Skip to main content

5 Carat Flawless Diamond

2
to
54
646
31
142
67
57
36
34
31
5
2
1
39
396
252
20
28
84
42
23
49
22
28
47
33
44
39
27
10
8
473
212
2
687
382
348
250
163
100
673
244
125
80
68
111
91
74
60
51
to
Sort By
I FLAWLESS GIA Certified 5 Carats Emerald Cut Diamond Ring Internally Flawless
By Antinori Fine Jewels
Located in Rome, IT
Natural Emerald Cut Diamond weighing 5.14 ct, H in color, Internally Flawless in clarity
Category

2010s Italian Modern Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond

GIA Certified 5 Carat Cushion Cut Diamond Ring FLAWLESS
By Antinori Fine Jewels
Located in Rome, IT
A really amazing diamond. The main stone is certified by GIA E Color white faced FLAWLESS Clarity
Category

2010s Italian Modern Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond

GIA Certified 5 Carat Diamond D COLOR FLAWLESS Clarity Ring
By Antinori Fine Jewels
Located in Rome, IT
An exquisite 5 carat D Color Flawless Clarity emerald cut diamond certified by GIA An investment
Category

2010s Italian Modern Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

EXCEPTIONAL GIA Certified 5 Carat Flawless Fancy Yellow Diamond Ring
By Antinori Fine Jewels
Located in Rome, IT
Introducing a masterpiece of unparalleled beauty and prestige: the 5 carat oval fancy yellow
Category

2010s Italian Modern Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Yellow Diamond, 18k Gold, Platinum

FLAWLESS GIA Certified 5 Carat Asscher Cut Diamond Solitaire Ring
By Antinori Fine Jewels
Located in Rome, IT
An exquisite ring handmade in Italy designed by Antinori Fine Jewels The main stone is a 5 carat
Category

2010s Italian Modern Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, 18k Gold

Flawless D Color GIA Certified 5 Carat Round Brilliant Cut Diamond
By Antinori Fine Jewels
Located in Rome, IT
Flawless D Color GIA Certified 5 Carat Round Brilliant Cut Diamond
Category

2010s Italian Modern Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond

GIA Certified 5 Carat Fancy Yellow Diamond Internally Flawless Clarity Ring
By Antinori Fine Jewels
Located in Rome, IT
Magnificent radiant cut diamond ring is the Highlight of Antinori di Sanpietro ROMA Speechless 5
Category

2010s Italian Modern Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Yellow Diamond, 18k Gold, Yellow Gold, Platinum

Flawless GIA Certified 5 Carat Oval Brilliant Cut Diamond Platinum Ring
By Antinori Fine Jewels
Located in Rome, IT
5.26 ct Oval Brilliant Cut Diamond Solitaire Platinum Engagement Ring Type IIa Ideal Cut. The
Category

2010s Italian Modern Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Platinum

GIA Certified 5 Carat D Color Flawless Radiant Cut Diamond Ring
By Antinori Fine Jewels
Located in Rome, IT
its center, weighing 5 carats. Graded as D color and Flawless clarity by GIA, this diamond is a
Category

2010s Unknown Modern Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, Gold, 18k Gold, White Gold

I Flawless GIA Certified 5 Carat Pear Cut Solitaire Platinum Diamond Ring
By Antinori Fine Jewels
Located in Rome, IT
I FLAWLESS GIA Certified 5 Carat Pear Cut Solitaire Platinum Diamond Ring
Category

2010s Italian Modern Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Platinum

E COLOR FLAWLESS GIA Certified 5 Carat Cushion Tapered Baguette Diamonds Ring
By Antinori Fine Jewels
Located in Rome, IT
An exquisite ring composed by a GIA Certified 5 carat cushion cut diamond with two side tapered
Category

2010s Italian Modern Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, 18k Gold, White Gold

