Skip to main content

Old Mine Emerald

to
39
376
230
198
140
74
521
501
59
58
31
7
164
302
91
32
19
49
18
11
11
3
8
8
2
6
341
220
4
333
54
9
8
8
to
8
6
6
3
2
165
144
41
21
20
19
18
14
6
3
2
1
1
563
2
356
166
Sort By
GIA Certified 3.10 Carat Old Mine Muzo Colombian Emerald & Old Cut Diamond Ring
Located in Miami, FL
are referred to as "Muzo Green" or "Old Mine" emeralds in the trade. Item Details: - Style: 3-Stone
Category

Vintage 1950s European Retro Three-Stone Rings

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, Platinum

2.06 Carat Old Mine Muzo Colombian Emerald & Diamond Halo Split Shank 18k Ring
By Gad & Co.
Located in Miami, FL
2.06 carat Old Mine Colombian Emerald and Diamond Halo with split shank diamond ring in 18K White
Category

2010s Colombian Modern Engagement Rings

Materials

Emerald, Diamond, White Gold, 18k Gold

Spectra Fine Jewelry GRS Certified Colombian Emerald Cocktail Ring
By Spectra Fine Jewelry
Located in New York, NY
renowned Muzo mines. They are formally described as "Muzo green" and known in the trade as "Old Mine
Category

21st Century and Contemporary American Three-Stone Rings

Materials

Emerald, 18k Gold, White Gold

40 Carat Old Mine Colombian Drop Emerald & Baguette Diamond 18K Gold Necklace
By Gad & Co.
Located in Miami, FL
Drop Emerald - Emerald Origin: Colombia - Carat: 17.04 Carats - Cut: Drop (Old Mine) - Color: Green
Category

20th Century Colombian Art Deco Drop Necklaces

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Emerald, 18k Gold, Gold, White Gold

4.26 Carat Vivid Green Colombian Muzo Mine Emerald & Emerald Cut Diamond Ring
By Gad & Co.
Located in Miami, FL
trade as “Old Mine” emeralds” Item Details: - Type: Ring - Metal: 18K White and Yellow Gold - Weight
Category

2010s Colombian Modern Engagement Rings

Materials

Emerald, Diamond, Yellow Gold, White Gold, 18k Gold

Certified 4.75cts Muzo Colombian Emerald Diamond Platinum Ballerina Ring
Located in Miami, FL
Exquisite ballerina style cocktail ring, with a sparkly ballerina & old mine Emerald. Crafted in
Category

Vintage 1980s Unknown Retro Cocktail Rings

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, Platinum

2.66 Carat Vivid Green Minor Oil Muzo Mine Colombian Emerald Floating Necklace
By Gad & Co.
Located in Miami, FL
the trade as “Old Mine” emeralds.  ______________________________ Side Stone Details: ✔ 38 princess
Category

2010s Colombian Contemporary Pendant Necklaces

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, 18k Gold, White Gold, Yellow Gold

Rare Mariposa Vivid Green Muzo Old Mine Colombian Emerald and Diamond Stack Ring
By Gad & Co.
Located in Miami, FL
are formally described as “Muzo Green” (*) and commonly known in the trade as “Old Mine” emeralds
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Colombian Art Deco Cocktail Rings

Materials

Emerald, Diamond, Yellow Gold, White Gold, 18k Gold

Old Mine Colombian Emerald Pearl Cluster Ring
Located in Chicago, IL
Circa 1850 This antique gold ring features a superb old mine Colombian emerald framed by two rows
Category

Antique 1850s Cluster Rings

Materials

Emerald, Pearl, Gold, 14k Gold

Art Deco Old Mine Diamond Emerald Gold Ring
Located in New York, NY
18k gold Art Deco ring, set with emeralds, surrounding a center approx. 1.22ct old mine cut diamond
Category

20th Century Art Deco More Rings

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, Gold

GRS Certified 2.53 Carat Vivid Green Colombian Minor Oil Emerald & Diamond Ring
By Gad & Co.
Located in Miami, FL
Green” (*) and commonly known in the trade as “Old Mine” emeralds” Ring Details: - Metal: 18K White
Category

