Skip to main content

Black Heart Earrings

13
to
58
242
230
356
178
175
109
65
29
14
14
10
8
6
6
4
4
3
3
3
2
2
1
1
1
1
1
25
24
15
15
14
Sort By
V-Mine Versace Valentine Black Heart Earrings
By Versace
Located in Los Angeles, CA
chain drop earrings with heat-shaped pendants with black enamel.
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Italian Contemporary Dangle Earrings

Vintage Yves Saint Laurent Rive Gauche Black Heart Earrings 1980s
By Yves Saint Laurent
Located in Wilmslow, GB
Spectacular Vintage YSL Heart Earrings from the illustrious Rive Gauche line. The heart, the symbol
Category

Vintage 1980s Clip-on Earrings

Dragon Heart Earring 'Single' with Garnet and Black Enamel
By Selda Jewellery
Located in Istanbul, TR
Dragon heart earring (single) with garnet and black enamel by Selda Jewellery Additional
Category

2010s Turkish Modern More Earrings

Materials

Garnet, Rose Gold, Enamel

Dragon Heart Earring 'Single' with Blue Topaz & Black Enamel
By Selda Jewellery
Located in Istanbul, TR
Dragon heart earring (single) with blue topaz & black enamel by Selda Jewellery Additional
Category

2010s Turkish Modern More Earrings

Materials

Topaz, Blue Topaz, Rose Gold, Enamel

Estate Heart Shaped Citrine Black Enamel Diamond 18 KT Earrings
Located in Napoli, IT
heart shaped natural Citrine of beautiful color approx13.6 Ct (12 x 12.5 mm average) set in black
Category

Vintage 1970s Italian Contemporary Dangle Earrings

Materials

Citrine, Diamond, 18k Gold, Enamel

14K White Gold 2.0 Carat Black Heart Shaped Diamond Solitaire Stud Earrings
Located in New York, NY
Indulge in the timeless elegance of 14K white gold with these stunning black heart shaped diamond
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Indian Modern Stud Earrings

Materials

Black Diamond, Diamond, White Gold, 14k Gold

Heart Shape Pink Sapphire Setting Hoop Earrings in 14ct Yellow & Black Gold
Located in London, GB
This stunning single earring is perfect to add to your collection, set 14ct yellow and black gold
Category

2010s British Hoop Earrings

Materials

Sapphire, Pink Sapphire, Gold, Yellow Gold, 14k Gold

Heart Shape Pink Sapphire Setting Hoop Earrings Set in 14ct Yellow & Black Gold
Located in London, GB
These stunning earrings are the perfect pair to add to your collection. These 14ct Yellow and Black
Category

2010s British Hoop Earrings

Materials

Pink Sapphire, Yellow Gold, Gold, 14k Gold

Two Sided Lapis & Black Onyx Heart Earrings in 18 Karat Rose Gold
By Sunita Nahata
Located in Hong Kong, HK
Celebrating the season of love with these cute and dainty heart shaped earrings! The earrings are
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Hong Kong Contemporary Dangle Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Pearl, Lapis Lazuli, Onyx, Blue Sapphire, Gold, 18k Gold, Rose ...

14k Gold Art Deco Style Heart Shape Rubies Diamonds Black Enamel Dangle Earrings
By Tutti Frutti Jewellery
Located in Bangkok, TH
gold, 16 round full cut diamonds and black enamel ,in the lower parts we have 2 Heart Shape Rubies Cabs
Category

2010s Thai Art Deco Dangle Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Ruby, 14k Gold, Enamel

18ct Yellow Gold Black Enamel Hearts Drop Earrings
Located in Cape Town, ZA
Gorgeous Item Attributes Weight: 7.84 gram Metal Colour: Yellow Gold Metal: 18ct Length: 40mm Width: ...
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Dangle Earrings

Materials

Yellow Gold, Enamel

14k Gold Art Deco Style Heart Shape Rubies Diamonds Black Enamel Dangle Earrings
By Tutti Frutti Jewellery
Located in Bangkok, TH
, 20 round full cut diamonds and black enamel ,in the lower parts we have 2 Heart Shape Rubies Cabs
Category

2010s Thai Art Deco Dangle Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Ruby, 14k Gold, White Gold, Enamel

