Skip to main content

Oval Silver Bowl

10
to
96
808
603
904
401
325
259
153
127
89
70
67
60
60
56
55
54
52
39
35
33
31
31
29
26
26
23
23
22
17
15
13
12
10
10
8
8
7
7
7
6
4
3
3
3
3
3
2
2
1
1
1
1
1
1
60
39
17
15
15
Sort By
Silver Austrian Huge Bowl Glass Liner, circa 1900-1910
Located in Vienna, AT
oval silver bowl of finest quality. the bowl has smooth surface / its edged areas (handles
Category

Antique Early 1900s Austrian Art Nouveau Sterling Silver

Materials

Silver

Classic-Style Oval Footed Silver Centerpiece Bowl
By Bragagnolo Argenti
Located in Milan, IT
Refinement and opulence impeccably coexist in this centerpiece bowl, a sublime piece boasting
Category

2010s Italian Centerpieces

Materials

Silver

Imperial Chrysanthemum Sterling Silver Oval Bowl Centerpiece
Located in Surfside, FL
Antique IMPERIAL CHRYSANTHEMUM sterling silver oval bowl centerpiece, patented in 1894 by Gorham
Category

20th Century Coffee and Tea Sets

Materials

Sterling Silver

Antique Silver Oval Serving Bowl with Peacock Handles
Located in Brea, CA
Antique silver oval serving bowl with peacock handles. Weighs 816 grams.
Category

Early 20th Century Serving Bowls

Materials

Silver

1796 Georgian Sterling Silver Pierced Oval Basket Centerpiece Bowl
Located in New York, NY
Beautiful Georgian sterling silver pierced oval basket made in London, Circa 1796. Swing handle
Category

Antique 1790s English George III Sterling Silver

Materials

Silver, Britannia Standard Silver, Sterling Silver

Tiffany & Co Sterling Silver Squash Vine Handle Bowl
By Tiffany & Co.
Located in Washington Depot, CT
Tiffany & Co sterling silver oval bowl with Squash Vine pattern handles. A beautiful sterling
Category

20th Century Silver Bowls

Materials

Sterling Silver

Large Barker Ellis, Menorah Hallmark Silverplate Oval Bowl, Early 20th c
By Barker Ellis Silver Co.
Located in valatie, NY
Large Barker Ellis, Menorah Hallmark Silverplate Oval Bowl. Barker Ellis silver, Birmingham England
Category

Early 20th Century English Sheffield and Silverplate

Materials

Silver Plate

Wonderful Large Oval Sterling Silver Regency Basket Bowl Centerpiece with Handle
Located in Roslyn, NY
A wonderful large oval sterling silver regency basket form bowl centerpiece with moveable handle.
Category

20th Century American Regency Sterling Silver

Materials

Sterling Silver

Hand Wrought Sterling Silver Bowl with Serving Spoon by Lebolt & Co
Located in Brisbane, QLD
There is something very charming about this footed oval bowl and matched sterling serving spoon by
Category

Early 20th Century American Arts and Crafts Silver Bowls

Materials

Silver, Sterling Silver

Georg Jensen Denmark Sterling Silver Centerpiece Bowl 752B by Harald Nielsen
By Harald Nielsen for Georg Jensen
Located in Washington Depot, CT
Georg Jensen Denmark sterling silver Art Deco rolled handle centerpiece bowl by Harald Nielsen 752B
Category

Mid-20th Century Danish Silver Bowls

Materials

Sterling Silver

Wonderful Large Belle Époque 800 Sterling Silver Oval Centerpiece Flower Bowl
Located in Roslyn, NY
A wonderful large belle époque 800 European sterling silver oval centerpiece flower bowl.
Category

20th Century German Belle Époque Sterling Silver

Materials

Sterling Silver

Fossilia Oval Gold Bowl
By Fos Ceramiche
Located in Milan, IT
Inspired by madrepore fossils, this exquisite oval-shaped bowl merges traditional craftsmanship
Category

2010s Italian Porcelain

Materials

Gold

Fossilia Oval Gold Bowl
Fossilia Oval Gold Bowl
H 6.3 in W 9.06 in D 7.49 in
Fossilia Oval Platinum Bowl
By Fos Ceramiche
Located in Milan, IT
This exquisite oval-shaped bowl exemplifies craftsmanship and design innovation. Inspired by the
Category