Flawless GIA Certified 5 Carat Emerald Cut Diamond Ring Golconda Type IIA
By Antinori Fine Jewels
Located in Rome, IT
An exquisite flawless GIA certified diamond for investment purposes Color Grade :D Clarity Grade
Category

2010s Italian Modern Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Emerald, Platinum

I Flawless GIA Certified 5 Carat Pear Cut Diamond Solitaire Engagement Ring
By Antinori Fine Jewels
Located in Rome, IT
. The star of the show is a dazzling 5-carat pear-cut diamond, exuding brilliance with its H color and
Category

2010s Italian Modern Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Platinum

GIA Certified 5 Carat Emerald Cut Diamond
By Antinori Fine Jewels
Located in Rome, IT
GIA Certified 5 Carat Emerald Cut Diamond Internally Flawless G COLOR EXCELLENT POLISH EXCELLENT
Category

2010s Unknown Modern Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Emerald, Platinum

GIA Certified Flawless D Color 5.05 Carat Emerald Cut Diamond
By Meghna Jewels
Located in Hoffman Estate, IL
An exquisite 5.05 investment grade diamond certified by GIA. The Emerald cut diamond has Flawless
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Unknown Contemporary Loose Gemstones

Materials

Diamond

GIA Certified 4 Carat Three-Stone Fancy Yellow Oval Cut Diamond Ring Flawless
By Antinori Fine Jewels
Located in Rome, IT
A magnificent three stone diamond ring composed by a 4 carat Oval cut diamond in clarity and Fancy
Category

2010s Italian Modern Three-Stone Rings

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

Emilio Jewelry Gia Certified 5.00 Carat Flawless Fancy Yellow Diamond Ring
By Emilio!
Located in New York, NY
Diamond in the center weighing alone over 5 carats. This diamond is very rare because it has a clarity
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Three-Stone Rings

Materials

Yellow Diamond

GIA Certified 5 Carat Emerald Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
By Antinori Fine Jewels
Located in Rome, IT
dazzling 5-carat emerald-cut diamond, certified by the Gemological Institute of America (GIA). The diamond
Category

2010s Italian Modern Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Emerald, Platinum

GIA Certified 5 Carat Emerald Cut Diamond Solitaire Ring
By Antinori Fine Jewels
Located in Rome, IT
: Immerse yourself in the dazzling brilliance of our stunning 5-carat diamond, meticulously crafted to
Category

2010s Unknown Contemporary Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Emerald, 18k Gold, Gold, White Gold

Emilio Jewelry Gia Certified 28.00 Carat Intense Yellow Flawless Diamond Ring
By Emilio!
Located in New York, NY
Intense Yellow Diamond, Flawless clarity. Please inquire for more images, certificates, details, and any
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Three-Stone Rings

Materials

Yellow Diamond

Emilio Jewelry 2.50 Carat GIA Certified Internally Flawless Pink Diamond Ring
By Emilio!
Located in New York, NY
Main stone: 2.50 carats Color: Fancy Light Brownish Pink Clarity: Internally Flawless Shape: CUT
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Three-Stone Rings

Materials

Pink Diamond

Emilio Jewelry Gia Certified 4.50 Carat Internally Flawless Pink Diamond Ring
By Emilio!
Located in New York, NY
light pink diamond internally flawless heart shape center. Filled with tremendous fire, sparkle and
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Three-Stone Rings

Materials

Pink Diamond

GIA Certified 5 Carat Fancy Yellow Diamond Ring VVS2 Clarity
By Antinori Fine Jewels
Located in Rome, IT
featuring a 5 carat GIA Fancy Yellow Radiant Cut Natural Diamond flanked on either side by phenomenal
Category

2010s Italian Modern Solitaire Rings

Materials

Yellow Diamond, Diamond, White Diamond, 18k Gold

GIA Certified 1.9 Carat Emerald Cut Flawless D Color Diamond Engagement Ring
By Meghna Jewels
Located in Hoffman Estate, IL
An exquisite 1.9 carat exceptional diamond certified by GIA. The Emerald cut diamond has Flawless
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Unknown Contemporary Loose Gemstones