2010s Colombian Retro Cluster Rings

Materials

Emerald, Diamond, Yellow Gold, White Gold, 18k Gold

Antique Old Mine Cut Diamond Emerald Ruby Gold Pendant
Located in Cairo, EG
natural green emerald stone with a diameter of 7.7mm×6.65mm and 2 old mine cut diamonds each with a
Category

Vintage 1910s Unknown Pendant Necklaces

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, Ruby, 14k Gold

2.72CT GRS Certified Minor Oil Muzo Green Colombian Emerald Pendant Necklace
By Gad & Co.
Located in Miami, FL
commonly known in the trade as “Old Mine” emeralds” Item Details: - Metal: 18K White Gold - Weight: 4.29
Category

2010s Colombian Art Deco Pendant Necklaces

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, 18k Gold, White Gold

Art Deco French old mine cut diamond emerald platinum ring
Located in Beverly Hills, CA
Crafted in the 1930s, this French Art Deco ring showcases a striking combination of 8 old mine cut
Category

Vintage 1930s Art Deco Cocktail Rings

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, Platinum

Antique Old Mine Cut Diamond and Emerald Ring, circa 1920
Located in London, GB
Old mine diamond and emerald ring. Set with one central cushion shape old mine diamond in an open
Category

Vintage 1920s Unknown Edwardian Cluster Rings

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, Platinum

GIA Certified 2.76 Carat Minor Oil Muzo Colombian Emerald & Diamond Pendant
By Gad & Co.
Located in Miami, FL
. They are formally described as "Muzo Green" and commonly known in the trade as "Old Mine" emeralds
Category

2010s Colombian Art Deco Pendant Necklaces

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, 18k Gold, White Gold, Yellow Gold

Art Deco GIA 1.51 carat old mine diamond emerald platinum ring
Located in Beverly Hills, CA
This Art Deco platinum ring sparkles with a GIA-certified 1.51 carat old mine diamond, accented by
Category

Vintage 1930s Art Deco Cocktail Rings

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, Platinum

1.50 Carat Old Mine Cut Diamond Emerald Platinum Engagement Ring
Located in Beverly Hills, CA
A beautiful estate engagement ring featuring a large old mine cut diamond, approximately 1.50
Category

20th Century American Art Deco Bridal Rings

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, Sapphire, Platinum

PANIM 18K Rose Gold Old Mine Cut Diamond & Emerald Ring
By PANIM
Located in Tsim Sha Tsui, Hong Kong
PANIM 18K Rose Gold Old Mine Cut Diamond & Emerald Ring A super 18 karat yellow gold, three stone
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Indian Modern Fashion Rings

Materials

Emerald, White Diamond, Diamond, Rose Gold, Gold, 18k Gold

Art Deco Style Old Mine Cut Green Emeralds Cocktail Ring
By Antinori Fine Jewels
Located in Chicago, IL
! The emeralds are natural, earth-mined stones. The setting is made of solid 14k white gold. The ring
Category

2010s Italian Modern Solitaire Rings

Materials

Emerald, White Diamond, Diamond, 14k Gold

Art Deco Style Emerald Old Mine Cut Diamond Ring
By Antinori Fine Jewels
Located in Chicago, IL
! The setting features spring green natural emeralds meticulously calibre cut to fit the iconically Art
Category

2010s Italian Art Deco Cocktail Rings

Materials

Emerald, White Diamond, Diamond, Yellow Gold, White Gold, 14k Gold

Antique Old Mine Diamond Emerald Sapphire Dome Engagement Ring
By Belrose Estate Jewelers
Located in Santa Barbara, CA
' Cut Emeralds, Sapphires = 3.15 carats total Old Mine Cut Diamonds = 0.10 carats total Ring Size: 6.75
Category

2010s Art Deco Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, Sapphire, Platinum

Art Deco 22.00 Ct Natural Emerald Old Mine Diamond 18 Kt Earrings
Located in Napoli, IT
sway freely Bar link in the middle is set with a couple of old mine Diamonds, four in total for approx
Category

Vintage 1920s European Art Deco Drop Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, 18k Gold

