Items Similar to William Seaward in Defence of William Freeman, on His Trial for Murder - 1846
Want more images or videos?
Request additional images or videos from the seller
1 of 6
William Seaward in Defence of William Freeman, on His Trial for Murder - 1846
About the Item
AUTHOR: SEWARD, William.
TITLE: Argument of William Seaward in Defence of William Freeman, on His Trial for Murder, at Auburn, July 21st and 22nd, 1846.
PUBLISHER: NY: Auburn: H. Oliphant, 1846.
DESCRIPTION: 31pp., with the chart of mental capacities, called “Spencer’s Intellectual Chart”, complete, original stitching.
CONDITION: Lacking yellow(?) wrappers, internally clean and bright, overall VERY GOOD.
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION: We can locate several printings all in 1846 by two different printers with unknown priority though one clearly states “Fourth Edition”. This aside RBH locates only 1 copy by each printer ever appearing at auction 2016 & this printer 1996.
AN EXTREMELY IMPORTANT CASE INFLUENTIAL IN BRINGING THE INSANITY PLEA INTO AMERICAN JURISPRUDENCE.
One of Seward's most "striking" criminal trials. The case "involved the death sentence on a poor imbecile Negro, Freeman, in whose defense Seward made in 1846 one of the most eloquent of his speeches; this he afterwards declared he would have repeated without the alteration of a word." DAB. This is the stated fourth edition, all having been printed in 1846. The "trial, and particularly his defense by former Governor William H. Seward, aroused great excitement because of the plea of insanity" [McDade]. Demonstrating his formidable talents as a trial lawyer in this closing argument, he defends Freeman, a black man accused of murdering a whole family - John Van Nest, his wife [who was pregnant], their child, and her mother. Seward says the slayings, "if a crime at all," are among the worst imaginable. His defense: Freeman is insane. Insanity, he says in this early definition of the term, is a "derangement of the mind, character and conduct, resulting from bodily disease." Seward urges the jury to set aside racial prejudices. "You, gentlemen, have, or ought to have, lifted up your souls above the bondage of prejudices so narrow and so mean as these. The color of the prisoner's skin, and the form of his features, are not impressed upon the spiritual, immortal mind which works beneath. Hold him then to be a MAN." "The case did much to insure a better hearing for the insane who, until then, received small consideration in the courts." - McDade.
REFERENCE: McDade 325 - II Harvard Law Cat. 565 - Sabin 79503.
- Dimensions:Height: 8.25 in (20.96 cm)Width: 5.25 in (13.34 cm)Depth: 0.5 in (1.27 cm)
- Materials and Techniques:
- Place of Origin:
- Period:
- Date of Manufacture:1846
- Condition:Wear consistent with age and use.
- Seller Location:Hillsborough, NJ
- Reference Number:1stDibs: LU6214242185062
About the Seller
5.0
Gold Seller
Premium sellers maintaining a 4.3+ rating and 24-hour response times
Established in 1985
1stDibs seller since 2022
54 sales on 1stDibs
Typical response time: 3 hours
- ShippingRetrieving quote...Shipping from: Hillsborough, NJ
- Return Policy
Authenticity Guarantee
In the unlikely event there’s an issue with an item’s authenticity, contact us within 1 year for a full refund. DetailsMoney-Back Guarantee
If your item is not as described, is damaged in transit, or does not arrive, contact us within 7 days for a full refund. Details24-Hour Cancellation
You have a 24-hour grace period in which to reconsider your purchase, with no questions asked.Vetted Professional Sellers
Our world-class sellers must adhere to strict standards for service and quality, maintaining the integrity of our listings.Price-Match Guarantee
If you find that a seller listed the same item for a lower price elsewhere, we’ll match it.Trusted Global Delivery
Our best-in-class carrier network provides specialized shipping options worldwide, including custom delivery.More From This Seller
View AllTrial of William Dandridge Epes, for the Murder of Francis Adolphus Muir - 1849
Located in Hillsborough, NJ
AUTHOR: EPES, William Dandridge.
TITLE: Trial of William Dandridge Epes, for the Murder of Francis Adolphus Muir, Dinwiddie County, Virginia: Including the Testimony Submitted in t...
Category
Antique 1840s American Books
Materials
Paper
Trial of Moses Parker.... for the Murder of David R. Lambert. NY 1825
Located in Hillsborough, NJ
AUTHOR: PARKER, Moses.