Two Sided White Moonstone & Black Onyx Heart Earrings in 18 Karat Rose Gold
By Sunita Nahata
Located in Hong Kong, HK
Celebrating the season of love with these cute and dainty heart shaped earrings! The earrings are
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Hong Kong Contemporary Dangle Earrings

Materials

Onyx, Diamond, Moonstone, Pearl, Gold, 18k Gold, Rose Gold

Yves Saint Laurent Vintage YSL Red Crystal Heart & Black Enamel Silver Earrings
By Yves Saint Laurent
Located in Portland, OR
These beautiful vintage Yves Saint Laurent earrings feature YSL's signature hearts which were a
Category

Vintage 1980s European Clip-on Earrings

Materials

Crystal, Enamel

Sacred Heart Spider Earrings, MWLC
Located in New York, NY
Long flaming Sacred Heart Earrings with Antique overtones in a modern mash up of styles and periods
Category

21st Century and Contemporary French Drop Earrings

Materials

Gilt Metal

Sacred Heart Spider Earrings, MWLC
Sacred Heart Spider Earrings, MWLC
Free Shipping
W 1 in L 3 in
Black Enamel Heart Studs Petite Earring Stack 14K Gold Contemporary Love
By Five Star Jewelry
Located in Austin, TX
Black represents elegance, restraint, strength, power, and so much more! These petite heart studs
Category

2010s American Contemporary Stud Earrings

Materials

14k Gold, White Gold, Yellow Gold, Enamel, Rose Gold

Iconic Chanel heart clip-on earring, made of black ebony sign. 2CC8
By Karl Lagerfeld for Chanel
Located in Stuttgart, DE
These are the most wanted vintage CHANEL wood heart clip-on earring! Very rare and iconic ear clips
Category

Vintage 1980s French Modern Dangle Earrings

Materials

Gold Plate, Gilt Metal

Iconic Chanel heart clip-on earring, made of black ebony sign. 2CC8
Iconic Chanel heart clip-on earring, made of black ebony sign. 2CC8
Free Shipping
W 1.78 in D 0.6 in Dm 0.79 in L 2.76 in
80s Black/Diamond Rhinestones Gold Toned Drop Heart Shaped Clip-On Earrings
Located in Sheung Wan, HK
- Vintage 80s black and diamond rhinestones in gold toned drop heart shaped clip on earrings
Category

Vintage 1980s Unknown Drop Earrings

Art Deco White and Black Diamonds Heart Shape Dangle Earrings in 18k Rose Gold
Located in Hong Kong, HK
Introducing our stunning Art Deco 18k Rose Gold Heart Shape Dangle earrings, an exquisite piece
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Hong Kong Artisan Dangle Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Black Diamond, 18k Gold, Rose Gold, Rhodium

Vintage Vendome Heart Brooch & Earrings Demi-Parure 1950s
By Vendome
Located in Wilmslow, GB
A terrific signed original VENDOME heart demi-parure dating to the mid century, 1950s. The shocking
Category

Vintage 1950s More Earrings

Black Heart Love Bow Silver Cupid Angel Moonstone Retro Pierced Drop Earrings
Located in Wokingham, England
High quality and handmade. Excellent gift for lady. Wear them on casual, prom, holiday... Material: Cloth, Alloy, Faux stone. Size: 5.8*4.5 cm. Weight: 5 g/ each. _ _ _ Great f...
Category

21st Century and Contemporary British Art Deco Drop Earrings

Givenchy Vintage Chunky Matte Triangle Heart Love Black Gold Hoop Clip Earrings
By Givenchy
Located in Wokingham, England
Very good condition and very unique. Givenchy Signed clearly on the reverse. Very light scratches, barely noticeable. Not any colour loss. Dark ink at back. Size: 5.3*3.8 cm. Weig...
Category

1990s French Artist Drop Earrings

Materials

Gold Plate

Oversized Dangle Black Lucite Clip Earrings with Gilded Heart Inclusions
Located in Atlanta, GA
Impressive Italian Lucite dangling clip-on earrings. Oversized zig-zag shape in true licorice black
Category

