Skip to main content

Rare Gemstone Engagement Rings

3.96 Carat Oval Aquamarine Diamond Three Stone Alternative Engagement Ring
3.96 Carat Oval Aquamarine Diamond Three Stone Alternative Engagement Ring

3.96 Carat Oval Aquamarine Diamond Three Stone Alternative Engagement Ring

Located in Beverly Hills, CA

Jewelry Beverly Hills storefront on 1stDibs to discover new arrivals of alternative engagement rings, rare

Category

21st Century and Contemporary American Modern Engagement Rings

Materials

Multi-gemstone, White Diamond, Diamond, Aquamarine, Platinum

Recent Sales

Oval Cut Alexandrite Bridal Wedding Ring, Art Deco Rose Gold Engagement Ring
Oval Cut Alexandrite Bridal Wedding Ring, Art Deco Rose Gold Engagement Ring

Oval Cut Alexandrite Bridal Wedding Ring, Art Deco Rose Gold Engagement Ring

Located in Orlando, Florida

, Oval Cut Alexandrite Bridal Wedding Ring For Her Vintage Unique rare gemstone Engagement Ring 18K

Category

21st Century and Contemporary American Art Deco Engagement Rings

Materials

Alexandrite, Diamond, 18k Gold, Rose Gold, Gold

Vintage 1.22ct Green Peridot in Yellow Gold Ring with Orange Enamel
Vintage 1.22ct Green Peridot in Yellow Gold Ring with Orange Enamel

Vintage 1.22ct Green Peridot in Yellow Gold Ring with Orange Enamel

Located in Miami, FL

snake-like pattern. With its intricate detailing and rare vintage charm, this gemstone engagement ring

Category

Mid-20th Century North American Artisan Cocktail Rings

Materials

Peridot, Gold, 10k Gold, Yellow Gold, Enamel

2.79 Ct Violet Blue Sapphire Cushion Cut Platinum Engagement Ring - GIA
2.79 Ct Violet Blue Sapphire Cushion Cut Platinum Engagement Ring - GIA

2.79 Ct Violet Blue Sapphire Cushion Cut Platinum Engagement Ring - GIA

Located in Beverly Hills, CA

-Certified Sapphire – Sri Lanka Origin. This exquisite platinum three-stone engagement ring features a rare

Category

21st Century and Contemporary American Contemporary Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Sapphire, Blue Sapphire, Blue Diamond, Yellow Di...

Rare Bicolor Tourmaline Emerald-Cut 18K Rose Gold  Diamond Ring - Unique Luxury
Rare Bicolor Tourmaline Emerald-Cut 18K Rose Gold  Diamond Ring - Unique Luxury

Rare Bicolor Tourmaline Emerald-Cut 18K Rose Gold Diamond Ring - Unique Luxury

By Merkaba

Located in Beverly Hills, CA

rare interplay of vibrant green and delicate pink hues, this one-of-a-kind gemstone captivates with its

Category

21st Century and Contemporary American Art Deco Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Multi-gemstone, Tourmaline, Emerald, 18k Gold, R...

People Also Browsed

6.47 Carat Paraiba Tourmaline Loose Gemstone, Oval Cut, Mozambique, GIA Certifie
6.47 Carat Paraiba Tourmaline Loose Gemstone, Oval Cut, Mozambique, GIA Certifie

6.47 Carat Paraiba Tourmaline Loose Gemstone, Oval Cut, Mozambique, GIA Certifie

By Merkaba

Located in Beverly Hills, CA

Offered loose by Merkaba Jewelry Beverly Hills, this 6.47 carat Paraiba tourmaline from Mozambique is an extraordinary collector gemstone, presented in a refined oval cut and accompa...

Category

21st Century and Contemporary Mozambican Contemporary Loose Gemstones

Materials

Tourmaline, Paraiba, 18k Gold, Rose Gold, White Gold, Yellow Gold, Platinum

Vivid Diamonds GIA Certified 7.23 Carat Emerald Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
Vivid Diamonds GIA Certified 7.23 Carat Emerald Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

Vivid Diamonds GIA Certified 7.23 Carat Emerald Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

By Vivid Diamonds

Located in Miami, FL

Breathtakingly beautiful Vivid Diamonds engagement ring crafted in platinum, featuring an exceptional GIA certified antique emerald cut diamond weighing 7.23 carats, D color, IF cla...