Antique Victorian 18K Rose Gold Old Mine Diamond Emerald Engagement Ring - GIA
Located in Great Neck, NY
Beautiful Antique Victorian 18K Rose Gold Old Mine Diamond and Emerald Engagement Ring. This
Category

Antique 1890s Victorian Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, Gold, 18k Gold, Rose Gold

Art Deco Style Green Emeralds Old Mine Cut Diamond Cocktail Ring
By Antinori Fine Jewels
Located in Chicago, IL
This diamond and emerald ring features natural diamonds and emeralds in a stunning Art Deco style
Category

2010s Italian Art Deco Solitaire Rings

Materials

Emerald, White Diamond, Diamond, 14k Gold

Victorian 1.15 Ct Colombian Emerald ..80 Ct Old Mine Diamond Three Stone pendant
Located in Napoli, IT
silver Set with a fine 1.15 Ct (6.6 x 6.3 mm.) old mine cut natural Emerald Colombian origin, intense
Category

Antique 1880s European Victorian Pendant Necklaces

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, 18k Gold, Silver

Spectra Fine Jewelry GRS Certified Colombian Emerald Diamond Earrings
By Spectra Fine Jewelry
Located in New York, NY
. They are formally described as “Muzo Green” and commonly known in the trade as “Old Mine” emeralds. The
Category

21st Century and Contemporary American Drop Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, 18k Gold, White Gold

Antique Art Deco 1920s 1.50 Carat Old Mine Cut Diamond Target Ring with Emeralds
Located in New York, NY
Finely crafted in platinum featuring a center Old Mine cut Diamond weighing approximately 1.50
Category

Vintage 1920s Art Deco Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, Platinum

Art Deco Old Mine Diamond Emerald Pendant Necklace Filigree 14K White Gold
Located in New York, NY
Mine Diamonds and fine green Emeralds. The sparkling white Old Mine Cut Diamonds are absolutely
Category

Early 20th Century Unknown Art Deco Pendant Necklaces

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, Gold, White Gold, 14k Gold

Necklace and pendant with emerald and old mine cut diamond 14k gold and silver
Located in The Hague, ZH
14k rose gold necklace with a rose gold and silver pendant set with emerald and old mine cut
Category

Antique 1880s Dutch Early Victorian Pendant Necklaces

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, 14k Gold, Silver

Ring with emerald 8.11ct and old mine cut diamonds 0.74ct 14k gold and platinum
Located in The Hague, ZH
14k yellow gold and platinum ring set with emerald up to 8.11ct and old mine cut diamond up to
Category

Vintage 1920s Dutch Art Nouveau Cocktail Rings

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, 14k Gold, Platinum

GRS Certified 2.72 Cts Columbian Minor Muzo Emerald Ring. Special Appendix
Located in Hong Kong, HK
legendary colors of "old mine" emeralds called Muzo green. 99% of emeralds are heavily included and goes
Category

2010s Hong Kong Cocktail Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Emerald, Gold, 18k Gold, White Gold

Art Deco Circa 1920s 18k Gold Old Mine Cut Diamond And Emerald Decorated Ring
Located in Fatih/İstanbul, 34
has J-K color and vvs-vs clarity. Totally is emerald 1 ct. Ring size is US 6.2 We can maka any size
Category

Vintage 1920s European Art Deco Three-Stone Rings

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, 18k Gold

Circa 1900s Emerald and Old Mine Diamond Navette Ring
Located in Hicksville, NY
: Weight: 1.00ct total weight Cut: Old Mine brilliant Color: F/G Clarity: VS Type: Natural Finger to Top of
Category

Antique Early 1900s Edwardian Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, Gold, 14k Gold, Yellow Gold

Extraordinary Old Mine Muzo Emerald Heart Cut Diamond Pendant Necklace
Located in Chicago, IL
is exceptional and has been certified by GRS Switzerland as "old mine muzo" please check the appendix!
Category

2010s American Contemporary Choker Necklaces

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, Platinum

2.08 Carat Old Mine Cut Diamond Emerald Platinum Engagement Ring
Located in New York, NY
This stunning platinum ring centers a sparkling EGL certified old mine brilliant diamond that
Category

