Skip to main content

Vintage Glass Salad Servers

3
to
54
1,534
91
1,641
724
136
121
100
98
98
39
17
11
154
131
130
129
94
Sort By
Sculptural Teak Salad Servers
Located in Sagaponack, NY
A set of sculptural and impeccably crafted Scandinavian Modern serving utensils. Made from teak and bakelite in Denmark, circa 1950s.
Category

1950s Danish Scandinavian Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Bakelite, Teak

Vintage Sculptural Teak Salad Servers
Sculptural Teak Salad Servers
H 1 in W 2.5 in D 11.5 in
Olive Wood Salad Servers, France 1970s
Located in ROUEN, FR
Olive Wood Salad Servers, France 1970s. Very elegant design in perfect condition. Servers are
Category

Mid-20th Century French Mid-Century Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Fruitwood, Olive

Vintage Olive Wood Salad Servers, France 1970s
Olive Wood Salad Servers, France 1970s
H 11.03 in W 1.78 in D 0.79 in
Pair of Spratling Silver Salad Servers
By William Spratling
Located in Montreal, QC
Spratling made numerous stylish items in his day and these salad servers are among that production
Category

1960s Mexican Mid-Century Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Sterling Silver

Vintage Pair of Spratling Silver Salad Servers
Pair of Spratling Silver Salad Servers
H 11.25 in W 2.5 in D 1.5 in
Asian Style Minimalist Rosewood Salad Servers
Located in Ferndale, MI
Asian Style Minimalist rosewood salad servers.
Category

Mid-20th Century Danish Mid-Century Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Midcentury Sculptural Teak Salad Servers
By Jens Quistgaard
Located in San Diego, CA
Beautiful set of sculptural and impeccably crafted Scandinavian Modern serving utensils. Made from teak and bakelite in Denmark, circa 1950s. Vintage pieces that are iconic, classic ...
Category

1950s Danish Scandinavian Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Bakelite, Teak

JHQ Dansk Denmark Teak Salad Servers
By Jens Quistgaard, Dansk
Located in Ferndale, MI
Pair of Jens Quistgaard Danish teak salad servers. Part of a recently acquired large collection.
Category

1960s Danish Mid-Century Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Teak

Vintage JHQ Dansk Denmark Teak Salad Servers
JHQ Dansk Denmark Teak Salad Servers
H 15.75 in W 2.19 in D 1 in
Large Couroc Style Acrylic Modernist Salad Servers
By The Couroc Company
Located in Ferndale, MI
Large scale black plastic or acrylic modernist salad servers. Recently acquired as part of large
Category

1960s American Mid-Century Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Plastic, Acrylic

Pair of Silver Plate Salad Servers
Located in Los Angeles, CA
For the chic host or luxury house! A pair of silver plate salad utensils - fork and spoon. The
Category

20th Century Mid-Century Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Silver Plate

Vintage Pair of Silver Plate Salad Servers
Pair of Silver Plate Salad Servers
H 1 in W 12.5 in D 2.5 in
Wooden Flower Shaped Salad Bowl with Servers
Located in Munster, IN
Gorgeous woodgrain and an adorable floral shape, this salad bowl with servers is a great way to add
Category

Mid-20th Century Philippine Mid-Century Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Wood

Pair of Danish Modern Teak Salad Servers
Located in San Diego, CA
A nice pair of Pair of Danish Modern teak salad servers, circa 1970s. The servers are made of solid
Category

Mid-20th Century Malaysian Mid-Century Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Teak

Carl Auböck Horn Salad Servers, Austria, 1960s
By Werkstätte Carl Auböck
Located in Berlin, DE
Carl Auböck Salad servers made of Horn, Austria, 1960s.
Category

1960s Austrian Mid-Century Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Horn

Carl Auböck Horn Salad Servers, Austria 1960s
By Werkstätte Carl Auböck
Located in Berlin, DE
Carl Auböck salad servers made of Horn, Austria 1960s.
Category