Materials

Diamond

6 Carat Internally Flawless Pear Shaped Diamond Engagement Ring GIA Certified E
Located in New York, NY
CERTIFIED Center Diamond: Carat Weight: 4 Carats Color: E* Clarity: INTERNALLY FLAWLESS -IF Style: PEAR
Category

2010s American Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond

GIA Certified 5 Carat Pear Cut Diamond Pave Engagement Platinum Ring
By Antinori Fine Jewels
Located in Rome, IT
and modern design. **Center Diamond:** The centerpiece of this sophisticated ring is a stunning 5
Category

2010s Italian Modern Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Platinum

GIA Certified 5 Carat Solitaire Round Diamond with pave ring
By Antinori Fine Jewels
Located in Rome, IT
entire design. Crafted with meticulous precision, the setting showcases the central diamond flawlessly
Category

2010s Unknown Contemporary Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, Gold, 18k Gold, White Gold

GIA Certified 5 Carat Blue Sapphire Emerald Cut Diamond Ring
By Antinori Fine Jewels
Located in Rome, IT
magnificent gemstone: 🔹 Weight: 5.21 carats 🔹 Measurements: 9.73 x 8.64 x 6.15 mm 🔹 Cutting: Expertly
Category

2010s Italian Modern Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, Sapphire, Blue Sapphire, Platinum

GIA Certified 5 Carat H VS1 Oval Diamond Engagement Ring "Violet"
Located in New York, NY
symbol of refined luxury. Centered upon a GIA Certified 5 Carat oval cut diamond, this ring is the
Category

2010s American Modern Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond

Golconda Type IIA GIA Certified Flawless D Color 8.09 Carat Pear Cut Diamond
By Meghna Jewels
Located in Hoffman Estate, IL
An exquisite 8.09 investment grade diamond certified by GIA. The Pear brilliant cut diamond has
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Unknown Modern Loose Gemstones

Materials

Diamond

GIA Certified 5 Carat D Color Emerald Cut Diamond Ring TYPE IIA
By Antinori Fine Jewels
Located in Rome, IT
The 5.51 Carat D Color Flawless Emerald Cut Diamond Ring! Elevate your elegance with this
Category

2010s Contemporary Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, Emerald

Natural Diamond Ring 0.51 carats 18 Karat White Gold 5 Diamonds Engagement Ring
Located in Antwerpen, BE
Weight:3.01Grams Gemstone: Natural Diamonds Shape: Round Brilliant Total Carat Weight: 0.51 cts Number of
Category

2010s Belgian Modern Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, 18k Gold, White Gold

Tiffany & Co. Soleste Fancy Internally Flawless Halo Diamond Engagement Ring
By Tiffany & Co.
Located in Rome, IT
condition and recently polished. Ring size is 5 Comes with Box; Pouch GIA Diamond Certificate; Brand
Category

2010s American Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, Yellow Diamond, Platinum

Emilio Jewelry Gia Certified Internally Flawless Pink Diamond Ring
By Emilio!
Located in New York, NY
brownish pink diamond with Internally Flawless clarity just over 2.50 carats alone. We are experts in
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Three-Stone Rings

Materials

Pink Diamond

GIA Certified 5 Carat TW Emerald Cut Diamond Three Stone Platinum Ring
Located in Miami, FL
This exquisite 5 carat total weight engagement ring is crafted to captivate hearts and transcend
Category

2010s North American Modern Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond

Vintage 5 Carats Sapphire and Diamond Cocktail Ring, 18 Karat Gold
Located in Miami, FL
with natural earth-mined diamonds weighing approximately 1 carat in total. These brilliant diamonds
Category

