Skip to main content
  • Design Credit: Samantha Todhunter Design Ltd., Photo Credit: Oliver Clarke. Dimensions: H 23.5 in. x W 18.5 in.
  • Design Credit: Lucy Harris Studio, Photo Credit: Francesco Bertocci. Dimensions: H 23.5 in. x W 18.5 in.
  • Design Credit: Timothy Godbold, Photo Credit: Karl Simone. Dimensions: H 23.5 in. x W 18.5 in.
  • Want more images or videos?
    Request additional images or videos from the seller
1 of 6

William Cave Thomas
The Argument

$55,000

About

Signed and inscribed on a label on the verso: No. 1/ The Argument/ W. Cave Thomas/ 203 Camden Rd/ NW Provenance: Christie’s, London, 6 November 1995, lot 88. Private Collection, London. This powerful watercolor is a mature work by the little-known Victorian painter William Cave Thomas. Although he is generally considered a fringe member of the Pre-Raphaelite circle, possibly as a result of the rarity of his works, Thomas was a close associate of several leading members of Pre-Raphaelite Brotherhood and is credited with giving the movement’s famed periodical, The Germ, its name. Thomas here depicts a bearded man dressed in a lavish red velvet costume. The wonderfully coarse beard and fur hat suggest that the figure was inspired by a trip that the artist took to Russia. A label on the reverse of the frame written in the Thomas’s hand records the title of this work, The Argument. The close-cropping, spirited hand gestures, and penetrating stare of the figure suggests that the dispute in question is one between the protagonist of the painting and the viewer. The son of a frame maker and gilder, Thomas studied at the Royal Academy in the 1830s and in 1840 travelled to Munich, where he attended the Academy of Fine Arts. He returned to England in 1843 and achieved modest success as an artist, art instructor, and writer in the nation’s capital. Thomas exhibited widely in London, most notably at the Royal Academy between 1843–1862 and at the Exhibition at Westminster Hall in 1845, where he won a £400 prize for a cartoon of an Allegory of Justice, which ultimately resulted in the fresco of the subject to adorn the House of Lords (in situ). In addition to working as the Master of the North London School for Drawing and Modelling in Camden, Thomas was a prolific writer and frequent contributor to the contemporary discourse on art and art education of his day. He penned numerous articles, pamphlets, and treatises on the arts, including: “The Influences Which Tend to Retard Progress of the Fine Arts” in the Builder (1848), Pre-Raphaelitism Tested by the Principles of Christianity: An Introduction to Christian Idealism (1860), and Mural or Monumental Decoration: Its Aims and Methods (1869). Thomas’s period of study in Germany, where he came into contact with Peter von Cornelius and Johann Friedrich Overbeck, played a crucial role in his stylistic development. His paintings have often been likened to those of the German painters known as the Nazarenes that he encountered in Munich. Despite the hints of “Germanism” detected in his works—including the hard lines and the prevalence of religious subjects—Thomas’s oeuvre should be viewed within the context of the main artistic movement of his day in England: Pre-Raphaelitism. Thomas was a friend of Dante Gabriel Rossetti—one of the founding members of the Pre-Raphaelite Brotherhood—and of Ford Madox Brown, with whom he shared a studio in the 1840s. The dynamic between the subject and the viewer in the present work is paralleled in Thomas’s painting Eliezer Offering the Earring and Bracelets to Rebecca (Fig. 1). Here, the figure of Eliezer is similarly shown bust-length and peering out of the painting. The viewer implicitly takes on the role of Rebecca, who is being offered the jewelry that Eliezer holds in his right hand. Thomas frequently worked from literary and religious sources when designing his pictures, but no source text has yet been identified for The Argument. The figure’s beard and the fur hat—which resembles a Cossack hat—suggest that the figure may have been inspired by a trip that Thomas undertook to Saint Petersburg in the 1850s. Ford Madox Brown recorded in a diary entry dated 30 August 1854 his response to a work executed by Thomas shortly after his return from Russia: “He [Thomas] showed me a study of a Russian Merchant that quite astonished me, a most noble painting equal to anything modern or ancient.” The work seen by Ford Madox Brown was probably The Russian Dealer of the Gostvinordor, which Thomas exhibited at the National Institution exhibition the following year. That picture, which is now untraced, was judged among the best portraits in the exhibition and was described by one reviewer as an “elaborately-painted head…the fur in [which] is the very acme of imitation.” While it is tempting to associate this reference with our watercolor, it seems more likely that these were different works of closely related theme. Thomas’s handwritten label on the verso describes the painting as “No. 1,” which suggests that it was shown as the first work in an as yet unidentified exhibition. The North West London address inscribed was one that the artist moved to around 1871. While this may suggest that the watercolor is a relatively late work, Anne Thomas, who is writing a biography of the artist, believes The Argument likely dates from the 1850s, close to the time of Thomas’s travels to Russia, but was only exhibited later in his life.

Details

Shipping & Returns

  • Shipping
    Retrieving quote...
    Ships From: New York, NY
  • Return Policy

    This item cannot be returned.

