Skip to main content

Wiinblad Christmas Plates

to
22
61
3
64
61
29
20
7
3
1
41
28
1
Sort By
Bjørn Wiinblad Christmas Plate 1972 "Caspar"
By Bjørn Wiinblad, Rosenthal
Located in Brønshøj, DK
Bjørn Wiinblad porcelain Christmas plate 1972, produced by Rosenthal. Motif: The Holy Three Kings
Category

Vintage 1970s German Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Bjørn Wiinblad Christmas Plate 1974 "Balthasar"
By Bjørn Wiinblad, Rosenthal
Located in Brønshøj, DK
Bjørn Wiinblad porcelain Christmas plate 1974, produced by Rosenthal Motif: The Holy Three Kings
Category

Vintage 1970s German Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Bjorn Wiinblad Christmas Plate 1973 "Melchior"
By Bjørn Wiinblad, Rosenthal
Located in Brønshøj, DK
Bjørn Wiinblad porcelain Christmas plate 1973, produced by Rosenthal Motif: Melchior Designed by
Category

Vintage 1970s German Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Bjørn Wiinblad Christmas Plate 1991 "Christmas Carols"
By Bjørn Wiinblad, Rosenthal
Located in Brønshøj, DK
Bjørn Wiinblad porcelain Christmas plate 1991, produced by Rosenthal Motif: Kommet, ihr Hirten
Category

1990s German Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Bjørn Wiinblad Christmas Plate 1986 "Christmas Carols"
By Bjørn Wiinblad, Rosenthal
Located in Brønshøj, DK
Bjørn Wiinblad porcelain Christmas plate 1986, produced by Rosenthal Motif: O Tannenbaum Designed
Category

Vintage 1980s German Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Bjørn Wiinblad Christmas Plate 1984 "Christmas Carols"
By Bjørn Wiinblad, Rosenthal
Located in Brønshøj, DK
Bjørn Wiinblad porcelain Christmas plate 1984, produced by Rosenthal Motif: Jingle Bells Designed
Category

Vintage 1980s German Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Bjørn Wiinblad Christmas Plate 1987 "Christmas Carols"
By Bjørn Wiinblad, Rosenthal
Located in Brønshøj, DK
Bjørn Wiinblad porcelain Christmas plate 1987, produced by Rosenthal Motif: O du fröhliche
Category

Vintage 1980s German Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Bjørn Wiinblad Christmas Plate 1990 "Christmas Carols"
By Bjørn Wiinblad, Rosenthal
Located in Brønshøj, DK
Bjørn Wiinblad porcelain Christmas plate 1990, produced by Rosenthal Motif: Leise rieselt der
Category

1990s German Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Bjørn Wiinblad Christmas Plate 1989 "Christmas Carols"
By Bjørn Wiinblad, Rosenthal
Located in Brønshøj, DK
Bjørn Wiinblad porcelain Christmas plate 1989, produced by Rosenthal Motif: Wer klopfet an
Category

Vintage 1980s German Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Bjørn Wiinblad Christmas plate 1988 "Christmas Carols"
By Bjørn Wiinblad, Rosenthal
Located in Brønshøj, DK
Bjørn Wiinblad porcelain Christmas plate 1988, produced by Rosenthal Motif: Süsser die Glocken nie
Category

Vintage 1980s German Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Bjørn Wiinblad Christmas Plate 1982 "Baptism of Jesus"
By Rosenthal, Bjørn Wiinblad
Located in Brønshøj, DK
Bjørn Wiinblad porcelain Christmas plate 1982, produced by Rosenthal Motif: John the Babtist
Category

Vintage 1980s German Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Bjørn Wiinblad Christmas Plate 1980 "Angel with Bells"
By Rosenthal, Bjørn Wiinblad
Located in Brønshøj, DK
Bjørn Wiinblad porcelain Christmas plate 1980, produced by Rosenthal Motif: The Angel and the
Category