Vintage 1980s Italian Modernist Clip-on Earrings

Rossella Ugolini 18K Gold Deco Style Earrings Heart-Shaped Ruby Diamonds Onyx
By Rossella Ugolini
Located in Rome, IT
. Details: Rossella Ugolini Handmade 18 Karats Yellow Gold Deco Style Earrings with Heart-Shaped Ruby and
Category

2010s Italian Art Deco Dangle Earrings

Materials

Onyx, Ruby, Diamond, Gold, 18k Gold, Yellow Gold

Vintage French Crystal Embellished Statement Heart Basket Earrings 1950s
Located in Wilmslow, GB
A pair of French earrings, dramatic yet delicate, gilt baskets, adorned with beautifully colored
Category

20th Century More Earrings

Oversize Valentino Heart Stone Earrings
By Valentino
Located in West Hollywood, CA
Valentino gold-plated oversize heart earrings with oversize black resin bead and glass multicolored
Category

Vintage 1980s Italian Clip-on Earrings

Oversize Valentino Heart Stone Earrings
Oversize Valentino Heart Stone Earrings
Free Shipping
H 2.5 in W 2 in
Black Heart Love Bow Silver Cupid Angel Moonstone Retro Drop Clip On Earrings
Located in Wokingham, England
High quality and handmade. Excellent gift for lady. Wear them on casual, prom, holiday... Material: Cloth, Alloy, Faux stone. Size: 5.8*4.5 cm. Weight: 5 g/ each. _ _ _ Great f...
Category

21st Century and Contemporary British Art Deco Dangle Earrings

Heart Emerald Paris Eiffel Tower Earring Silver Gold
By J DAUPHIN
Located in Los Angeles, CA
Heart Emerald Earring Silver Gold Eiffel Tower J Dauphin J DAUPHIN "LOVE " Silver and Gold
Category

2010s American Contemporary Hoop Earrings

Materials

Emerald, Gold, Silver, Sterling Silver

Vintage Chanel Gripoix Heart Earrings Midnight Blue
By Chanel
Located in Bangkok, TH
Early 1990s Chanel gripoix heart earrings in midnight blue adorned with gold toned interlocking CC
Category

1990s French Clip-on Earrings

18K Gold Gemstone Heart Stud Earrings Gemstone Option
By Oshi Jewels
Located in Bangkok, TH
Gemstone Heart stud Earrings in 18K White Gold, Rose Gold, Yellow Gold. Gemstone option : Abalone
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Thai Modern Stud Earrings

Materials

18k Gold, Rose Gold, White Gold, Yellow Gold

1970s Lea Stein Clip On Heart Earrings
By Lea Stein
Located in Scottsdale, AZ
How Could You Not Love These Adorable Earrings!? Circa 1970's, these Lea Stein heart shaped
Category

Vintage 1970s French Clip-on Earrings

14K Gold Gemstone Heart Stud Earrings Gemstone Option
By Oshi Jewels
Located in Bangkok, TH
Gemstone Heart Stud Earrings is made of 14K solid gold available in three colors of gold and four
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Thai Modern Stud Earrings

Materials

Rose Gold, White Gold, Yellow Gold, 14k Gold

Christian Dior Vintage Crystals Black Double Heart Interlock Gold Clip Earrings
By Christian Dior
Located in Wokingham, England
Very excellent condition. Unique design. Signed at back. 100% Genuine. Rare to find. Size: 2.0*1.3 cm. Weight: 3.0 g/each. _ _ _ Great for everyday wear. Come with velvet pouch ...
Category

Vintage 1980s German Art Deco Clip-on Earrings

Materials

Gold Plate, Enamel

Earrings Clear Quartz & Black Diamonds
Located in Miami, FL
Radiate elegance with these stunning 18kt White Gold Drop Earrings. At their heart, clear quartz
Category

2010s American Contemporary Dangle Earrings

Materials

Black Diamond, Quartz, 14k Gold

Heart Emerald Earring Silver Gold Eiffel Tower J Dauphin
By J DAUPHIN
Located in Los Angeles, CA
Heart Emerald Earring Silver Gold Eiffel Tower J Dauphin J DAUPHIN "LOVE " Silver and Gold
Category

2010s American Contemporary Hoop Earrings

Materials

Emerald, Gold, Silver, 10k Gold, Sterling Silver

Vintage Moschino Gold Heart Earrings 1980s
By Moschino
Located in Wilmslow, GB
A pair of striking vintage Moschino Heart Earrings. Featuring a lustrous gold heart motif framed in
Category