1stDibs Buyer Protection Guaranteed
If your item arrives not as described, we’ll work with you and the seller to make it right. Learn More
About the Seller
5.0
Located in New York, NY
Recognized Seller
These prestigious sellers are industry leaders and represent the highest echelon for item quality and design.
Established in 1997
1stDibs seller since 2012
14 sales on 1stDibs
More From This SellerView All
  • Un Enfant
    By Joseph Ramanankamonjy
    Located in New York, NY
    Signed and inscribed, lower center: Joseph / Ramanankamonjy / un enfant / Madagascar / “sanguine sur soie” Provenance: Private Collection, Paris Private Collection, Florida Sometim...
    Category

    20th Century Modern Figurative Drawings and Watercolors

    Materials

    Silk, Watercolor

  • Petite Fille
    By Joseph Ramanankamonjy
    Located in New York, NY
    Signed and inscribed, lower center: Joseph / Ramanankamonjy / Madagascar / Petite fille / “aquarelle sur soie” Provenance: Private Collection, Paris Private Collection, Florida Som...
    Category

    20th Century Modern Figurative Drawings and Watercolors

    Materials

    Silk, Watercolor

  • Head of a Cheerful Man Wearing a Cap
    Located in New York, NY
    Watermark: the arms of Amsterdam Provenance: Christie’s, Amsterdam, 1 December 1986, lot 46; where acquired by: Private Collection, New York Literature: Roger Adolf d’Hulst, “Jo...
    Category

    17th Century Baroque Portrait Drawings and Watercolors

    Materials

    Paper, Chalk

  • Study of a Woman
    Located in New York, NY
    Signed, lower right: Wm Bouguereau Provenance: with Galerie Percier, Paris with Galerie Drouant-David, Paris Private Collection, Chicago Bouguereau was the preeminent academic p...
    Category

    19th Century Old Masters Portrait Drawings and Watercolors

    Materials

    Pastel, Board, Paper

  • Head of a Female Saint
    By Bernardino Lanino
    Located in New York, NY
    Provenance: Duke Vittorio Amadeo I (d. 1637), Turin; by descent in the Library of the Dukes of Savoy Antonio Abrate (1834–1925), Turin, after 1887; by descent to: Adele Abrate Carl...
    Category

    16th Century Old Masters Portrait Drawings and Watercolors

    Materials

    Paper, Chalk

  • Head of a Woman
    Located in New York, NY
    Provenance: The Artist’s widow (according to a handwritten label on the reverse) with David Cooper, 56 George Street, London, 1951; where probably acquired by: Walter Steinberg, U...
    Category

    1920s Expressionist Portrait Drawings and Watercolors

    Materials

    Paper, Ink, Watercolor, Pen

You May Also Like
  • The Village Maids - British Victorian art exhibited RA 1880 watercolour painting
    By Marcella M Walker
    Located in London, GB
    This stunning exhibited Pre-Raphaelite 19th century watercolour painting is by British Victorian female artist Marcella M Walker. The painting was painted in 1880 and exhibited at th...
    Category

    19th Century Pre-Raphaelite Figurative Drawings and Watercolors

    Materials

    Watercolor

  • Meeting At A Diner
    Located in Minneapolis, MN
    This vintage illustration features a disheveled Jimmy Stewart type in rumpled raincoat and hat, being side-eyed with disdain. The other fellow appears to be wearing last night's tuxe...
    Category

    1940s American Realist Figurative Drawings and Watercolors

    Materials

    Paper, Gouache, Graphite

  • On the Look Out
    By Sir Kyffin Williams
    Located in Belgravia, London, London
    Watercolour and pencil on paper Paper size: 10.75 x 15.5 inches Framed size: 20.5 x 25.5 inches Signed lower right
    Category

    20th Century Figurative Drawings and Watercolors

    Materials

    Paper, Watercolor, Pencil

  • "Julius Caesar" original art for Penguin book cover
    By Milton Glaser
    Located in Miami, FL
    An uncanny and unexpected pose characterizes this work as Julius Ceasar warily looks over his shoulder and blood-stained toga. Signed lower right "M. Glaser" Exhibited: Milton Glase...
    Category

    1980s Contemporary Figurative Drawings and Watercolors

    Materials

    Paper, Watercolor, Pencil

  • She Fox
    By June Glasson
    Located in Denver, CO
    June Glasson is an artist, illustrator, and designer. She live in Laramie, WY. Her paintings have been exhibited at the National Portrait Gallery in London, Nature Morte Gallery in B...
    Category

    2010s Contemporary Figurative Drawings and Watercolors

    Materials

    Paper, Ink, Gouache, Pencil

  • Max Beerbohm, 19th Century British caricature of Mr Harry Nichols
    By Max Beerbohm
    Located in Petworth, West Sussex
    Max Beerbohm (British, 1872 – 1956) Mr Harry Nicholls (In a life of pleasure), 1893 Signed ‘MAX’ (lower right), inscribed with title in ink Pencil on paper with evidence of some wate...
    Category

    Late 19th Century Victorian Figurative Drawings and Watercolors

    Materials

    Paper, Watercolor, Pencil

Recently Viewed

View More

The 1stDibs Promise

Learn More

Expertly Vetted Sellers

Confidence at Checkout

Price-Match Guarantee

Exceptional Support

Buyer Protection

Trusted Global Delivery