Vintage 1980s German Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Bjørn Wiinblad Christmas plate 1983 "Nativity of Jesus"
By Rosenthal, Bjørn Wiinblad
Located in Brønshøj, DK
Bjørn Wiinblad porcelain Christmas plate 1983, produced by Rosenthal Motif: Silent Night Holy
Category

Vintage 1980s German Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Bjorn Wiinblad Christmas Plate Angel with Harp 1978 Collectible Limited Ed 11 in
By Bjørn Wiinblad, Rosenthal, Bjorn Wiinblad
Located in North Hollywood, CA
Bj0rn Wiinblad Christmas Plate 1978 "Angel with Harp". limited edition 11 inches diameter. Bjørn
Category

Late 20th Century German Baroque Ceramics

Materials

Porcelain

Bjørn Wiinblad Christmas plate 1971 "Mary with baby Jesus"
By Rosenthal, Bjørn Wiinblad
Located in Brønshøj, DK
Bjørn Wiinblad porcelain Christmas plate 1971, produced By Rosenthal. Motif: Maria with the Child
Category

Vintage 1970s German Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Bjørn Wiinblad Christmas plate 1979 "The flight to Egypt"
By Rosenthal, Bjørn Wiinblad
Located in Brønshøj, DK
Bjørn Wiinblad porcelain Christmas plate 1979, produced by Rosenthal Motif: The Flight to Egypt
Category

Vintage 1970s German Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Bjørn Wiinblad Christmas Plate 1976 "Angel of the Trumpet"
By Rosenthal, Bjørn Wiinblad
Located in Brønshøj, DK
Bjørn Wiinblad porcelain Christmas plate 1976, produced by Rosenthal Motif: The Angel and her
Category

Vintage 1970s German Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Bjørn Wiinblad Christmas Plate 1977 "Shepherds Greet the Newborn King"
By Rosenthal, Bjørn Wiinblad
Located in Brønshøj, DK
Bjørn Wiinblad porcelain Christmas plate 1977, produced by Rosenthal Motif: The Herds' arrival
Category

Vintage 1970s German Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Bjørn Wiinblad Christmas plate 1981 "Boy Jesus at the Temple"
By Rosenthal, Bjørn Wiinblad
Located in Brønshøj, DK
Bjørn Wiinblad porcelain Christmas plate 1981, produced by Rosenthal Motif: The Child with the
Category

Vintage 1980s German Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Bjørn Wiinblad Christmas Plate 1975 "Annunciation to the Blessed Virgin Mary"
By Rosenthal, Bjørn Wiinblad
Located in Brønshøj, DK
Bjørn Wiinblad porcelain Christmas plate 1975, produced by Rosenthal Motif: The Proclamation
Category

Vintage 1970s German Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Bjørn Wiinblad Christmas Plate 1985 "The Three Magi Follow the Star"
By Bjørn Wiinblad, Rosenthal
Located in Brønshøj, DK
Bjørn Wiinblad porcelain Christmas plate 1985, produced by Rosenthal Motif: We three kings of
Category

Vintage 1980s German Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Six Crystal Christmas Wall Plates by Bjorn Wiinblad per Rosenthal
By Bjorn Wiinblad, Rosenthal
Located in Milan, Italy
Bjorn Wiinblad for Rosenthal Hand-decorated glass plates in bright colors. With Wiinblad
Category

Vintage 1970s German Modern Decorative Dishes and Vide-Poche

Materials

Crystal

Christmas Songs Plate by Bjorn Wiinblad for Rosenthal from 1977
By Bjorn Wiinblad, Rosenthal
Located in Milan, Italy
Porcelain Christmas plate from 1977 by Bjorn Wiinblad made by the German manufacturer Rosenthal
Category

Vintage 1970s German Modern Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Christmas Songs Plate by Bjorn Wiinblad for Rosenthal from 1980
By Rosenthal, Bjorn Wiinblad
Located in Milan, Italy
Porcelain Christmas plate from 1980 by Bjorn Wiinblad made by the German manufacturer Rosenthal
Category