2010s Italian Porcelain

Materials

Platinum

Fossilia Oval Platinum Bowl
Fossilia Oval Platinum Bowl
H 6.3 in W 9.06 in D 7.49 in
Hand-Hammered Oval Serving Bowl, .800 Silver, Italy, Late 20th Century
By Zaramella Argenti 1
Located in Mt Kisco, NY
Oval serving bowl with rounded sides, entirely hammered by hand to get a special brightness. Made
Category

Late 20th Century Italian Modern Serving Bowls

Materials

Silver

Vintage Sheridan Victorian Style Silver Plated Footed Scalloped Oval Fruit Bowl
Located in Philadelphia, PA
Vintage Sheridan Victorian Style Silver Plated Footed Scalloped Oval Fruit Bowl. Circa Mid 20th
Category

Mid-20th Century Victorian Serving Bowls

Materials

Silver Plate

Very Fine English Sheffield Silver Plated Covered Oval Bowl on Tray
Located in Houston, TX
bowl and the tray the bowl is attached to the tray. It is chased in a scrolling pattern and has an
Category

Antique 1850s English Sheffield and Silverplate

Materials

Silver

Vintage Regency Style Silver Plated Scalloped Oval Serving Platter Fruit Bowl
Located in Philadelphia, PA
Vintage Regency Style Silver Plated Scalloped Oval Serving Platter Fruit Bowl. Circa mid to late
Category

Mid-20th Century Regency Serving Bowls

Materials

Silver Plate

Vintage Victorian Style Grapevine Silver Plated Oval Twin Handle Fruit Bowl
Located in Philadelphia, PA
Vintage Victorian Style Grapevine silver plated oval twin handle fruit bowl. Item features a
Category

Mid-20th Century Victorian Serving Bowls

Materials

Silver Plate

Georg Jensen Sterling Silver 925s Small Oval Candy Bowl Made After 1945
By Georg Jensen
Located in Aarhus C, DK
Candy bowl/centerpiece from Georg Jensen Silver Copenhagen. Small oval bowl made of sterling
Category

Mid-20th Century Danish Mid-Century Modern Sterling Silver

Materials

Sterling Silver

Vintage Ceramic Pottery Oval Bowl
Located in Medina, OH
Beautiful vintage oval decorative bowl. The outside and inside have a unique design and makes its a
Category

Late 20th Century Modern Pottery

Materials

Ceramic

Vintage Ceramic Pottery Oval Bowl
Vintage Ceramic Pottery Oval Bowl
H 4.25 in W 16 in D 6.5 in
15 in - Sterling Silver Gorham Antique Floral Repousse Oval Serving Bowl
By Gorham
Located in Brooklyn, NY
Dimensions: 15 x 11 1/8 x 2 3/8 in Weight: 27 toz
Category

Early 20th Century American Serving Bowls

Materials

Sterling Silver

Lalique Oval Flower Centerpiece Bowl
By Lalique
Located in West Palm Beach, FL
Beautiful rare Lalique centerpiece adorned with orchids on each end. This oval shaped centerpiece
Category

20th Century French Centerpieces

Materials

Crystal

 Lalique Oval Flower Centerpiece Bowl
 Lalique Oval Flower Centerpiece Bowl
H 5.25 in W 12 in D 8.5 in
Contemporary Oval Hammered Silver Dish
By William & Son
Located in London, GB
Large and elegant contemporary hammered silver table centrepiece of oval form. The silver dish or
Category

Early 2000s English Modern Centerpieces

Materials

Sterling Silver

Contemporary Oval Hammered Silver Dish
Contemporary Oval Hammered Silver Dish
H 3.25 in W 19.75 in D 14 in
16 in - Sterling Silver Mauser Antique Scroll Openwork Footed Oval Serving Bowl
By The Mauser Manufacturing Co.
Located in Brooklyn, NY
Dimensions: 16 x 13 x 3.75 in Weight: 38 toz
Category

Early 20th Century American Serving Bowls

Materials

Sterling Silver

Victorian Silver Oval Mirrored Plateau
By Stephen Smith
Located in London, GB
This beautiful silver plateau, oval in form, has finely cast and hand-chased classical scenes
Category

