Skip to main content
Want more images or videos?
Request additional images or videos from the seller
1 of 5

Domenico Beccafumi
Allegory of Fortune

c. 1510

About the Item

Provenance: S. Spinelli Collection, Florence; their sale, Galleria Pesaro, Milan, July 11-14, 1928, lot 112 (unsold); reoffered Galleria Luigi Bellini, Florence, April 23-26, 1934, lot 132, as manner of Baldassare Peruzzi Dr. Giacomo Ancona, Florence, 1930s, and after 1939, San Francisco; thence by descent to his son: Mario Ancona, San Francisco; thence by descent to his children: Mario Ancona III and Victoria Ancona, San Francisco, until 1995; thence to: Phyllis Ancona Green, widow of Mario Ancona, Los Angeles (1995-2012) Literature: Donato Sanminiatelli, Domenico Beccafumi. Milan 1967, p. 170 (under paintings attributed to Beccafumi) Among the precious survivors of Renaissance secular paintings for domestic interiors are several unusual and particularly attractive panels painted in Siena at the end of the fifteenth and beginning of the sixteenth centuries. These paintings depict exemplary figures from antiquity—heroes or heroines, as well as allegorical, literary, and mythological figures. For the most part, these panels have survived in groups of three, although it is possible that some of these works were painted either as part of larger series or as individual projects. One such trio by Beccafumi consists of two paintings now at the National Gallery, London (Marcia and Tanaquil) and a third in the Galleria Doria-Pamphilj, Rome (Cornelia). These were commissioned around 1517–1519 for the bedroom of Francesco di Camillo Petrucci in Siena and were most likely placed together as elements in the wall decoration (spalliere) or installed above the back of a bench or cassapanca. Another, earlier (ca. 1495–1500), set of three—Guidoccio Cozzarelli’s Hippo, Camilla, and Lucretia (Private Collection, Siena) survives with its original wooden framework—a kind of secular triptych. Judith, Sophonisba, and Cleopatra in the collection of the Monte dei Paschi, Siena, are by an anonymous artist close to Beccafumi called the “Master of the Chigi-Saracini Heroines.” Girolamo di Benvenuto’s Cleopatra, Tuccia, and Portia are dispersed (homeless, Prague, Chambery), and Brescianino’s Faith, Hope, and Charity are in the Pinacoteca Nazionale in Siena. The present painting first appeared in the Spinelli sale in Florence in 1934, at which time it was sold with two panels of identical size and format. Each was catalogued as being by the “manner of Baldassare Peruzzi” and of unidentified subject. Of these, the painting depicting a male figure turned to the right has recently reappeared in a private Italian collection, while the location of the third work, portraying a cloaked figure turned three-quarters left, remains unknown. Our panel depicts the allegorical figure of Fortune. Here she is represented in typical fashion as a nude female figure balanced on a wheel (sometimes called the Rota Fortunae), her billowing drapery indicating that she is as changeable as the wind. The appearance of the Virgin and Child in the cloud at the upper right is an unusual addition to the iconography. The subjects of the two pendant male figures are as yet unidentified, but presumably would represent related allegorical figures. As revealed by the catalogue illustration, our panel had been considerably overpainted at the time of its sale in 1934. Subsequent cleaning has made it far more legible and permitted its quality and authorship to be appreciated. As it at present appears, and has now been confirmed by Prof. Piero Torriti upon first-hand inspection (letter of December 5, 2011) the Allegory of Fortune is an early work by Beccafumi, of the same type (and of similar size) as the three panels mentioned above that