Shop Talk

Peter Suchy’s New England Showroom Is a ‘Vintage Jewelry Museum’

When asked about his beginnings as a jewelry dealer and designer, Peter Suchy is concise and keen to reflect pragmatically on the facts of which he is most proud. Among those facts: He worked at the bench as a repairman and goldsmith for more than 20 years, after which he studied at the Gemological Institute of America.

Suchy has made a niche in antique diamond engagement rings and signed pieces, offering jewelry and watches from brands like Cartier, Bulgari, Tiffany & Co., Rolex and Patek Philippe. One could argue that he is the kind of vintage jewelry dealer that is the backbone of the market, someone who demonstrates expertise and integrity while delivering exceptional fine jewelry to a global client base. 

Peter Suchy spent 20 years as a bench jeweler before getting into the vintage and antique jewelry business. Above: 2.48-carat diamond and platinum engagement ring, 1900, and 2.52-carat diamond, emerald and onyx platinum ring, 1930–39. Top: A 1950s white-gold swirl-link necklace set with 11 carats of diamonds. Images courtesy of Peter Suchy

Suchy’s showroom is situated in a disarmingly unassuming retail building in Stamford, Connecticut. But inside, it is clear why clients have described it as a  “vintage jewelry museum.” The characterization is not hyperbole — the store houses more than 10,000 pieces of vintage, estate and antique jewelry.

Like its owner, the space is devoid of artifice or pretense, with classical American decor featuring curved walnut architraves and overhead Art Deco–style light boxes. This lack of ostentation hints at the taste and refinement of the jewels on offer and reflects a sales philosophy belonging to a bygone era, that the only decoration necessary is the jewelry itself.

Suchy is one of the world’s foremost specialists in vintage and estate jewelry, which he has collected and sold for the past three decades. A perusal of his inventory on 1stdibs reveals a fondness for substantial gemstones of all varieties. Many of his own designs are simple but powerful, with carat weights in the double digits, such as a 30-carat star sapphire ring, a 49-carat citrine pendant and a 20-carat prasiolite ring. Introspective asked him how he goes about designing his eye-popping creations and what advice he has on collecting vintage and antique jewels.

Is there a period of vintage or antique jewelry that is in vogue at the moment?

Art Deco and Edwardian jewelry are both currently very popular. In particular, Tiffany & Co. and Cartier Art Deco jewelry are in high demand — especially rings and earrings — although for me, they are timeless investment styles. I believe that people are beginning to appreciate the quality and distinctive style of vintage jewelry. We are seeing a move away from mass production and back to the handmade art of estate and vintage jewelry. 

Can you talk us through the style of Peter Suchy–designed jewelry? What are the defining aesthetic traits?  

Large gemstones create one-of-a-kind statement pieces — my jewelry designs itself! We start with a gemstone that we have acquired from an estate because we love it, and we let it inspire the design. We try to bring out the beauty of the stones, with the designs made for the important-size gem that goes into it. Each stone is certainly rare in its own right.

How were you introduced to estate jewelry? 

It was my mentor, the renowned jeweler Jack Newstadt, who introduced me to it. As a bench jeweler, I became fascinated by the superior handmade quality and distinct design of vintage jewelry. I remember examining Art Nouveau and Art Deco rings and bracelets and discovering fine hand engraving and detailing on both the front and back of the jewels. Jack was also a gemologist, and I inherited his love for fine diamonds and gemstones. 

For a vintage jewelry expert like you, what makes a piece truly stand out? What are the characteristics that get you excited? 

Peter Suchy
“As a bench jeweler, I became fascinated by the superior handmade quality and distinct design of vintage jewelry,” says Peter Suchy, who is now one of the world’s foremost specialists in vintage and estate jewelry.

Every once in a while, a piece of jewelry will capture the essence of a design period. This is what we are looking for. A great example that we are offering is a Tiffany & Co. Art Deco Colombian emerald ring from the early nineteen hundreds. The high-dome sugarloaf-cabochon-cut emerald is a recognizable and distinctive Art Deco style, as is the handmade setting for the baguette- and trapezoid-cut diamonds.

With so many buyers looking to invest in vintage jewelry by important makers, and substantial gemstones of high quality becoming more and more desirable, what advice would you give to potential clients? 

When shopping for vintage jewelry, always look for distinct designs. Above all, find jewels that you love and are personally attracted to. Listen to your instincts.


Peter Suchy’s Talking Points

Cartier yellow-gold Tank Louis wristwatch, 1970s
Shop Now
Cartier yellow-gold Tank Louis wristwatch, 1970s

“The Cartier Tank watch is always a classic: simple and elegant. Examples are very popular, and this nineteen seventies Tank is no exception. The blue band is set off perfectly against the yellow-gold case. Since listing, it has become one of our most-viewed items.”

Peter Suchy 15.45-carat Ceylon sapphire, diamond and platinum engagement ring, 2010
Shop Now
Peter Suchy 15.45-carat Ceylon sapphire, diamond and platinum engagement ring, 2010

“I have a love for rare and exotic-colored sapphires, and the violet color of this sapphire truly is one of a kind. As many of our stones do, this one came from an estate, though the setting was beyond repair. I wanted to create something more unique than the traditional three-stone ring. Two well-matched brilliant-cut diamonds brought out the brightness of the violet color even more.”

Tiffany & Co. 1.52-carat ruby, diamond and platinum engagement ring, 1910–19
Shop Now
Tiffany & Co. 1.52-carat ruby, diamond and platinum engagement ring, 1910–19

“This ring is an example of Tiffany & Co. at its best. Truly very unique, and not an engagement ring many people would opt for, it exemplifies the crossover between the Art Deco and Edwardian periods. The central ruby is natural with no enhancements and has an incredibly rich color.”

Buccellati 4.16-carat emerald and yellow- and rose-gold cuff bracelet, 1940s
Shop Now
Buccellati 4.16-carat emerald and yellow- and rose-gold cuff bracelet, 1940s

“What can I say about Buccellati? I think this emerald bracelet speaks for itself. It dates back to the nineteen forties. Simply put, it is one of the most beautiful pieces of designer vintage jewelry of its time. Buccellati is known for its incredible craftsmanship and highly detailed designs, and this piece epitomizes those characteristics for me.”

Peter Suchy emerald-cut diamond and platinum engagement ring, 21st century
Shop Now
Peter Suchy emerald-cut diamond and platinum engagement ring, 21st century

“One of the finest pieces we have created is this Art Deco–inspired emerald-step-cut and trapezoid-cut diamond three-stone engagement ring. The setting is handmade and modeled after an original nineteen twenties setting from our inventory.”

Loading next story…

No more stories to load; check out The Study.

No more stories to load; check out The Study.