20th Century Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, Platinum

1920s Drop Shape Natural Unenhanced Emerald Old Mine Diamond Ring
Located in London, GB
Drop shape old mine diamond and emerald ring. Set to the centre with a drop shape old mine diamond
Category

Vintage 1920s Art Deco Three-Stone Rings

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, Yellow Gold, Platinum

Antique Victorian Colombia Emerald, Pearl, & Old Mine Diamond Pendant Circa 1880
Located in Miami, FL
pendant bears a 3.65 carat (approx.) emerald center stone, adorned with 34 old mine and single cut
Category

Antique 19th Century Colombian Victorian Pendant Necklaces

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, Pearl, Silver, Gold

Emilio Jewelry Certified No oil Muzo Old Mine Colombian Emerald Ring
By Emilio!
Located in New York, NY
emeralds, known for the purity of color and texture, and its iconic vivid green has fascinated people for
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Three-Stone Rings

Materials

Emerald

Vintage Emerald and Old Mine Cut Diamond Gold Earrings
Located in Cairo, EG
flanked with old mine cut diamonds estimate weight of 1 carat
Category

Vintage 1960s Dangle Earrings

Vintage 18K Yellow Gold Scrollwork Emerald and Old Mine Cut Diamond Ring
Located in MONTMORENCY, FR
-set emerald of approximately 0.90 carat at its center. Flanking the vibrant green gem are ten old mine
Category

Mid-20th Century French Retro Dome Rings

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, Yellow Gold

Vintage Emerald And Old Mine Cut Diamond Gold Ring
Located in Cairo, EG
with diameter stone 8mm×7.75mm flanked with old mine cut diamonds with estimate weight of 2.5 carars H
Category

Vintage 1980s Cluster Rings

Antique Emerald And Old Mine Cut Diamond Gold Ring
Located in Cairo, EG
old mine cut diaminds estimate weight of 1.5 carats ring was made during soviet era 1930.c
Category

Vintage 1930s Cluster Rings

Antique Old Mine Cut Diamond And Emerald Gold Ring
Located in Cairo, EG
Antique 14k gold ring centered with natural green emerald flanked with large old mine cut diamonds
Category

Vintage 1910s Cluster Rings

Antique Victorian 18K Yellow Gold Old Mine Diamond and Colombian Emerald Ring
Located in Great Neck, NY
Beautiful Antique Victorian 18K Yellow Gold Old Mine Diamond and Colombian Emerald Ring. This
Category

Antique 1890s Victorian Wedding Rings

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, Gold, 18k Gold, Yellow Gold

Antique Emerald And Old Mine Cut Diamond Gold Ring
Located in Cairo, EG
8.45mm flanked with old mine cut diamonds with estimate weight of 1.5 carats H colour vs clearity ring
Category

Vintage 1910s Cocktail Rings

Victorian Marquise Navette Old Cut Diamond & Emerald
Located in beverly hills, CA
This refined and lovely Victorian ring spotlights a vibrant octagon shaped emerald within a navette
Category

Antique 1840s Victorian Cluster Rings

Materials

Diamond, Emerald

1.26 Carat Old-Mine Colombian Emerald Diamond Platinum Three-Stone Ring, GIA
Located in Beverly Hills, CA
antique Colombian stones known in the trade as “old-mine.” Flanking the emerald are two white diamonds
Category

21st Century and Contemporary American Contemporary Fashion Rings

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, Platinum

Platinum Bracelet with 8 Carat Trapeze, Emerald and Old Mine Cut Diamonds
Located in Antwerp, BE
Beautiful 18kt White Gold Bracelet set with 8 Carat Trapeze,Emerald & Old Mine Cut Diamonds
Category

Early 20th Century Art Deco Tennis Bracelets

Materials

Diamond, 18k Gold, White Gold

GIA Emerald Diamond 14K Gold Vintage Earrings Old Mine Certified 8.68 Carats
Located in Sylvania, GA
Old South Jewels proudly presents LUXURY. ANTIQUE GIA CERTIFIED 8.68 CARAT RARE EMERALDS
Category

Antique 19th Century Dangle Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, Gold, 14k Gold