TITLE: Trial of Moses Parker, James Buckland, Joseph Wade, William Walker, Cornelius Holly, Abra Ham Potts and Noah Doremus,... for the Murder of David R. La...
Category
Antique 1820s American Books
Materials
Leather
Report of the Trial of Jason Fairbanks for the Murder of Elizabeth Fales - 1801
Located in Hillsborough, NJ
AUTHOR: FAIRBANKS, Jason.
TITLE: Report of the Trial of Jason Fairbanks, on an Indictment for the Murder of Miss Elizabeth Fales. At the Supreme Court, Holden at Dedham, in the Cou...
Category
Antique Early 1800s American Books
Materials
Paper
Trial of John Fox, for the Murder of John Henry. New-Brunswick, N.J. 1856
Located in Hillsborough, NJ
AUTHOR: FOX, John.
TITLE: Trial of John Fox, for the Murder of John Henry, at the Special Term of the Middlesex over and Terminer, at New-Brunswick, N.J., May, 1856, Containing the...
Category
Antique 1850s American Books
Materials
Paper
John MILTON. A Defence of the People of England. 1692 - FIRST EDITION IN ENGLISH
Located in Hillsborough, NJ
AUTHOR: MILTON, John.
TITLE: A Defence of the People of England, by John Milton: in Answer to Salmasius's Defence of the King.
PUBLISHER: n.p., n.p., 1692.
DESCRIPTION: FIRST EDI...
Category
Antique 1690s British Books
Materials
Leather
Three Of A Kind. The History Of The Murder Of Mrs. Barnaby & Sawtell c.1890's
Located in Hillsborough, NJ
AUTHOR: (ANON) Dr. Graves, Isaac Sawtell, Frank C. Almy.
TITLE: Three Of A Kind. The History Of The Murder Of Mrs. Barnaby - The Sawtell Murder - The Life, Trial, And Confession Of...
Category
Antique 1890s American Books
Materials
Paper
You May Also Like
Antique Map of Asia, 1846
Located in Langweer, NL
Antique map titled 'Asie'. Original antique map of Asia. Source unknown, to be determined.
Artists and Engravers: Alexandre Vuillemin (1812-188...
Category
Antique 19th Century Maps
Materials
Paper
$73 Sale Price
20% Off
Old Colourful Decorative Map of Turkey in Europe, 1846
Located in Langweer, NL
Antique map titled 'Turkey in Europe'. Old map of Turkey in Europe.
This map originates from 'A New Universal Atlas Containing Maps of the various Em...
Category
Antique 1840s Maps
Materials
Paper
$216 Sale Price
20% Off
Colourful Antique Map of Switzerland, 1846
Located in Langweer, NL
Antique map titled 'Switzerland'. Old map of Switzerland.
This map originates from 'A New Universal Atlas Containing Maps of the various Empires...
Category
Antique 1840s Maps
Materials
Paper
$206 Sale Price
20% Off
Decorative Antique Map of Germany, 1846
Located in Langweer, NL
Antique map titled 'Germany'. Old map of Germany.
This map originates from 'A New Universal Atlas Containing Maps of the various Empires, Kingdoms, ...
Category
Antique 1840s Maps
Materials
Paper
$216 Sale Price
20% Off
William Henry Pyne and His Microcosm, Pre-Publication, First Edition
By Harris Myers
Located in valatie, NY
William Henry Pyne and His Microcosm by Harris Myers. Stroud: Sutton Publishing Limited, 1996. Pre-Publication review copy, 1st edition hardcover wi...
Category
20th Century English Books
Materials
Paper
Fraeijlemaborg, Christ, 1846
Located in Langweer, NL
Fraeijlemaborg.' (Fraeylema Castle.) This Castle is situated in the province of Groningen in Slochteren. It was built around 1500 and its first known occupant was Remmert Fraeylema. ...
Category
Antique 19th Century Prints
Materials
Paper
$79 Sale Price
20% Off
Recently Viewed
View AllMore Ways To Browse
Marcantonio Forest
Marcel Breuer D4
Marcel Takahama
Maria Table Bruno
Marilyn Monroe Chair
Mario Bellini Amanta Lounge Chair
Maritime Beacon
Mastercraft Couch
Max Sauze Isoceles
Mazlaghan Rug
Mcm Arches
Mcm Bench
Mcm Cane Chairs
Mcm Fiberglass Chairs
Mechanical Coin Bank
Meissen Boy With Flowers
Meissen Cobalt Vase
Meissen Coffee Set