Vintage 1980s German Modern Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Christmas Songs Plate by Bjorn Wiinblad for Rosenthal from 1986
By Rosenthal, Bjorn Wiinblad
Located in Milan, Italy
Porcelain Christmas plate from 1986 by Bjorn Wiinblad made by the German manufacturer Rosenthal
Category

Vintage 1980s German Modern Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Christmas Songs Plate by Bjorn Wiinblad for Rosenthal from 1988
By Rosenthal, Bjorn Wiinblad
Located in Milan, Italy
Porcelain Christmas plate from 1988 by Bjorn Wiinblad made by the German manufacturer Rosenthal
Category

Vintage 1980s German Modern Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Christmas Songs Plate by Bjorn Wiinblad for Rosenthal from 1983
By Rosenthal, Bjorn Wiinblad
Located in Milan, Italy
Porcelain Christmas plate from 1983 by Bjorn Wiinblad made by the German manufacturer Rosenthal
Category

Vintage 1980s German Modern Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Christmas Songs Plate by Bjorn Wiinblad for Rosenthal from 1990
By Rosenthal, Bjorn Wiinblad
Located in Milan, Italy
Porcelain Christmas plate from 1990 by Bjorn Wiinblad made by the German manufacturer Rosenthal
Category

1990s German Modern Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Christmas Songs Plate by Bjorn Wiinblad for Rosenthal from 1993
By Rosenthal, Bjorn Wiinblad
Located in Milan, Italy
Porcelain Christmas plate from 1993 by Bjorn Wiinblad made by the German manufacturer Rosenthal
Category

1990s German Modern Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Christmas Songs Plate by Bjorn Wiinblad for Rosenthal from 1984
By Rosenthal, Bjorn Wiinblad
Located in Milan, Italy
Porcelain Christmas plate from 1984 by Bjorn Wiinblad made by the German manufacturer Rosenthal
Category

Vintage 1980s German Modern Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Christmas Songs Plate by Bjorn Wiinblad for Rosenthal from 1994
By Rosenthal, Bjorn Wiinblad
Located in Milan, Italy
Porcelain Christmas plate from 1994 by Bjorn Wiinblad made by the German manufacturer Rosenthal
Category

1990s German Modern Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Christmas Songs Plate by Bjorn Wiinblad for Rosenthal from 1991
By Bjorn Wiinblad, Rosenthal
Located in Milan, Italy
Porcelain Christmas plate from 1991 by Bjorn Wiinblad made by the German manufacturer Rosenthal
Category

1990s German Modern Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Christmas Songs Plate by Bjorn Wiinblad for Rosenthal from 1987
By Rosenthal, Bjorn Wiinblad
Located in Milan, Italy
Porcelain Christmas plate from 1987 by Bjorn Wiinblad made by the German manufacturer Rosenthal
Category

Vintage 1980s German Modern Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Christmas Songs Plate by Bjorn Wiinblad for Rosenthal from 1985
By Rosenthal, Bjorn Wiinblad
Located in Milan, Italy
Porcelain Christmas plate from 1985 by Bjorn Wiinblad made by the German manufacturer Rosenthal
Category

Vintage 1980s German Modern Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Christmas Songs Plate by Bjorn Wiinblad for Rosenthal from 1989
By Bjorn Wiinblad, Rosenthal
Located in Milan, Italy
Porcelain Christmas plate from 1989 by Bjorn Wiinblad made by the German manufacturer Rosenthal
Category

Vintage 1980s German Modern Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Set of 3 Bjørn Wiinblad for Rosenthal, Christmas Glass Plates 1976, 1977 & 1980
By Bjørn Wiinblad, Rosenthal
Located in Andernach, DE
Bjorn Wiinblad, Danish artist, has created this beautiful series for German art glass & porcelain
Category

Late 20th Century German Mid-Century Modern Decorative Art

Materials

Crystal

Bjørn Wiinblad for Rosenthal, Christmas Plate in Porcelain from 1987
Located in Copenhagen, DK
Bjørn Wiinblad for Rosenthal. Christmas plate in porcelain from 1987. In good condition. Signed
Category