Category

21st Century and Contemporary American Modern Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, Platinum

Nazarelle GIA Certified Brazilian Paraiba Tourmaline Diamond Cocktail Ring
Nazarelle GIA Certified Brazilian Paraiba Tourmaline Diamond Cocktail Ring

Nazarelle GIA Certified Brazilian Paraiba Tourmaline Diamond Cocktail Ring

By Nazarelle

Located in Houston, TX

This ring is designed by Nazarelle and made in 14k white and rose gold. For the center stone it features one oval Paraiba Tourmaline from Brazil, GIA certified (GIA: 2151487144 ) wei...

Category

2010s American Contemporary Cocktail Rings

Materials

Diamond, Tourmaline, Gold, 14k Gold, White Gold, Rose Gold

6.50 Carat Unheated Ceylon Sapphire Cushion Platinum Diamond Ring GIA By Merkaba
6.50 Carat Unheated Ceylon Sapphire Cushion Platinum Diamond Ring GIA By Merkaba

6.50 Carat Unheated Ceylon Sapphire Cushion Platinum Diamond Ring GIA By Merkaba

By Merkaba

Located in Beverly Hills, CA

A rare, collector-caliber, one of a kind cushion sapphire three stone cocktail ring by Merkaba Jewelry Beverly Hills, centering a 6.50 carat natural unheated Blue Ceylon sapphire fro...

Category

21st Century and Contemporary Sri Lankan Modern Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Sapphire, Blue Sapphire, Platinum

Bochic “Capri” Vintage Natural Diamond & Emerald Ring Set in 18K Gold & Silver
Bochic “Capri” Vintage Natural Diamond & Emerald Ring Set in 18K Gold & Silver

Bochic “Capri” Vintage Natural Diamond & Emerald Ring Set in 18K Gold & Silver

By Bochic

Located in New York, NY

Bochic “Capri” Vintage Emerald & Diamond Ring Set in 18K Gold & Silver Natural Emeralds - 9 Carats Natural Rose Cut Gray Diamonds - 2 Carat This Ring is from the "Capri...

Category

Late 20th Century Thai Art Deco Cocktail Rings

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, 18k Gold, Silver

6 CTW Natural Zambian Emerald Diamond Engagement Ring 10 Karat White Gold
6 CTW Natural Zambian Emerald Diamond Engagement Ring 10 Karat White Gold

6 CTW Natural Zambian Emerald Diamond Engagement Ring 10 Karat White Gold

By Spectrum Jewels

Located in Diera, Dubai

6 CTW Natural Zambian Emerald Diamond Engagement Ring 10 Karat White Gold features octagon cut emerald set in center with diamonds around it and on shank making it statement engageme...

Category

21st Century and Contemporary American Art Deco Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, Gold, 10k Gold, White Gold

3.93 Carat Pink Tourmaline Pear Toi et Moi Ring Platinum with 1.00 Carat Diamond
3.93 Carat Pink Tourmaline Pear Toi et Moi Ring Platinum with 1.00 Carat Diamond

3.93 Carat Pink Tourmaline Pear Toi et Moi Ring Platinum with 1.00 Carat Diamond

By Merkaba

Located in Beverly Hills, CA

A one of a kind platinum Toi et Moi cocktail ring by Merkaba Jewelry Beverly Hills, created as a modern symbol of love and duality. This Toi et Moi design, meaning “you and me,” cele...

Category

21st Century and Contemporary American Modern Cocktail Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Multi-gemstone, Tourmaline, Platinum

IGI 18K 6.63 Ct Zambia Intense Green Emerald&Diamonds Antique Engagement Ring
IGI 18K 6.63 Ct Zambia Intense Green Emerald&Diamonds Antique Engagement Ring

IGI 18K 6.63 Ct Zambia Intense Green Emerald&Diamonds Antique Engagement Ring

Located in Kaohsiung City, TW

*IGI 18K 6.63 Ct Zambia Minor-Oiled Intense Green Emerald&Diamonds Antique Engagement Ring* An IGI-certified Zambia natural intense green emerald weighing 6.63 ct set on the 18K...

Category

21st Century and Contemporary Taiwanese Contemporary Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, Emerald, Gold, 18k Gold, Yellow Gold

GIA certified .15ct Fancy Intense Pink Purple Diamond Loose 41114
GIA certified .15ct Fancy Intense Pink Purple Diamond Loose 41114

GIA certified .15ct Fancy Intense Pink Purple Diamond Loose 41114

By Unbranded

Located in New York, NY

GIA Certified .15ct Natural Diamond Loose Fancy Intense Pink Purple Even 4.00 x 2.69 x 1.88 mm Report # 2235404915 Stating I3 clarity

Category

21st Century and Contemporary Retro Loose Gemstones

Materials

Diamond

4.36 Carat Brazilian Imperial Topaz Emerald Cut Drop Earrings 18K Yellow Gold
4.36 Carat Brazilian Imperial Topaz Emerald Cut Drop Earrings 18K Yellow Gold

4.36 Carat Brazilian Imperial Topaz Emerald Cut Drop Earrings 18K Yellow Gold

By Merkaba

Located in Beverly Hills, CA

4.36 carat total Brazilian imperial topaz emerald cut diamond drop earrings in 18K yellow gold and platinum by Merkaba Jewelry Beverly Hills. A collector focused, one of a kind pair ...