Vintage 1980s Clip-on Earrings

Heart Ruby Earring Eiffel Tower White Gold J Dauphin
By J DAUPHIN
Located in Los Angeles, CA
Heart Ruby Earring Eiffel Tower White Gold J Dauphin J DAUPHIN "LOVE " Silver and Gold earring
Category

2010s American Contemporary Hoop Earrings

Materials

Ruby, White Gold, Gold, 10k Gold

Vintage Heart-Shaped Sunburst 14 Karat Gold Stud Earrings
Located in Rotterdam, NL
These lovely heart-shaped stud earring are made of 14 karat yellow gold. This timeless symbol of
Category

20th Century Contemporary Stud Earrings

Materials

Gold, 14k Gold, Yellow Gold

Heart Ruby Earring Eiffel Tower Silver Gold J Dauphin
By J DAUPHIN
Located in Los Angeles, CA
Heart Ruby Earring Eiffel Tower Silver Gold J Dauphin J DAUPHIN "LOVE " Silver and Gold earring
Category

2010s American Contemporary Hoop Earrings

Materials

Ruby, Gold, Silver, 10k Gold, Sterling Silver

David Webb 18K Yellow Gold Black Enamel, Diamond Studded Heart and Cupid Earring
By David Webb
Located in New York, NY
form of striking black enameled hearts, these exquisite pieces are adorned with shimmering round
Category

20th Century American Modern Clip-on Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Yellow Gold, Platinum, Enamel

Blue Sapphire & Diamond, Heart To Heart Drop Earrings in 18Kt White Gold
Located in Westmount, CA
A pair of heart to heart drop earrings set with natural blue sapphires with a black rhodium accent
Category

2010s Canadian Contemporary Clip-on Earrings

Materials

Blue Sapphire, Diamond, 18k Gold, White Gold

Diana M. 18 kt White Gold Diamond Heart Earrings Containing 5.23 cts
By Diana M. Jewels
Located in New York, NY
18 kt white gold diamond heart earrings containing 5.23 cts tw of black and white diamonds. Diana M
Category

21st Century and Contemporary North American Modern Stud Earrings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Black Diamond, White Gold

Heart Earring White Gold Ruby Eiffel Tower Dangle J Dauphin
By J DAUPHIN
Located in Los Angeles, CA
Heart Earring White Gold Ruby Eiffel Tower Dangle J Dauphin J DAUPHIN "LOVE " White Gold 14 Karat
Category

2010s American Contemporary Hoop Earrings

Materials

Ruby, 14k Gold, White Gold, Yellow Gold

Coomi 18 Karat Vivid Orange with Black Diamonds Heart Studs
By Coomi
Located in Secaucus, NJ
Trinity collection heart-shaped stud earrings set in 18K White Gold with Vivid Orange 0.46ct and
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Thai Contemporary Stud Earrings

Materials

Diamond, White Gold

Rose Flower Shaped Fancy Black & White Diamond Earrings
Located in New York, NY
This early 20th-century rose-shaped black and white diamond earring is a striking testament to the
Category

20th Century Indian Retro Stud Earrings

Materials

White Diamond, Black Diamond, 18k Gold, White Gold

Ella Gafter 16.5mm Black Tahitian Pearl Diamond Earrings
By Ella Gafter
Located in New York, NY
The Tahitian pearl and diamond earrings feature a heart-shape design with mother-of-pearl, lending
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Italian Artist Drop Earrings

Materials

White Diamond, Black Pearl, Diamond, Pearl, 18k Gold, White Gold

Pair of Cartier 1.20 Carat Total Weight Diamond 18k Gold Heart Stud Earrings
By Cartier
Located in Beverly Hills, CA
One Pair of Cartier 1.20 Carat Total Weight Diamond 18k Yellow Gold Heart Stud Earrings. Featuring
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Stud Earrings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Gold, 18k Gold, Yellow Gold

Burnt Color Diamond and Black Color Diamond Natural Earring
By Malpani Jewels
Located in Hung Hom, HK
are studded in this heart shape cute earrings. The earring can be worn together or can be used as a
Category