Antique 1870s English Victorian Centerpieces

Materials

Sterling Silver

Victorian Silver Oval Mirrored Plateau
Victorian Silver Oval Mirrored Plateau
H 4.75 in W 21.75 in D 18.5 in
10.25 in Sterling Silver S. Kirk & Son Antique Floral Repousse Oval Serving Bowl
By Kirk & Son
Located in Brooklyn, NY
Dimensions: 10.25 x 7.5 x 1.5 in Weight: 10.2 toz
Category

Early 20th Century American Serving Bowls

Materials

Sterling Silver

Oval Basket Bowl - Nymphenburg - Perlservice - Bayerisches Königsservice
By Nymphenburg Porcelain
Located in Stockholm, SE
A large oval basket bowl from the Perl-service. "Bayerisches Königsservice" after design by
Category

Early 20th Century German Rococo Revival Tableware

Materials

Porcelain

Horace Woodward & Co Victorian Sterling Silver Presentation Bowl
By Horace Woodward & Co. Ltd., Edgar Finley & Hugh Taylor
Located in Jesmond, Newcastle Upon Tyne
collection This fine antique sterling silver bowl has an oval spreading form onto a plain oval foot. The
Category

Antique 1890s English Victorian Sterling Silver

Materials

Silver, Sterling Silver

Keller French Silver 20th Century Centerpiece Bowl
By Gustave Keller Freres
Located in New York, NY
Keller, French 0.950 (higher purity than sterling) silver oval-shaped centerpiece bowl with a
Category

20th Century French Sterling Silver

Materials

Silver, Sterling Silver

Edwardian Arts & Crafts Style Sterling Silver Presentation Bowl
By T. Woolley 1
Located in Jesmond, Newcastle Upon Tyne
silver presentation bowl/bowl has a plain oval rounded form onto an oval spreading pedestal foot. The
Category

Antique Early 1900s English Arts and Crafts Sterling Silver

Materials

Silver, Sterling Silver

20th Century Sterling Silver Italian Oval Centerpiece
By Argenterie Lala
Located in VALENZA, IT
Entirely handmade solid sterling silver centerpiece. The shaped and edged oval bowl with a double
Category

1990s Italian Other Sterling Silver

Materials

Sterling Silver

Wakely & Wheeler Antique Sterling Silver Presentation Bowl
Located in Jesmond, Newcastle Upon Tyne
silver bowl, crafted in sterling standard, has a oval form onto an oval domed foot. The large body of
Category

Vintage 1910s British Serving Bowls

Materials

Sterling Silver

Victorian Sterling Silver Cream Jug and Sugar Bowl
By Charles Stuart Harris
Located in Jesmond, Newcastle Upon Tyne
sterling silver cream jug and sugar bowl. Both pieces have an oval boat shaped form onto a collet foot
Category

Antique Late 19th Century English Victorian Sterling Silver

Materials

Silver, Sterling Silver

Oval Bowl with Peasant Scene, Nymphenburg, c. 1775
Located in Greding, DE
Oval bowl with peasant scene, Nymphenburg, c. 1775, pressed mark Rautenschild, incised 6, painting
Category

Antique 1770s German Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Rosenthal, Germany. "Sanssouci", Large Oval Cream-Colored Bowl
Located in Copenhagen, DK
Rosenthal, Germany. "Sanssouci", large oval cream-colored bowl decorated with flowers and gold
Category

Vintage 1930s German Rococo Revival Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Art Nouveau Sterling Silver Enamel Bowl, Usa, 1890
Located in Milan, IT
Art Nouveau oval shaped bowl in sterling silver. Embossed decoration in pure Libertry style
Category

Antique Late 19th Century American Sterling Silver

Materials

Sterling Silver

Austrian Gilt Bronze Crystal Centerpiece Oval Footed Bowl
Located in Toledo, OH
Crystal centerpiece bowl with gilt bronze edge and footed paw base, featuring figural goat and man
Category

20th Century Austrian Gothic Centerpieces

Materials

Crystal, Bronze

KPM Porcelain Hand Painted Oval Bowl, 19th Century
By KPM Porcelain
Located in Lambertville, NJ
Antique 19th century hand painted porcelain with floral and gilt decoration. The bowl with center
Category