were commissioned from the artist by Francesco Petrucci. But while those can be dated to ca. 1517-1519, our panel would most likely have been painted several years earlier. Presumably, but not necessarily, the other two male figures sold from the Spinelli collection in 1934, would have been painted by Beccafumi as well. The three panels are clearly related to another trio given to Beccafumi. This is the group comprising Sophonisba and Cleopatra, both in the Musée Bonnat in Bayonne, and Judith with the Head of Holofernes, in the Wallace Collection, London. The London and Bayonne panels were considered early works of Beccafumi by Berenson (1897, 1932, 1968), Adolfo Venturi (1933) and, Gibellino-Krascenninnicowa in her 1933 monograph on the artist. Subsequently, Pope-Hennessey (1940) rejected the attribution, as did Sanminiatelli (1967), and Baccheschi (1977). However, more recently, the attribution to Beccafumi has been revived by Bagnoli (1990) and convincingly confirmed by Torriti in his catalogue raisonné of Beccafumi’s works (1998). The connection of these two sets of three panels is close enough—formally, stylistically, and physically—to posit whether they once comprised a larger series. However, the unresolved subject matter of the ex-Spinelli panels, and their iconographic relationship to the three representing ancient heroines, makes such a suggestion at present speculative. They are, however, works of a single moment in the artist’s career and have manifest bonds in their portrayal of the subjects as well as the treatment of the landscape and sky. Torriti dates the Bayonne-London panels ca.1508-1510 and the Allegory of Fortune should be considered of approximately the same date. In confirming the attribution of the Fortuna to Beccafumi, Torriti calls special attention to the similarity of the protagonist in our picture with several female figures in Beccafumi’s oeuvre: the Lucretia (a fragment most likely from a full-length painting similar to the Fortuna) at Oberlin; the woman at the right of the Cerealia (painted for Petrucci) in the Martelli collection, Eve in the Descent into Limbo, and female figures in various frescoes by the artist. A particularly apposite comparison is found in a red chalk drawing (Paris, Louvre, inv. N. 10788), a study for one of the women in the Betrothal of the Virgin, a Beccafumi fresco in the Oratorio di San Bernardino in Siena. However, these are for the most part similarities of type rather than style—for which the Trinity Triptych (Pinacoteca, Siena) of 1513, different as it may be in subject, provides a valuable comparison. While the repaint and damage documented in the 1934 photograph has been largely mitigated, some abrasions to the paint surface of the Fortuna remain. These gratefully interfere only slightly with the elegance and mystery of this allegorical figure representing the changeability of fortune and the unpredictability of life. In summarizing his opinion, Torriti has written that “the painting here under study can be directly attributed to the great Beccafumi and therefore its unexpected discovery represents an important contribution to the history of Sienese art of the sixteenth century.”
  • Creator:
    Domenico Beccafumi (1484 - 1551, Italian)
  • Creation Year:
    c. 1510
  • Dimensions:
    Height: 32.75 in (83.19 cm)Width: 20.38 in (51.77 cm)
  • Medium:
  • Movement & Style:
  • Period:
  • Condition:
  • Gallery Location:
    New York, NY
  • Reference Number:
    1stDibs: LU10212222042
More From This SellerView All
  • Orientale
    By Henri Fantin-Latour
    Located in New York, NY
    Signed, lower right: Fantin Provenance: Gustave Tempelaere (1840–1904), Paris; possibly by descent to his son: Julien Tempelaere (1876–1961) and with F. & J. Tempelaere, Paris, prob...
    Category