Vintage 1980s Italian Contemporary Cocktail Rings

Materials

Diamond, Sapphire, Gold, 18k Gold

Incredible Platinum 1.50ct GIA D/Internally Flawless Pear Diamond Ring
Located in San Francisco, CA
Internally Flawless clarity. The center diamond is expertly set in a 5 prong setting flanked by a tapered
Category

2010s American Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

1.50 Carat E-F VS Diamonds 18K White Gold 5 Stones Modern Band Ring
By Antinori Fine Jewels
Located in Rome, IT
Presenting the exquisite 1.50 Carat in total, E-F per color VS per Clarity 18K White Gold 5
Category

2010s Italian Modern Band Rings

Materials

Diamond, Yellow Gold, White Gold, 18k Gold, Gold

Natural Diamond 1.00 Carats 18 Karat White Gold 5 Solitaire Engagement Ring
Located in Antwerpen, BE
and refined taste. Adorned with five brilliant natural diamonds totaling 1.00 carats, this ring
Category

2010s Belgian Modern Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, 18k Gold, White Gold

5 Carat Fancy Light Yellow Diamond Three-Stone Engagement Ring, GIA Certified IF
Located in New York, NY
, Radiant-cut diamond. This diamond has been certified by GIA as Internally Flawless, highlighting its
Category

21st Century and Contemporary American Contemporary Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, Yellow Diamond, 18k Gold, Platinum

1.50 Carat E-F VS Diamonds 18K White Gold 5 Stones Classic Half Band Ring
By Antinori Fine Jewels
Located in Rome, IT
Presenting the exquisite 1.50 Carat in total, E-F per color VS per Clarity 18K White Gold 5
Category

2010s Italian Modern Band Rings

Materials

Diamond, Yellow Gold, White Gold, 18k Gold, Gold

Emilio Jewelry Gia Certified Internally Flawless Pear Shape Pink Diamond Ring
By Emilio!
Located in New York, NY
Fifth Avenue, A very special Pink diamond dazzles and stuns weighing just over 2.50 carats. Set with
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Three-Stone Rings

Materials

Pink Diamond

Vintage 1.54 Carat Ruby Diamond Platinum Ring
Located in Beverly Hills, CA
One Vintage 1.54 Carat Ruby Diamond Platinum Ring. Featuring one oval cut ruby of 1.54 carats
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Ruby, Platinum

Mid-Century 2.51 Carat Spinel Diamond Platinum Ring
Located in Beverly Hills, CA
One Mid-Century 2.51 Carat Spinel Diamond Platinum Ring. Featuring one cushion cut spinel of 2.51
Category

Vintage 1920s Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Spinel, Platinum

Vintage 0.89 Carat Sapphire and Diamond Platinum Ring
Located in Beverly Hills, CA
One Vintage 0.89 Carat Sapphire and Diamond Platinum Ring. Featuring one oval mixed cut sapphire of
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Sapphire, Blue Sapphire, Platinum

Vintage GIA 10.03 Carat Pear Cut Diamond Platinum Ring
Located in Beverly Hills, CA
One Vintage GIA 10.03 Carat Pear Cut Diamond Platinum Ring. Featuring one GIA pear cut diamond of
Category

1990s Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Platinum

Anabela Chan Fine Sustainable Jewelry Rose Gold Petite 5 Diamond Ring
Located in London, GB
-finger ring in 14K rose gold, hand-set with 5 petite natural white diamonds of 0.1 carats Size EU 47.5
Category

2010s British Contemporary Band Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, 14k Gold, Rose Gold

Anabela Chan Fine Sustainable Jewelry Rose Gold Petite 5 Diamond Ring
Located in London, GB
-finger ring in 14K rose gold, hand-set with 5 petite natural white diamonds of 0.1 carats Size EU 45.5
Category

2010s British Contemporary Band Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, 14k Gold, Rose Gold

Art Deco 1.75 Carat Total Weight Diamond Platinum Ring
Located in Beverly Hills, CA
One Art Deco 1.75 Carat Total Weight Diamond Platinum Ring. Featuring one old European cut diamond
Category