Antique 1880s German Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Swedish Art Deco Streamlined Silver Plate Beaded Trophy Bowl
Located in New York, NY
This elegant Art Deco trophy bowl was realized in Sweden in 1924. It offers a sculptural oval body
Category

Vintage 1920s Swedish Art Deco Centerpieces

Materials

Silver Plate

Sterling Silver Three Piece Teaset, Hallmarked:-Chester 1926 & Birmingham:-1927
By Barker Brothers Silver Ltd.
Located in York, GB
Sterling Silver THREE PIECE TEASET - TEAPOT, SUGAR & CREAM All three pieces are by Barker Brothers
Category

Vintage 1920s English Sterling Silver

Materials

Sterling Silver

Eva Englund Orrefors Etched Glass Footed Oval Bowl in Yellow
By Eva Englund
Located in Phoenix, AZ
Etched glass bowl - Overall Foral & Vine pattern. Signed on the bottom - Orrefors Expo v159 - 78
Category

Antique 19th Century Swedish Glass

Materials

Glass

Vintage Seguso Murano Purple Pulegoso Bubble Oval Glass Bowl with Appendages
By Archimede Seguso
Located in North Miami, FL
bowl looks like a mini space ship with the hundreds of tiny bubbles inside that look like silver foil
Category

Vintage 1960s Italian Mid-Century Modern Glass

Materials

Blown Glass

Meissen, Germany. Colossal open lace oval bowl in porcelain.
Located in Copenhagen, DK
Meissen, Germany. Colossal open lace oval bowl. Hand-painted with polychrome flower motifs and
Category

Mid-20th Century German Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

English Silver Plated Bone Handle Four Piece Tea / Coffee Service / Tray
By Sheffield Silver Co.
Located in Tarry Town, NY
, embodying a perfect blend of functionality and aesthetics. The creamer and sugar bowl, featuring silver
Category

Early 20th Century English Art Deco Tea Sets

Materials

Silver Plate

WMF Silverplate Modernist Plate Sigrid Kupetz Design with Small Oval Bowl
By WMF Württembergische Metallwarenfabrik
Located in Ottawa, Ontario
WMF silver plate modernist plate Sigrid Kupetz design with small oval bowl, both by
Category

Vintage 1930s German Aesthetic Movement Sheffield and Silverplate

Materials

Silver Plate

Antique Tiffany & Company Sterling Silver Fern and Flowers Repousse Bowl
By Tiffany & Co.
Located in Cincinnati, OH
This elegant late 19th century sterling silver bowl was made by Tiffany & Company. The silver bowl
Category

Antique 1880s American Late Victorian Sterling Silver

Materials

Silver

20th Century Italian Solid 800 Silver Presentation Bowl, Monteith Style
By Arval Argenti Valenza
Located in VALENZA, IT
A magnificent, refined and imposing Monteith style presentation bowl in Italian 800 silver; This
Category

Vintage 1980s Italian Edwardian Sterling Silver

Materials

Silver

Jens Quistgaard Danish Oval Teak Bowl for Dansk
By Jens Quistgaard
Located in Cincinnati, OH
A darker toned teak wood oval shaped bowl designed by Jens H. Quistgaard who is known for his
Category

Mid-20th Century Danish Mid-Century Modern Serving Bowls

Materials

Teak

Tiffany and Co. Sterling Silver Oval Serving Tray
Located in Houston, TX
Very fine sterling tray with oval shape having tapering and lobed sides. Reticulated open work on
Category

Antique 1890s American Platters and Serveware

Materials

Silver

Celestial Christofle Crystal Centerpiece Bowl On Fitted Silver Stand
By Christofle
Located in New York, NY
, oval bowl with fluted starburst, floral carvings and scalloped lip, nestled within an antique ornate
Category

Antique Late 19th Century French Belle Époque Centerpieces

Materials

Crystal, Silver

Vintage Lenox "Castle Garden" Oval Veggie Serving Bowl
By Lenox's Ceramic Art Company
Located in Malibu, CA
Classic Lenox deep oval server in the "Castle Garden" pattern; from 1970's. This pattern features
Category

Vintage 1970s American American Classical Platters and Serveware

Materials

Porcelain

Royal Copenhagen, Saxon Flower, centerpiece and oval bowl in porcelain
Located in Copenhagen, DK
Royal Copenhagen, Saxon Flower, a centerpiece and oval bowl hand-decorated with polychrome flowers
Category