    1890s Romantic Figurative Paintings

    Materials

    Canvas, Paper, Oil

  • Portrait of an Artist (possibly a Self-Portrait)
    Located in New York, NY
    Provenance: Bradley Collection. Private Collection, Upperville, Virginia. Literature: Katlijne van der Stighelen and Hans Vlieghe, Rubens: Portraits of Unidentified and Newly Identified Sitters painted in Antwerp, Corpus Rubenianum Ludwig Burchard, vol. 19, pt. 3, London and Turnhout, 2021, under cat. no. 189, p. 161, and fig. 75. This painting had previously been considered to be by an anonymous Tuscan painter of the sixteenth century in the orbit of Agnolo Bronzino. While the painting does in fact demonstrate a striking formal and compositional similarity to Bronzino’s portraits—compare the nearly identical pose of Bronzino’s Portrait of a Young Man in the Metropolitan Museum of Art (Fig. 1)—its style is completely foreign to Italian works of the period. That it is painted on an oak panel is further indication of its non-Italian origin. This portrait can in fact be confidently attributed to the Antwerp artist Huybrecht Beuckelaer. Huybrecht, the brother of Joachim Beuckelaer, has only recently been identified as the author of a distinct body of work formerly grouped under the name of the “Monogrammist HB.” In recent studies by Kreidl, Wolters, and Bruyn his remarkable career has been delineated: from its beginnings with Joachim in the workshop of Pieter Aertsen; to his evident travels to Italy where, it has been suggested, he came into contact with Bronzino’s paintings; to his return to Antwerp, where he seems to have assisted Anthonis Mor in painting costume in portraits; to his independent work in Antwerp (where he entered the Guild of Saint Luke in 1579); and, later to his career in England where, known as “Master Hubberd,” he was patronized by the Earl of Leicester. Our painting was recently published by Dr. Katlijne van der Stighelen and Dr. Hans Vlieghe in a volume of the Corpus Rubenianum, in which they write that the painting “has a very Italian air about it and fits convincingly within [Beuckelaer’s] oeuvre.” Stighelen and Vlieghe compare the painting with Peter Paul Ruben’s early Portrait of a Man, Possibly an Architect or Geographer in the Metropolitan Museum of Art, in which the sitter holds a compass and wears a similarly styled doublet (Fig. 2). Huybrecht both outlived and travelled further afield than his brother Joachim, who made his career primarily in Antwerp. Whereas Joachim was the main artistic inheritor of their uncle and teacher, Pieter Aertson, working in similar style and format as a specialist in large-scale genre and still-life paintings, Huybrecht clearly specialized as a painter of portraits and was greatly influenced by the foreign artists and works he encountered on his travels. His peripatetic life and his distinctly individual hand undoubtedly contributed to the fact his career and artistic output have only recently been rediscovered and reconstructed. His periods abroad seem to have overlapped with the mature phase of his brother Joachim’s career, who enrolled in the Antwerp Guild of Saint Luke much earlier than his brother, establishing himself as an independent painter in 1560. Joachim’s activity was confined to the following decade and half, and his latest work dates from the last year of his life, 1574. Our portrait was likely produced in the late 1560s, a dating supported by the dendrochronological investigation performed by Dr. Peter Klein, which established that it is painted on an oak panel with an earliest felling date of 1558 and with a fabrication date of ca. 1566. This painting presents a portrait of an artist, almost certainly Huybrecht’s self-portrait. The young sitter is confidently posed in a striking patterned white doublet with a wide collar and an abundance of buttons. He stands with his right arm akimbo, his exaggerated hands both a trademark of Huybrecht and his brother Joachim’s art, as well as a possible reference to the “hand of the artist.” The figure peers out of the painting, interacting intimately and directly with the viewer, as we witness him posed in an interior, the tools and results of his craft visible nearby. He holds a square or ruler in his left hand, while a drawing compass...
    Category

    16th Century Old Masters Paintings

    Materials

    Oil, Panel

  • The Veronica of the Virgin (Verónica de la Virgen)
    Located in New York, NY
    The panel has been attributed both to Joan de Joanes and his son Vicente Macip Comes (Valencia, ca. 1555 – 1623). Provenance: Private Collection, England, by 1886 (according to stencils on the reverse) Private Collection, New Jersey, until 2010 The Veil of Veronica, often called the Sudarium, is one of the most important and well-known relics of Christ. According to legend, Veronica offered Christ her veil as he carried the cross to his crucifixion. He wiped his face with the veil, which left the cloth miraculously imprinted with his image. Depictions of Christ’s face on a veil, or simply images that focused in on Christ’s face, were treasured objects of religious devotion. The popularity of this format also inspired similar images of the face of the Virgin. The iconographic type of the present painting is known as the Veronica of the Virgin, which was especially favored in late medieval and early Renaissance Spain. Distinct from the images of the suffering Christ, the Veronica of the Virgin is based on the legend that Saint Luke painted a portrait of Mary from life. Although scholars have sometimes mistaken them for portraits of Queen Isabella I of Castile (known as Isabel la Católica) or as a depiction of Saint Maria Toribia (known as María de la Cabeza, or, Mary of the Head), paintings like this one were clearly intended as images of the Virgin in the style of Saint Luke’s lost portrait. The Veronica of the Virgin was especially popular in Valencia, and depictions of this subject produced there all stem back to one visual prototype: a Byzantine image in the city’s cathedral (Fig. 1). This early treatment of the Veronica was given to the cathedral in 1437 by Martin the Humane, King of Aragon and Valencia, who promoted religious veneration of the Veronica of the Virgin as part of the celebration of the Immaculate Conception of Mary. This devotion spread throughout Martin’s kingdom and particularly took hold in Valencia, where the Byzantine image resided. The image, which is displayed in a gold reliquary...
    Category

    16th Century Old Masters Paintings

    Materials

    Oil, Wood Panel

  • Portrait of a Man
    Located in New York, NY
    Provenance: with Leo Blumenreich and Julius Böhler, Munich, 1924 Dr. Frederic Goldstein Oppenheimer (1881-1963), San Antonio, Texas; by whom given to: Abraham M. Adler, New York, un...
    Category