Category

21st Century and Contemporary American Modern Drop Earrings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Emerald, Multi-gemstone, Topaz, Imperial Topaz, ...

4.47 Carat Pink Tourmaline Oval Diamond Ring in 18K Rose Gold by Merkaba Jewelry
4.47 Carat Pink Tourmaline Oval Diamond Ring in 18K Rose Gold by Merkaba Jewelry

4.47 Carat Pink Tourmaline Oval Diamond Ring in 18K Rose Gold by Merkaba Jewelry

By Merkaba

Located in Beverly Hills, CA

A luminous 4.47 carat Pink Tourmaline oval diamond ring handcrafted in 18K rose gold by Merkaba Jewelry Beverly Hills, created for collectors who are drawn to rare color, refined ele...

Category

21st Century and Contemporary American Modern Cocktail Rings

Materials

Tourmaline, Multi-gemstone, White Diamond, Diamond, Gold, Rose Gold, 18k...

2 Carat Colombian Emerald Diamond Platinum Ring
2 Carat Colombian Emerald Diamond Platinum Ring

2 Carat Colombian Emerald Diamond Platinum Ring

Located in Chicago, IL

Handcrafted in solid platinum, this elegant ring centers on a vivid Colombian emerald weighing approximately 2.00 carats, framed by two natural trillion-cut diamonds totaling approxi...

Category

2010s American Contemporary Three-Stone Rings

Materials

Emerald, Diamond, Platinum

Exquisite 3.15 Carat Chrome Tourmaline Ring in 18K White Gold – Luxury Gemstone
Exquisite 3.15 Carat Chrome Tourmaline Ring in 18K White Gold – Luxury Gemstone

Exquisite 3.15 Carat Chrome Tourmaline Ring in 18K White Gold – Luxury Gemstone

By Merkaba

Located in Beverly Hills, CA

Rare 3.15 Carat Chrome Tourmaline Ring in 18K White Gold – An Exceptional Gift by Merkaba Jewelry Beverly Hills. Presenting a rare and exquisite 3.15-carat Chrome Tourmaline emerald...

Category

21st Century and Contemporary American Art Deco Cocktail Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Multi-gemstone, Tourmaline, Chrome Tourmaline, 1...

7.87 Carat Pink Tourmaline Cushion Cocktail Ring Platinum Diamond - Merkaba
7.87 Carat Pink Tourmaline Cushion Cocktail Ring Platinum Diamond - Merkaba

7.87 Carat Pink Tourmaline Cushion Cocktail Ring Platinum Diamond - Merkaba

By Merkaba

Located in Beverly Hills, CA

7.87 carat pink tourmaline cushion cocktail ring in platinum by Merkaba Jewelry Beverly Hills. Centered by a vivid, high-impact pink tourmaline chosen for its saturated glow and comm...

Category

21st Century and Contemporary American Modern Cocktail Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Multi-gemstone, Sapphire, Pink Sapphire, Tourmal...

Emerald Cut Platinum Engagement Ring, 4.01ct Deep Blue Spinel, Merkaba
Emerald Cut Platinum Engagement Ring, 4.01ct Deep Blue Spinel, Merkaba

Emerald Cut Platinum Engagement Ring, 4.01ct Deep Blue Spinel, Merkaba

By Merkaba

Located in Beverly Hills, CA

A collector grade 4.01 carat natural deep blue spinel takes center stage in this refined emerald cut platinum alternative engagement ring by Merkaba Jewelry Beverly Hills. Chosen for...

Category

21st Century and Contemporary American Modern Engagement Rings

Materials

Diamond, White Diamond, Emerald, Multi-gemstone, Spinel, Platinum

No Oil Colombian Emerald Diamond Micro Pavé Ring in Platinum by Merkaba Jewelry
No Oil Colombian Emerald Diamond Micro Pavé Ring in Platinum by Merkaba Jewelry

No Oil Colombian Emerald Diamond Micro Pavé Ring in Platinum by Merkaba Jewelry

By Merkaba

Located in Beverly Hills, CA

A rare and highly refined 0.79 carat No Oil Colombian emerald diamond alternative engagement ring handcrafted in platinum by Merkaba Jewelry Beverly Hills. At its center is a natural...