Vintage 1980s German Modern Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Bjørn Wiinblad for Rosenthal, Christmas Plate in Porcelain from 1989
Located in Copenhagen, DK
Bjørn Wiinblad for Rosenthal. Christmas plate in porcelain from 1989. In good condition. Signed
Category

Vintage 1980s German Modern Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

7 Hand Painted & Signed Bjørn Wiinblad Porcelain Plates for Rosenthal, 1970s
By Bjørn Wiinblad, Rosenthal
Located in Andernach, DE
, '78, '79, 1980, then the last one in this set: 1982. The 7 Christmas plates are made from bisque
Category

Late 20th Century German Mid-Century Modern Decorative Art

Materials

Porcelain

Bjørn Wiinblad for Rosenthal, Christmas plate with a biblical motif. 1972
Located in Copenhagen, DK
Bjørn Wiinblad for Rosenthal, Christmas plate with a biblical motif. 1972 - "Holy King Caspar
Category

Vintage 1970s German Modern Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Bjørn Wiinblad for Rosenthal, Christmas plate with a biblical motif. 1971
Located in Copenhagen, DK
Bjørn Wiinblad for Rosenthal, Christmas plate with a biblical motif. 1971 - "Maria Mit Kind" (Mary
Category

Vintage 1970s German Modern Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Bjørn Wiinblad for Rosenthal, Christmas plate with a biblical motif. 1973
Located in Copenhagen, DK
Bjørn Wiinblad for Rosenthal, Christmas plate with a biblical motif. 1973 - "Heilige 3 Könige
Category

Vintage 1970s German Modern Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Bjørn Wiinblad for Rosenthal. Set of four hand-painted Christmas plates.
Located in Copenhagen, DK
Bjørn Wiinblad for Rosenthal, a set of four hand-painted Christmas plates with biblical motifs
Category

Vintage 1970s German Modern Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Bjørn Wiinblad for Rosenthal. Set of five hand-painted Christmas plates.
Located in Copenhagen, DK
Bjørn Wiinblad for Rosenthal, a set of five hand-painted Christmas plates with biblical motifs
Category

Vintage 1970s German Modern Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Vintage Plate Christmas Carols on Porcelain "Silent night, holy night" Rosenthal
By Rosenthal, Bjorn Wiinblad
Located in Bastogne, BE
Vintage wall plate Christmas Carols on Porcelain: "Silent night, holy night" by ROSENTHAL Germany
Category

Vintage 1980s German Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Grey ceramic table lamp by Bjorn Wiinblad for Rosenthal, Germany 1970s
By Bjorn Wiinblad, Rosenthal
Located in ECHT, NL
plate for Rosenthal. Wiinblad also designed ceramic pieces for Nymolle, a Danish pottery.
Category

Late 20th Century German Mid-Century Modern Table Lamps

Materials

Ceramic, Plastic, Fabric

White & gold Sarastro porcelain box by Bjorn Wiinbland for Rosenthal, 1980s
By Bjørn Wiinblad, Rosenthal
Located in STRASBOURG, FR
. Starting in 1971, he also designed an annual commemorative Christmas plate for Rosenthal. Wiinblad also
Category

Vintage 1980s German Romantic Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Christmas Plates in Glass by Artist Björn Wiinblad
By Bjørn Wiinblad
Located in Brussels, BE
Christmas plates in glass by artist Björn Wiinblad. Rosenthal company. This collection includes
Category

Late 20th Century German Art Deco Decorative Dishes and Vide-Poche

Materials

Glass

Rare Rosenthal Wiinblad Christmas Plate from 1971
Located in Copenhagen, DK
Rare Rosenthal Wiinblad Christmas plate from 1971. 29 cm. in diameter. In perfect condition.
Category

Vintage 1970s German Mid-Century Modern Porcelain

Rare Hand Painted Rosenthal Bjørn Wiinblad Christmas Plate from 1971
Located in Copenhagen, DK
Rare hand painted Rosenthal Bjørn Wiinblad Christmas plate from 1971. "Mary with child". Stamped
Category