Early 20th Century Danish Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Antique Victorian Sterling Silver Presentation Bowl by Mappin & Webb
By Mappin & Webb
Located in Jesmond, Newcastle Upon Tyne
A magnificent, fine and impressive antique Victorian English sterling silver presentation bowl; an
Category

Antique 1890s British Victorian Serving Bowls

Materials

Sterling Silver

French 19th Century Louis XVI Style Oval Shaped Centerpiece Bowl
Located in West Palm Beach, FL
An exquisite French 19th century Louis XVI st. Baccarat crystal and ormolu oval shaped centerpiece
Category

Antique 19th Century French Louis XVI Centerpieces

Materials

Crystal, Ormolu

Large Italian .925 Silver Centerpiece Bowl with Four Handles & Marble Base
Located in Los Angeles, CA
A large Italian sterling silver centerpiece bowl with handles & marble base. Italy, circa 1970
Category

Vintage 1970s Italian Organic Modern Centerpieces

Materials

Marble, Silver

Gorham Sterling Silver Plymouth Open Work Bowl with Monogram
By Gorham
Located in Washington Depot, CT
Sterling silver oval dish by Gorham in the Plymouth pattern with monogram, circa 1912. Monogram
Category

20th Century Serving Bowls and Tureens

Materials

Sterling Silver

Antique Silver Bowl Small Fruit Basket with Relief, Openwork Decorative Object
Located in Hampshire, GB
silver oval bon bon dish bowl intricate cut out & embossed details Absolutely stunning sterling silver
Category

Vintage 1930s Swedish Art Deco Sterling Silver

Materials

Silver, Sterling Silver

Oval Silver Plated Monteith Jardinière, French, 19th Century
Located in San Francisco, CA
Oval silver plated Monteith bowl with loop leaf handles. Great as a jardinière or cachepot
Category

Antique 1860s French Neoclassical Sheffield and Silverplate

Materials

Silver Plate

Antique Chinese Export Silver Cream Jug / Creamer and Sugar Bowl
By Sincere & Co.
Located in Jesmond, Newcastle Upon Tyne
. This fine antique Chinese Export Silver (CES) cream jug and sugar bowl have an oval rounded form onto a
Category

Antique Early 1900s Chinese Serving Bowls

Materials

Silver

Viennese Silver Centerpiece Bowl with Handle by Jarosinski & Vaugoin, circa 1925
By Jarosinski & Vaugoin
Located in Vienna, AT
Oval shaped massive silver bowl with movable bow handle. The plan is radially driven, merging into
Category

Antique Early 1900s Austrian Art Nouveau Sterling Silver

Materials

Silver

  • 1
  • ...
Get Updated with New Arrivals
Save "Oval Silver Bowl", and we’ll notify you when there are new listings in this category.

Oval Silver Bowl For Sale on 1stDibs

Find many varieties of an authentic oval silver bowl available at 1stDibs. Each oval silver bowl for sale was constructed with extraordinary care, often using metal, silver and sterling silver. There are 108 variations of the antique or vintage oval silver bowl you’re looking for, while we also have 3 modern editions of this piece to choose from as well. Your living room may not be complete without an oval silver bowl — find older editions for sale from the 18th Century and newer versions made as recently as the 21st Century. An oval silver bowl made by Mid-Century Modern designers — as well as those associated with Modern — is very popular. Georg Jensen, Royal Copenhagen and Seguso Vetri d'Arte each produced at least one beautiful oval silver bowl that is worth considering.

How Much is a Oval Silver Bowl?

The average selling price for an oval silver bowl at 1stDibs is $1,575, while they’re typically $70 on the low end and $32,000 for the highest priced.

Finding the Right dining-entertaining for You

Your dining room table is a place where stories are shared and personalities shine — why not treat yourself and your guests to the finest antique and vintage glass, silver, ceramics and serveware for your meals?

Just like the people who sit around your table, your serveware has its own stories and will help you create new memories with your friends and loved ones. From ceramic pottery to glass vases, set your table with serving pieces that add even more personality, color and texture to your dining experience.