Category

21st Century and Contemporary American Modern Engagement Rings

Materials

Multi-gemstone, Emerald, White Diamond, Diamond, Beryl, Platinum

Get Updated with New Arrivals
Save "Rare Gemstone Engagement Rings", and we’ll notify you when there are new listings in this category.

Rare Gemstone Engagement Rings For Sale on 1stDibs

Find an expansive variety of rare gemstone engagement rings available on 1stDibs. These distinct designs — crafted with great care and often made from gold, 18k gold and white gold — can elevate any look. Find a collection of 224 vintage versions or 391 modern creations for a more contemporary example of these cherished accessories. Our inventory is broad and distinctive, with accessories on offer that were made as long ago as the 18th Century to those produced as recently as the 21st Century. Pieces in our collection of rare gemstone engagement rings made by contemporary jewelers — as well as those associated with modern — are very popular. Alberto, Celine Roelens and Sarosi By Timeless Gems each produced beautiful examples of these items that are worth considering. While most can agree that any pick from our collection easily elevates most outfits, but the choice of diamond versions from the 415 available is guaranteed to add a special touch to your ensemble. A selection of oval cut, cushion cut and emerald cut can be found today on these pages. There aren’t many items for men in our collection of rare gemstone engagement rings, as most of the options available are for women.

How Much are Rare Gemstone Engagement Rings?

Prices for rare gemstone engagement rings can differ depending upon size, time period and other attributes — at 1stDibs, these accessories begin at $260 and can go as high as $3,375,000, while rare gemstone engagement rings, on average, fetch $13,944.

Finding the Right Rings for You

Antique and vintage rings have long held a special place in the hearts of fine jewelry lovers all over the world.

No matter their origin or specific characteristics, rings are timeless, versatile accessories. They’ve carried deep meaning since at least the Middle Ages, when diamond rings symbolized strength and other kinds of rings were worn to signify romantic feelings or to denote an affiliation with a religious order. Rings have also forever been emblematic of eternity.

Over time, rings have frequently taken the form of serpents, which have long been associated with eternal life, health and renewal. Italian luxury jewelry house Bulgari has become famous for its widely loved Serpenti motif, for example, and its Serpenti ring, like the other accessories in the collection, began as an homage to jewelry of the Roman and Hellenistic eras. The serpent is now a popular motif in fine jewelry. Jewelry devotees have long pined for rings adorned with reptiles, thanks to antique Victorian rings — well, specifically, Queen Victoria’s illustrious engagement ring, which took the form of a gold snake set with rubies, diamonds and an emerald (her birthstone). Designs for Victorian-era engagement rings often featured repoussé work and chasing, in which patterns are hammered into the metal.

Engagement rings, which are reliably intimidating to shop for, are still widely recognized as symbols of love and commitment. On 1stDibs, a range of buying guides can be found for those in the market for antique engagement ringsvintage engagement rings or Art Deco engagement rings

The most collectible antique engagement rings and vintage engagement rings are those from the Victorian, Edwardian and Art Deco eras. Named for the monarchies of the four King Georges, who in succession ruled England starting in 1714 (plus King William’s reign), antique Georgian rings, be they engagement rings or otherwise, are also coveted by collectors. Pearls, along with colored gemstones like garnets, rubies and sapphires, were widely used in Georgian jewelry. The late-1700s paste jewelry was a predecessor to what we now call fashion or costume jewelry

The Art Nouveau movement (1880–1910) brought with it rings inspired by the natural world. Antique Art Nouveau rings might feature depictions of winged insects and fauna as well as women, who were simultaneously eroticized and romanticized, frequently with long flowing hair. Art Deco jewelry, on the other hand, which originated during the 1920s and ’30s, is by and large “white jewelry.” White metals, primarily platinum, were favored over yellow gold in the design of antique Art Deco rings and other accessories as well as geometric motifs, with women drawn to the era’s dazzling cocktail rings in particular.

Whether you’re hunting down a chunky classic for a Prohibition-themed cocktail party or seeking a clean contemporary design to complement your casual ensemble, find an exquisite collection of antique, new and vintage rings on 1stDibs.

Questions About Rare Gemstone Engagement Rings
  • 1stDibs ExpertNovember 2, 2021
    The best gemstone for an engagement ring is really a matter of preference. Diamonds have extraordinary brilliance, a hardness of 10, and are more scratch-resistant than any other gemstone. Emeralds and sapphires are also popular gemstones for an engagement ring. Shop a collection of vintage and modern engagement rings from some of the world’s top jewelers on 1stDibs.