Vintage 1970s German Modern Ceramics

Rare Hand Painted Rosenthal Bjørn Wiinblad Christmas Plate from 1972, "Caspar"
Located in Copenhagen, DK
Rare hand painted Rosenthal Bjørn Wiinblad Christmas plate from 1972. "Caspar". Stamped. Measures
Category

Vintage 1970s German Modern Ceramics

Rare Hand Painted Rosenthal Bjørn Wiinblad Christmas Plate from 1973, "Melchior"
Located in Copenhagen, DK
Rare hand painted Rosenthal Bjørn Wiinblad Christmas plate from 1973. "Melchior". Stamped
Category

Vintage 1970s German Scandinavian Modern Ceramics

Anton Michelsen Gilded Silver and Enamel 1972 Christmas Fork by Bjorn Wiinblad
By Anton Michelsen, Bjørn Wiinblad
Located in Los Angeles, CA
A Danish gilded sterling silver and enamel Christmas fork from Anton Michelsen of Copenhagen
Category

Mid-20th Century Danish Mid-Century Modern Sterling Silver

Materials

Silver, Sterling Silver

Bjørn Wiinblad for Rosenthal, Christmas Plate in Porcelain from 1984
Located in Copenhagen, DK
Bjørn Wiinblad for Rosenthal. Christmas plate in porcelain from 1984. In very good condition
Category

Vintage 1980s German Modern Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Bjørn Wiinblad for Rosenthal, Christmas Plate in Porcelain from 1990
Located in Copenhagen, DK
Bjørn Wiinblad for Rosenthal. Christmas plate in porcelain from 1990. In very good condition
Category

1990s German Modern Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Bjørn Wiinblad Brutalist Floor Vase
By Bjørn Wiinblad
Located in Valby, 84
ships, restaurants, Christmas plates and playing cards. In Denmark, he lived in Det Blå Hus, a
Category

Vintage 1960s Danish Scandinavian Modern Vases

Materials

Ceramic

Two Wall-Mounted Collages, by Bjørn Wiinblad Collage and Oil on Plate
Located in Copenhagen, DK
Two wall-mounted collages, by Bjørn Wiinblad (1918-2006) Collage and oil on plate. Signed
Category

Vintage 1980s Danish Scandinavian Modern Decorative Art

Two Wall-Mounted Collages, by Bjorn Wiinblad Collage and Oil on Plate
Located in Copenhagen, DK
Two wall-mounted collages, by Bjorn Wiinblad (1918-2006) Collage and oil on plate. Signed
Category

Vintage 1980s Danish Scandinavian Modern Decorative Art

Bjørn Wiinblad Christmas plate 1978 "Angel with Harp"
By Bjørn Wiinblad, Rosenthal
Located in Brønshøj, DK
Bjørn Wiinblad porcelain Christmas plate 1978, produced by Rosenthal Motif: Angel with Harp
Category

Vintage 1970s German Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

Bjørn Wiinblad for Rosenthal, Christmas Plate in Porcelain from 1983
Located in Copenhagen, DK
Bjørn Wiinblad for Rosenthal. Christmas plate in porcelain from 1983. In good condition. Signed
Category

Vintage 1980s German Modern Porcelain

Materials

Porcelain

  • 1
Get Updated with New Arrivals
Save "Wiinblad Christmas Plates", and we’ll notify you when there are new listings in this category.

Wiinblad Christmas Plates For Sale on 1stDibs

At 1stDibs, there are several options of wiinblad christmas plates available for sale. The range of distinct wiinblad christmas plates — often made from ceramic and porcelain — can elevate any home. Wiinblad christmas plates have been produced for many years, with earlier versions available from the 20th Century and newer variations made as recently as the 20th Century. Wiinblad christmas plates are generally popular furniture pieces, but modern and mid-century modern styles are often sought at 1stDibs. Bjørn Wiinblad and Rosenthal each produced beautiful wiinblad christmas plates that are worth considering.

How Much are Wiinblad Christmas Plates?

Wiinblad christmas plates can differ in price owing to various characteristics — the average selling price at 1stDibs is $169, while the lowest priced sells for $160 and the highest can go for as much as $2,000.