Vintage 1930s Art Deco Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Platinum

Mid-Century GIA 5.17 Carat Sapphire Diamond Platinum Ring
Located in Beverly Hills, CA
One Mid-Century GIA 5.17 Carat Sapphire Diamond Platinum Ring. Featuring one GIA cushion mixed cut
Category

Vintage 1950s Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Sapphire, Blue Sapphire, Platinum

GIA Certified 0.50 Carat Brilliant Cut, Excellent Natural Diamond
Located in Darmstadt, DE
gifts. 5 C's: Certificate: GIA Carat: 0.50ct Color: D Clarity: FL(Flawless) Cut: Excellent Polish
Category

2010s German Modern Loose Gemstones

Materials

Diamond

0.27 carat Diamond, 14K Gold Star, Constellation Ring
Located in New York, NY
, ensuring durability without compromising elegance. Natural Diamonds: Total Diamond Weight: 0.27 carats—a
Category

2010s American Modern Cluster Rings

Materials

Diamond, 14k Gold

GIA 2.00 Carat Fancy Color Diamond Platinum Three Stone Ring
Located in Beverly Hills, CA
One GIA 2.00 Carat Fancy Color Diamond Platinum Three Stone Ring. Featuring one GIA regular step
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Three-Stone Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Yellow Diamond, Brown Diamond, Platinum

Emilio Jewelry Certified 17.03 Carat Emerald Diamond Ring
By Emilio!
Located in New York, NY
. Based on emerald grading methodology the clarity of the emerald is Internally flawless-vvs1 with no
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Three-Stone Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Emerald, 18k Gold, Platinum

Emilio Jewelry Certified 19.21 Carat Emerald Diamond Ring
By Emilio!
Located in New York, NY
Internally flawless-vvs1 with no imperfections visible to the naked eye. The emeralds are without any
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Three-Stone Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Emerald, 18k Gold, Platinum

Edwardian GIA 0.99 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Platinum Ring
Located in Beverly Hills, CA
One Edwardian GIA 0.99 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Platinum Ring. Featuring one GIA old European
Category

Vintage 1910s Edwardian Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Platinum

Art Deco GIA 2.63 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Platinum
Located in Beverly Hills, CA
One Art Deco GIA 2.63 Carat Old European Cut Diamond Platinum. Featuring one GIA old European cut
Category

Vintage 1930s Art Deco Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Platinum

GIA 3.52 Carat Australian No Heat Sapphire Diamond Platinum Ring
Located in Beverly Hills, CA
One GIA 3.52 Carat Australian No Heat Sapphire Diamond Platinum Ring. Featuring one GIA oval mixed
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Pink Diamond, Sapphire, Blue Sapphire, Platinum

Art Deco GIA 3.35 Carat Old Mine Cut Diamond Ring
Located in Beverly Hills, CA
One Art Deco GIA 3.35 Carat Old Mine Cut Diamond Ring. Featuring one GIA old mine cut diamond of
Category

Vintage 1920s Art Deco Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Platinum

Art Deco GIA 1.16 Carat Transitional Cut Diamond Platinum Ring
Located in Beverly Hills, CA
One Art Deco GIA 1.16 Carat Transitional Cut Diamond Platinum Ring. Featuring one GIA transitional
Category

Vintage 1920s Art Deco Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Platinum

  • 1
  • ...
Get Updated with New Arrivals
Save "5 Carat Flawless Diamond", and we’ll notify you when there are new listings in this category.

