a wide selection of mine cut diamond jewelry on 1stDibs.
  • 1stDibs ExpertFebruary 22, 2021
    Although old European cut diamonds are often priced lower than modern cuts, due to scarcity, they can sometimes be more valuable than modern cut diamonds.
  • 1stDibs ExpertApril 5, 2022
    Jewelry makers stopped using the old European cut for diamond and other gemstone jewelry around 1930. The style was common during the Art Deco period, but the brilliant cut became popular in the years that followed. On 1stDibs, shop a selection of Old European cut diamond gemstone jewelry.
  • 1stDibs ExpertFebruary 22, 2021
    Because the old mine cut is no longer used on diamonds, diamonds with this cut are rare and so you can often get quite a lot of money for them. Nevertheless, it is still dependent on the quality of the individual diamonds and on the color, clarity, cut and carat number.
  • 1stDibs ExpertAugust 24, 2021
    Yes, old European cut diamonds can be worth more than many other cut diamonds as they are not produced anymore. This cut was developed and popularized between the years 1890 and 1930 and is likely to be found in an antique ring belonging to this period and featuring a round-cut diamond.
  • 1stDibs ExpertFebruary 22, 2021
    Old mine cut diamonds are usually worth less than old european cut diamonds. Because they are generally 10-15% less expensive, they are often larger than other cut diamonds for engagement rings.
  • Like any other diamond, an old mine cut diamond's worth depends on a variety of factors. These factors include the 4C's (color, clarity, cut, carat), the overall beauty and "make" of the stone, the demand, supply, etc. On average however, old mine cuts are typically priced slightly lower (around 5-10%) than modern cut diamonds.