    16th Century Old Masters Portrait Paintings

    Materials

    Oil, Panel

  • Esther in the Women's House of Ahasuerus
    By Artus Wolfort
    Located in New York, NY
    Born in Antwerp, Artus Wolffordt received his training in Dordrecht where he became a master in 1603 at the age of twenty-two. He returned to his native city in 1615 and initially worked as an assistant to Otto van Veen...
    Category

    17th Century Old Masters Paintings

    Materials

    Oil, Panel

  • Madonna and Child with the Infant Saint John the Baptist
    Located in New York, NY
    Inscribed, reverse: Fr Brina Provenance: Private Collection, New Jersey. Francesco Brina was one of the “Studiolo” painters, responsible for the panel of Neptune and Amphitrite in F...
    Category

    16th Century Old Masters Paintings

    Materials

    Oil, Wood Panel

You May Also Like
  • Leda And The Swan By Workshop Of Bartholomaeus Spranger
    Located in New Orleans, LA
    Workshop of Bartholomaeus Spranger 16th Century Flemish Leda and the Swan Oil on panel Retelling one of the most legendary Greco-Roman mythological tales, this exceptional oil on...
    Category

    16th Century Old Masters Nude Paintings

    Materials

    Panel, Oil

  • Diana and Actaeon, a Mannerist painting after Joseph Heintz the Elder
    Located in PARIS, FR
    This painting seduced us with its rich colors. Depicting Diana and her companions surprised by Actaeon, it was inspired by an engraving by Aegidius Sadeler II after a painting by Jos...
    Category

    17th Century Old Masters Nude Paintings

    Materials

    Oil, Wood Panel

  • Venus and Adonis
    By Baron Pierre Narcisse Guerin (workshop)
    Located in Paris, FR
    Baron Pierre Narcisse GUERIN (Circle of) 1774-1833 French Venus et Adonis (Venus and Adonis) Oil on canvas Canvas: 53" high x 39 1/2" wide Frame: ...
    Category

    19th Century Old Masters Figurative Paintings

    Materials

    Canvas, Oil

  • Cleopatra
    Located in London, GB
    Gabriel Revel was born in 1642 in the town of Chateau-Thierry in the province of Champagne. Although the name of his father is unknown, his profession was that of a ‘painter-glazer’ so the young Gabriel would no doubt have learnt the basic skills to become an artist in his father’s studio from an early age. Little is known of Revel’s early career however by 1671 he was working on the decorative schemes at Versailles and Gobelin under Charles le Brun, indicating his skill was great enough to be considered one of the finest artistic talents of the day. In 1683, Gabriel became a member of the Royal Academy after submitting his portraits of François Girardon and Michel Anguier. This success led to a number of commissions outside of Paris in the provinces, especially Dijon which he travelled to regularly until moving there permanently in 1692 after the death of Le Brun. Revel clearly took artistic influence from the fashions of the day using bold colours and fine detail to create highly decorative works. His Group Portrait, dated 1686 in the Portland Art Museum shows the central figure, much like the painting of Cleopatra in question, looking upwards wrapped in a rich blue drapery wearing jewel encrusted clothing. This type of decoration and composition would have had a base in Le Brun’s historical works and would almost certainly have been a style Revel developed whilst working on the decoration at Versailles. Whilst in Dijon, Gabriel painted virtually without competition and further circulated the style of historical painting popularized at Versailles by Le Brun. One of his most significant commissions in Dijon is the ceiling painting...
    Category

    17th Century Old Masters Nude Paintings

    Materials

    Canvas, Oil

  • Old Master Dutch Female Nude Arcadian Landscape - 19th century art oil painting
    By (Attributed to) Isaac de Mucheron
    Located in London, GB
    An original oil on canvas which is attributed verso to Isaac Mucheron with figure by Vandveldt. The scene depicts a nude in an Arcadia classical landscape with ruins. Fresh colour an...
    Category

    Early 19th Century Old Masters Landscape Paintings

    Materials

    Oil

  • Portrait of Putti Playing - French 17th century art Old Master oil painting
    Located in London, GB
    This stunning French 17th century Old Master oil painting is by Baroque artist Laurent de la Hyre. It was painted circa 1645 and has excellent provenance from Christie's. The painti...
    Category

    17th Century Old Masters Portrait Paintings

    Materials

    Oil

Recently Viewed

View All