2010s Hong Kong Art Nouveau Hoop Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Black Diamond, Brown Diamond, 18k Gold

Jean Paul Gaultier Vintage Resin Jewelled Heart Inlaid Clip-On Earrings
By Jean Paul Gaultier
Located in Nice, FR
JEAN PAUL GAULTIER vintage domed resin clip-on earrings featuring a heart inlaid with rhinestone
Category

20th Century French Clip-on Earrings

Naimah Sacred Burning Heart, Corazón Ardiente, Milagros, Statement Earrings
By Naimah
Located in Istanbul, 34
Our love for mingling mythology, legends, and history lit a fire under Burning Heart Milagros. For
Category

21st Century and Contemporary European Modern Clip-on Earrings

Materials

Zircon, 18k Gold, Gold Plate, Vermeil, Sterling Silver

TIFFANY & CO Loving Heart PALOMA PICASSO 18 Kt Yellow Gold Large Earrings, 22 Gm
By Tiffany & Co.
Located in New York, NY
Yellow Gold Loving Heart Earrings These authentic Tiffany & Co earrings are finely crafted from solid 18k
Category

1990s Dangle Earrings

Materials

18k Gold, Yellow Gold

Chilango Pendant Faberge Style Heart Black and White 925 Silver Enamel circonia
Located in Viena, Viena
Chilango pendant Faberge style Heart Black and White 925 silver enamel, approx. 53 x 27 x 21 mm
Category

2010s Stud Earrings

Materials

Silver, Sterling Silver, Enamel

Richard Kerr Hot Pink and Multicolor Heart Jeweled Clip Earrings
By Richard Kerr
Located in Atlanta, GA
. The earrings are set on a black resin background frame with assorted bright colors of hot pink, yellow
Category

Vintage 1980s American Romantic Clip-on Earrings

Moi Joya Gold Diamond and Black Enamel Earring
Located in Lawrenceville, GA
/Vilandi/Polki : 0.26ct 925 Silver Other : Black Enamel The joy of finding the perfect pair of earrings
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Indian Drop Earrings

Materials

Diamond, 14k Gold, Silver, Enamel

Stambolian 18K Gold Black White Diamond Floral Clusters Drop Dangle Earrings
By Stambolian
Located in Boca Raton, FL
Stambolian 18K Gold Black White Diamond Floral Clusters Drop Dangle Earrings These beautiful
Category

21st Century and Contemporary American Contemporary Drop Earrings

Materials

White Diamond, Black Diamond, 18k Gold, Yellow Gold

Chic Reversible Black and White Diamond Earrings in 18kt White Gold
Located in Lugano, CH
rhythm, almost a visual melody that speaks to the heart of the beholder. On the other earring, the design
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Italian Contemporary Hoop Earrings

Materials

White Diamond, Black Diamond, White Gold

4.70 Carats Black Spinel and Diamond Earrings in 18k White Gold
By Zahira Fine Jewellery
Located in Bangkok, TH
and precision characteristic of the Art Deco era. At the heart of these earrings lie the captivating
Category

2010s Thai Art Deco Dangle Earrings

Materials

Diamond, Spinel, Black Spinel, White Gold

MINH LUONG Eternal Knot Peacock Pearl Emerald Black Spinels Gold Single Earring
Located in Chêne-Bourg, CH
earring from the same collection for an asymmetrical look. METAL Ethical 18-carat Solid Black Rhodium
Category

21st Century and Contemporary Swiss Modern Drop Earrings

Materials

Black Spinel, Cultured Pearl, Black Pearl, Pearl, Emerald, Black Diamond...

MINH LUONG Eternal Knot Peacock Pearl Emerald Black Spinels Gold Single Earring
MINH LUONG Eternal Knot Peacock Pearl Emerald Black Spinels Gold Single Earring
Free Shipping
W 0.67 in D 0.36 in Dm 0.36 in L 0.57 in
Italian Diamond Coral and Black Onyx Dangle Earrings, Pair
Located in New York, NY
A very beautiful pair of Italian diamond, coral, black onyx, 18-karat white gold dangle earrings
Category