Invite serveware from around the world to join your table settings. For special occasions, dress up your plates with a striking Imari charger from 19th-century Japan or incorporate Richard Ginori’s Italian porcelain plates into your dining experience. Celebrate the English ritual of afternoon tea with a Japanese tea set and an antique Victorian kettle. No matter how big or small your dining area is, there is room for the stories of many cultures and varied histories, and there are plenty of ways to add pizzazz to your meals.

Add different textures and colors to your table with dinner plates and pitchers of ceramic and silver or a porcelain lidded tureen, a serving dish with side handles that is often used for soups. Although porcelain and ceramic are both made in a kiln, porcelain is made with more refined clay and is more durable than ceramic because it is denser. The latter is ideal for statement pieces — your tall mid-century modern ceramic vase is a guaranteed conversation starter. And while your earthenware or stoneware is maybe better suited to everyday lunches as opposed to the fine bone china you’ve reserved for a holiday meal, handcrafted studio pottery coffee mugs can still be a rich expression of your personal style.

“My motto is ‘Have fun with it,’” says author and celebrated hostess Stephanie Booth Shafran. “It’s yin and yang, high and low, Crate & Barrel with Christofle silver. I like to mix it up — sometimes in the dining room, sometimes on the kitchen banquette, sometimes in the loggia. It transports your guests and makes them feel more comfortable and relaxed.”

Introduce elegance at supper with silver, such as a platter from celebrated Massachusetts silversmith manufacturer Reed and Barton or a regal copper-finish flatware set designed by International Silver Company, another New England company that was incorporated in Meriden, Connecticut, in 1898. By then, Meriden had already earned the nickname “Silver City” for its position as a major hub of silver manufacturing.

At the bar, try a vintage wine cooler to keep bottles cool before serving or an Art Deco decanter and whiskey set for after-dinner drinks — there are many possibilities and no wrong answers for tableware, barware and serveware. Explore an expansive collection of antique and vintage glass, ceramics, silver and serveware today on 1stDibs.

Questions About Oval Silver Bowl
  • 1stDibs ExpertJune 30, 2023
    To find out if antique silver punch bowls are worth anything, experts recommend that you consult a certified appraiser. Antique silver punch bowls can be highly sought after and valuable, depending on a variety of factors like how well they are cared for, their origin and maker. Often called the “Queen of metals,” silver has been universally adored for thousands of years. It is easy to see why it has always been sought after: It is durable, strong and beautiful. (Louis XIV had tables made entirely of silver.) Sterling silver is an alloy that is made of 92.5 percent silver — the “925” stamp that identifies sterling-silver jewelry refers to this number. The other 7.5 percent in sterling silver is typically sourced from copper. Although resources can help you find information about a particular piece, an experienced professional is in the best position to determine the value. On 1stDibs, find an assortment of punch bowls.

Read More

Ready for a Cinderella Moment? This Glass Handbag Is a Perfect Fit

Glass slippers might be the stuff of fairytales, but glass handbags? Artist Joshua Raiffe has made them a reality, and they're far less delicate than you might imagine, but just as dreamy.

With Dansk, Jens Quistgaard Delivered Danish Simplicity to American Tables

When a visionary Copenhagen designer teamed up with an enterprising Long Island couple, Scandi-style magic landed in kitchens and dining rooms across the United States.

Hostess Extraordinaire Aerin Lauder Shares Entertaining Tips and Auction Picks

The arbiter of good taste, who has curated a collection for 1stDibs Auctions, invites 1stDibs inside her family’s Hamptons barn for a firsthand look at her welcoming style.

Handmade with Lab-Grade Glass, This Decanter Holds Your Favorite Cocktail Concoctions

Artist Simone Crestani conjures the fascination you remember from Chemistry 101.

28 Cheerful Home Bars, Where Everybody (Literally) Knows Your Name

Simple or sophisticated, equipped with console, cart or custom cabinetry, these stylish bar areas deserve a toast.

Meet the Celebrated Hostess Whose Magical Tabletops Enhance Every Occasion

For Stephanie Booth Shafran, entertaining guests is about opening her heart as well as her home.

How to Identify Real Capodimonte Porcelain

Early examples by the Italian manufacturer can be hard to come by, but the best later pieces possess the same over-the-top charm.

How Noguchi Elevated Ashtrays to Objets d’Art

Smoking might have fallen out of fashion, but these ashtrays have enduring design appeal.