GIA Emerald Necklace Platinum 18K Antique Diamond Old Mine Huge 105.65 Carats!
Located in Sylvania, GA
Old South Jewels proudly presents.... LUXURY. GIA Certified RARE PLATINUM 105.65 CARATS EMERALD
Category

Antique 19th Century Victorian Beaded Necklaces

Materials

Emerald, Diamond, Platinum

Antique Emerald And Old Mine Cut Diamond Gold Dangling Earrings
Located in Cairo, EG
Antique 14k gold earrings with 2 dangling green emerald in pear shape with an estimate emerald
Category

Vintage 1910s Dangle Earrings

Antique Victorian 18K Yellow Gold Emerald Old Mine Diamond Five Stone Ring - GIA
Located in Great Neck, NY
Beautiful Antique Victorian 18K Yellow Gold Emerald Old Mine Diamond Five Stone Ring - GIA. This
Category

Antique 1890s Victorian Three-Stone Rings

Materials

Emerald, Diamond, Yellow Gold, 18k Gold, Gold

Art Deco Platinum Old Mine Marquis Diamond and Emerald Rectangular Ring
Located in Addison, TX
Presenting a Amazing! Art Deco Platinum Old Mine Marquis Diamond and Emerald Rectangular Ring
Category

Vintage 1920s Unknown Art Deco Cocktail Rings

Materials

Platinum

Victorian Earrings Emerald 16 Old Mine Cut Diamonds Blue Enamel 14 Karat Gold
Located in New York, NY
This is a gorgeous pair of Antique Victorian Earrings with Emerald, Old Mine Cut Diamonds and Royal
Category

Antique 19th Century Unknown Victorian Stud Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, Gold, Yellow Gold, Enamel, 14k Gold

14 Karat Yellow Gold Ornate Old Mine Diamond and Emerald Engagement Ring
Located in Hicksville, NY
] Weight: 5.7 grams Diamond Details: .50ct, Natural Diamond, Old Miner brilliant, F color, SI Clarity
Category

Vintage 1960s Unknown Contemporary Engagement Rings

Materials

Yellow Gold

Antique English 15 Carat Gold Old Mine Cut Diamond and Emerald Navette Ring
Located in New Orleans, LA
and old mine cut diamonds weighing approximately 2.24 carats total weight set in 15 carat gold.
Category

Antique 19th Century English Cocktail Rings

Men's Ring with old mine cut diamond up to 0.45ct 14k gold 3.3 grams
Located in The Hague, ZH
14k yellow gold men's ring set with emerald shape old mine cut diamond total approximately 0.45ct
Category

Antique 1880s Dutch Early Victorian Solitaire Rings

Materials

Diamond, 14k Gold

Antique Circa 1900s 18k Gold Natural Old Cut Diamond And Emerald Brooch
Located in Fatih/İstanbul, 34
light yellow and s1-s2-s3 clarity. Totally is emerald 2.28 ct. Please contact for any questions.
Category

Antique Early 1900s European Victorian Brooches

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, 18k Gold

Vintage Circa 1970s 18k Natural Old Cut Diamond And Emerald Tennis Bracelet
Located in Fatih/İstanbul, 34
has H-I color and vs-s1 clarity. Totally is emerald 0.60 carat. Total length is bracelet 16.7 cm. Box
Category

Vintage 1970s European Retro Tennis Bracelets

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, 18k Gold

  • 1
Get Updated with New Arrivals
Save "Old Mine Emerald", and we’ll notify you when there are new listings in this category.

Old Mine Emerald For Sale on 1stDibs

On 1stDibs, you can find the most appropriate old mine emerald for your needs in our varied inventory. Every item for sale was constructed with extraordinary care, often using Gold, Platinum and 18k Gold. You can easily find a 142 antique edition and 26 modern creations to choose from as well. Making the right choice when shopping for an old mine emerald may mean carefully reviewing examples of this item dating from different eras — you can find an early iteration of this piece from the 19th Century and a newer version made as recently as the 21st Century, both of which have proven very popular over the years. As it relates to this specific piece, our collection includes designs that are universally popular, but 1.5 Carat and 2 Carat carat weights, specifically, are sought with frequency. Finding an appealing old mine emerald — no matter the origin — is easy, but Emeralds Maravellous, Thesis Gems and Jewelry and AVGVSTA each produced a popular version that is worth a look. Today, if you’re looking for an old mine cut version of this piece and are unable to find the perfect match, our selection also includes emerald cut and bead alternatives. There aren’t many items for men if you’re seeking an old mine emerald, as most of the options available are for women and unisex.