5 Carat Flawless Diamond For Sale on 1stDibs

You are likely to find exactly the 5 carat flawless diamond you’re looking for on 1stDibs, as there is a broad range for sale. Frequently made of Platinum, Gold and 18k Gold, this item was constructed with great care. Our collection of these items for sale includes 13 vintage editions and 204 modern creations to choose from as well. Finding the perfect 5 carat flawless diamond may mean sifting through those created during different time periods — you can find an early version that dates to the 20th Century and a newer variation that were made as recently as the 21st Century. As it relates to this specific piece, our collection includes designs that are universally popular, but .5 Carat and 1 Carat carat weights, specifically, are sought with frequency. Finding an appealing 5 carat flawless diamond — no matter the origin — is easy, but Antinori Fine Jewels, J. Birnbach and Paul Spurgeon each produced a popular version that is worth a look. A round cut version of this piece has appeal, but there are also emerald cut and oval cut versions for sale. If you’re browsing our inventory for a 5 carat flawless diamond, you’ll find that many are available today for women, but there are still pieces to choose from for unisex and men.

How Much is a 5 Carat Flawless Diamond?

The price for a 5 carat flawless diamond starts at $1,128 and tops out at $4,450,000 with these rings, on average, selling for $64,384.

Finding the Right Rings for You

Antique and vintage rings have long held a special place in the hearts of fine jewelry lovers all over the world.

No matter their origin or specific characteristics, rings are timeless, versatile accessories. They’ve carried deep meaning since at least the Middle Ages, when diamond rings symbolized strength and other kinds of rings were worn to signify romantic feelings or to denote an affiliation with a religious order. Rings have also forever been emblematic of eternity.

Over time, rings have frequently taken the form of serpents, which have long been associated with eternal life, health and renewal. Italian luxury jewelry house Bvlgari has become famous for its widely loved Serpenti motif, for example, and its Serpenti ring, like the other accessories in the collection, began as an homage to jewelry of the Roman and Hellenistic eras. The serpent is now a popular motif in fine jewelry. Jewelry devotees have long pined for rings adorned with reptiles, thanks to antique Victorian rings — well, specifically, Queen Victoria’s illustrious engagement ring, which took the form of a gold snake set with rubies, diamonds and an emerald (her birthstone). Designs for Victorian-era engagement rings often featured repoussé work and chasing, in which patterns are hammered into the metal.

Engagement rings, which are reliably intimidating to shop for, are still widely recognized as symbols of love and commitment. On 1stDibs, a range of buying guides can be found for those in the market for antique engagement ringsvintage engagement rings or Art Deco engagement rings

The most collectible antique engagement rings and vintage engagement rings are those from the Victorian, Edwardian and Art Deco eras. Named for the monarchies of the four King Georges, who in succession ruled England starting in 1714 (plus King William’s reign), antique Georgian rings, be they engagement rings or otherwise, are also coveted by collectors. Pearls, along with colored gemstones like garnets, rubies and sapphires, were widely used in Georgian jewelry. The late-1700s paste jewelry was a predecessor to what we now call fashion or costume jewelry

The Art Nouveau movement (1880–1910) brought with it rings inspired by the natural world. Antique Art Nouveau rings might feature depictions of winged insects and fauna as well as women, who were simultaneously eroticized and romanticized, frequently with long flowing hair. Art Deco jewelry, on the other hand, which originated during the 1920s and ’30s, is by and large “white jewelry.” White metals, primarily platinum, were favored over yellow gold in the design of antique Art Deco rings and other accessories as well as geometric motifs, with women drawn to the era’s dazzling cocktail rings in particular.

Whether you’re hunting down a chunky classic for a Prohibition-themed cocktail party or seeking a clean contemporary design to complement your casual ensemble, find an exquisite collection of antique, new and vintage rings on 1stDibs.

Questions About 5 Carat Flawless Diamond
  • 1stDibs ExpertSeptember 28, 2021
    A 5-carat diamond’s worth varies depending on the 4Cs of diamond quality – color, cut, clarity and carat. On average, a 5-carat diamond could cost you between $9,600 to $67,500. It is also likely that the price range per carat will be even broader. On 1stDibs, you can find a variety of 5-carat diamond jewelry.