Early 2000s Italian Dangle Earrings

Materials

Coral, Diamond, Onyx, 14k Gold, 18k Gold

Italian Diamond Coral and Black Onyx Dangle Earrings, Pair
Italian Diamond Coral and Black Onyx Dangle Earrings, Pair
H 2.63 in W 0.38 in D 0.38 in Dm 0.38 in L 2.63 in
12mm Black Mabe Earring in Engraved Sterling Silver
By Stephen Dweck
Located in Lyndhurst, NJ
12mm Black Mabe Earring in Engraved Sterling Silver Stephen’s heart and passion go into each Dweck
Category

21st Century and Contemporary American Artisan Hoop Earrings

Materials

Sterling Silver

  • 1
Get Updated with New Arrivals
Save "Black Heart Earrings", and we’ll notify you when there are new listings in this category.

Black Heart Earrings For Sale on 1stDibs

On 1stDibs, there are many options to choose from in our inventory of black heart earrings. These distinct designs — crafted with great care and often made from gold, 18k gold and white gold — can elevate any look. Our collection of these items for sale includes 70 vintage editions and 45 modern creations to choose from as well. Our collection, which features older pieces for sale from the 20th Century and newer versions made as recently as the 21st Century, has proven very popular over the years. modern and contemporary are consistently popular styles when it comes to black heart earrings. Yves Saint Laurent, Christian Lacroix and Chanel each produced beautiful examples of these items that are worth considering. Browse our collection of 21 diamond versions today to add the perfect touch to your look. A selection of heart cut, round cut and ball cut can be found today on these pages. When shopping our range of black heart earrings, you’ll find that there are less available pieces for men today than there are for women.

How Much are Black Heart Earrings?

Prices for black heart earrings start at $44 and top out at $9,500 with these earrings, on average, selling for $498.

Finding the Right earrings for You

In the United States, ear piercing didn’t really become popular until the 1950s and ‘60s, but our desire for a dazzling pair of vintage earrings has deeper roots than that. In fact, wearing earrings actually goes back thousands of years, and you can find many tangible connections between now and then in how we continue to talk about these treasured accessories.

Women wore ornamental earrings — studs and hoops at the very least — in Ancient Egypt, which is home to mines that are among the earliest sources of emeralds in the world. Emerald earrings are highly prized today, and their quality lies in their rich, saturated color. The highest-quality emeralds are green or bluish-green. Earrings worn by the affluent in early Roman civilizations were set with precious stones such as diamonds and pearls, and a clean-looking pop of pearl on the front of the lobe is as timeless as ever. Hoop earrings are imbued with symbolism and cultural significance for many, and on view in the Metropolitan Museum of Art’s Ancient Near Eastern Art Gallery is a pair of simple gold hoops from Mesopotamia dating to between 2600 and 2500 B.C.

Today, ear piercing is very popular all over the world, and, as a result, it is difficult to overstate how much everyone pines for a good pair of earrings — modernist drop earrings, glamorous Victorian hoops, geometrically complex chandelier earrings, you name it. Sure, jewelry trends and the fashion darlings of social media come and go, but earrings have a staying power that seems impenetrable: The still-strong love affair between British royals and Cartier earrings is more than a century old, glossy 1970s hoops from legacy houses such as Bulgari and Van Cleef & Arpels remain the statement makers they’ve always been and although people have been stacking earrings for many moons, the allure of an expertly mismatched stack of charms and studs still feels fresh and new.

While there is no shortage of modern earring designs to choose from, the classics, like coral earrings, Art Deco–style earrings and diamond drop earrings are still heavy hitters. On 1stDibs, find a wide range of antique, new and vintage earrings today.

Questions About Black Heart Earrings
  • 1stDibs ExpertNovember 1, 2023
    What a black heart necklace symbolizes is a matter of personal interpretation. Traditionally, wearing a black heart pendant is a sign that a person is grieving the loss of a loved one. However, many people today choose to wear the necklaces simply because they like how they look. Find a wide range of necklaces on 1stDibs.
  • 1stDibs ExpertNovember 14, 2023
    To tell if black diamond earrings are real, first examine the surface of the gemstones. Real black diamonds usually have imperfections, while fakes usually appear flawless. Because it can be difficult to identify well-made synthetic gemstones with the naked eye, consider consulting a knowledgeable jeweler, dealer or appraiser for assistance with authentication. Find a variety of black diamond jewelry on 1stDibs.