Finding the Right dining-entertaining for You

Your dining room table is a place where stories are shared and personalities shine — why not treat yourself and your guests to the finest antique and vintage glass, silver, ceramics and serveware for your meals?

Just like the people who sit around your table, your serveware has its own stories and will help you create new memories with your friends and loved ones. From ceramic pottery to glass vases, set your table with serving pieces that add even more personality, color and texture to your dining experience.

Invite serveware from around the world to join your table settings. For special occasions, dress up your plates with a striking Imari charger from 19th-century Japan or incorporate Richard Ginori’s Italian porcelain plates into your dining experience. Celebrate the English ritual of afternoon tea with a Japanese tea set and an antique Victorian kettle. No matter how big or small your dining area is, there is room for the stories of many cultures and varied histories, and there are plenty of ways to add pizzazz to your meals.

Add different textures and colors to your table with dinner plates and pitchers of ceramic and silver or a porcelain lidded tureen, a serving dish with side handles that is often used for soups. Although porcelain and ceramic are both made in a kiln, porcelain is made with more refined clay and is more durable than ceramic because it is denser. The latter is ideal for statement pieces — your tall mid-century modern ceramic vase is a guaranteed conversation starter. And while your earthenware or stoneware is maybe better suited to everyday lunches as opposed to the fine bone china you’ve reserved for a holiday meal, handcrafted studio pottery coffee mugs can still be a rich expression of your personal style.

“My motto is ‘Have fun with it,’” says author and celebrated hostess Stephanie Booth Shafran. “It’s yin and yang, high and low, Crate & Barrel with Christofle silver. I like to mix it up — sometimes in the dining room, sometimes on the kitchen banquette, sometimes in the loggia. It transports your guests and makes them feel more comfortable and relaxed.”

Introduce elegance at supper with silver, such as a platter from celebrated Massachusetts silversmith manufacturer Reed and Barton or a regal copper-finish flatware set designed by International Silver Company, another New England company that was incorporated in Meriden, Connecticut, in 1898. By then, Meriden had already earned the nickname “Silver City” for its position as a major hub of silver manufacturing.

At the bar, try a vintage wine cooler to keep bottles cool before serving or an Art Deco decanter and whiskey set for after-dinner drinks — there are many possibilities and no wrong answers for tableware, barware and serveware. Explore an expansive collection of antique and vintage glass, ceramics, silver and serveware today on 1stDibs.

Read More

Ready for a Cinderella Moment? This Glass Handbag Is a Perfect Fit

Glass slippers might be the stuff of fairytales, but glass handbags? Artist Joshua Raiffe has made them a reality, and they're far less delicate than you might imagine, but just as dreamy.

With Dansk, Jens Quistgaard Delivered Danish Simplicity to American Tables

When a visionary Copenhagen designer teamed up with an enterprising Long Island couple, Scandi-style magic landed in kitchens and dining rooms across the United States.

Hostess Extraordinaire Aerin Lauder Shares Entertaining Tips and Auction Picks

The arbiter of good taste, who has curated a collection for 1stDibs Auctions, invites 1stDibs inside her family’s Hamptons barn for a firsthand look at her welcoming style.

Handmade with Lab-Grade Glass, This Decanter Holds Your Favorite Cocktail Concoctions

Artist Simone Crestani conjures the fascination you remember from Chemistry 101.

28 Cheerful Home Bars, Where Everybody (Literally) Knows Your Name

Simple or sophisticated, equipped with console, cart or custom cabinetry, these stylish bar areas deserve a toast.

Meet the Celebrated Hostess Whose Magical Tabletops Enhance Every Occasion

For Stephanie Booth Shafran, entertaining guests is about opening her heart as well as her home.

How to Identify Real Capodimonte Porcelain

Early examples by the Italian manufacturer can be hard to come by, but the best later pieces possess the same over-the-top charm.

How Noguchi Elevated Ashtrays to Objets d’Art

Smoking might have fallen out of fashion, but these ashtrays have enduring design appeal.