How Much is an Old Mine Emerald?

On average, an old mine emerald at 1stDibs sells for $8,650, while they’re typically $556 on the low end and $270,000 for the highest priced versions of this item.

The Legacy of Diamond in Jewelry Design

Antique diamond rings, diamond tiaras and dazzling vintage diamond earrings are on the wish lists of every lover of fine jewelry. And diamonds and diamond jewelry are primarily associated with storybook engagements and red-carpet grand entrances — indeed, this ultra-cherished gemstone has a dramatic history on its hands.

From “A Diamond Is Forever” to “Diamonds Are a Girl’s Best Friend,” pop culture has ingrained in our minds that diamonds are the most desired, the most lasting and the most valuable gemstone. But what makes the diamond so special? Each stone — whether it’s rubies, sapphires or another stone — is unique and important in its own right. April babies might claim diamonds for themselves, but just about everyone wants this kind of sparkle in their lives!

There are several factors that set diamonds apart from other stones, and these points are important to our gem education.

Diamonds are minerals. They are made up of almost entirely of carbon (carbon comprises 99.95 percent; the remainder consists of various trace elements). Diamonds are the hardest gemstones, ranking number 10 on the Mohs Hardness Scale. Even its name, diamond, is rooted in the Greek adamas, or unconquerable. The only object that can scratch a diamond is another diamond. Diamonds are formed deep within the earth at very high temperatures (1,652–2,372 degrees Fahrenheit at depths between 90 and 120 miles beneath the earth’s surface) and are carried up by volcanic activity. Diamonds are quite rare, according to the Gemological Institute of America, and only 30 percent of all the diamonds mined in the world are gem quality.

In the 1950s, the Gemological Institute of America developed the 4Cs grading system to classify diamonds: clarity, color, cut and carat weight. Not all diamonds are created equal (there are diamonds, and then there are diamonds). The value of the diamond depends on the clarity (flawless diamonds are very rare but a diamond's value decreases if there are many blemishes or inclusions), color (the less color the higher the grade), cut (how the diamond’s facets catch the light, certain cuts of diamonds show off the stone better than others) and carat weight (the bigger, the better).

When you start shopping for a diamond engagement ring, always prioritize the cut, which plays the largest role in the diamond's beauty (taking the time to clean your diamond ring at least every six months or so plays a role in maintaining said beauty). And on 1stDibs, a range of buying guides can be found for those in the market for antique engagement ringsvintage engagement rings or Art Deco engagement rings

Shop antique and vintage diamond rings, diamond necklaces and other extraordinary diamond jewelry on 1stDibs.  

Questions About Old Mine Emerald
  • 1stDibs ExpertApril 5, 2022
    Mine cut diamonds are up to 300 years ago. Mine cut diamonds were popular around the 18th century during Victorian times and are still in high demand today. You’ll find a wide selection of mine cut diamond jewelry on 1stDibs.
  • 1stDibs ExpertFebruary 22, 2021
    Because the old mine cut is no longer used on diamonds, diamonds with this cut are rare and so you can often get quite a lot of money for them. Nevertheless, it is still dependent on the quality of the individual diamonds and on the color, clarity, cut and carat number.
  • 1stDibs ExpertFebruary 22, 2021
    Old mine cut diamonds are usually worth less than old european cut diamonds. Because they are generally 10-15% less expensive, they are often larger than other cut diamonds for engagement rings.
  • Like any other diamond, an old mine cut diamond's worth depends on a variety of factors. These factors include the 4C's (color, clarity, cut, carat), the overall beauty and "make" of the stone, the demand, supply, etc. On average however, old mine cuts are typically priced slightly lower (around 5-10%) than modern cut diamonds.