1960s Austrian Mid-Century Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Horn

Mcm Walnut and Stainless Steel Salad Servers
Located in San Diego, CA
A nice pair of walnut and stainless steel MCM salad servers, circa 1970s. The servers handles are
Category

Mid-20th Century Japanese Mid-Century Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Stainless Steel

JHQ Dansk Denmark Modernist Acrylic Salad Servers
By Jens Quistgaard, Dansk
Located in Ferndale, MI
Pair of Jens Quistgaard acrylic plastic salad servers. Marked Dansk Designs Denmark.
Category

Late 20th Century Danish Mid-Century Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Pair of JHQ Dansk Denmark Teak Salad Servers
By Jens Quistgaard, Dansk
Located in Ferndale, MI
Pair of Jens Quistgaard for Dansk Denmark teak salad servers. Recently purchased with large
Category

1960s American Mid-Century Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Teak

Carl Auböck Salad Servers in Horn, Austria, 1960s
By Werkstätte Carl Auböck
Located in Berlin, DE
Carl Auböck salad servers, Austria, 1960s.
Category

1960s Austrian Mid-Century Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Horn

Carl Auböck Salad Servers in Horn, Austria 1960s
By Werkstätte Carl Auböck
Located in Berlin, DE
Carl Auböck salad servers, Austria 1960s.
Category

1960s Austrian Mid-Century Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Horn

Large Georg Jensen Salad Set / Servers by Lapaglia
By Georg Jensen
Located in Los Angeles, CA
Large Georg Jensen salad set / servers designed by Alphonse LaPaglia - measures: 10.25" long.
Category

Mid-20th Century Danish Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Sterling Silver

Pair of Mid-Century Flintwood Molded Plastic Salad Servers
By Carl Reininger
Located in Ferndale, MI
Pair of Mid-Century flintwood molded plastic salad servers by Carl Reininger Ability Products
Category

Mid-20th Century American Mid-Century Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Plastic

Mid-Century modern Rosewood and Bakelite Salad Servers
Located in Charleston, SC
This stunning vintage Danish modern style serving set has gorgeous rosewood handles and equally as stunning Bakelite. I love how the 2 pieces vary in color but are meant to be togeth...
Category

Mid-20th Century Unknown Mid-Century Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Bakelite, Rosewood

Pair of Vintage Salad Servers Hollywood Regency Brass & Ebony
Located in San Diego, CA
Simple and elegant stylized set of salad servers made of solid brass and ebony, beautiful design.
Category

Mid-20th Century Thai Hollywood Regency Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Brass

Danish Teak Salad Bowl with Servers by Wiggers, 1960s
By Wiggers
Located in Esbjerg, DK
comes with a salad serving set in rosewood and stainless steel (32 cm in length). The bowl is fully
Category

1960s Danish Mid-Century Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Teak

1950s William Spratling Wood Sterling Silver Salad Server Set Mexico
By William Spratling
Located in Chula Vista, CA
1950s William Spratling Wood Sterling Silver Salad Server Set Handcrafted Taxco, Mexico Maker
Category

1950s Mexican Mid-Century Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Sterling Silver

20th Century Arthur Court Grape Pyrex Serving Tray & Grape Salad Servers
By Arthur Court
Located in Nuernberg, DE
A gorgeous Arthur Court's grape pyrex serving tray with grape salad servers. Marked and dated 1999
Category

1990s American Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Aluminum

Danish Pair of Stainless Steel Salad Servers with Bamboo Handles
Located in Haddonfield, NJ
. Stemplet stainless steal ASNI Denmark Danish pair of stainless steel salad servers with bamboo handles.
Category

Mid-20th Century Danish Scandinavian Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Stainless Steel

Large Inlaid Walnut Salad Bowl & Servers by Gladmark of California
By Gladmark
Located in San Diego, CA
steel salad servers that are 13" long; the servers were made in Japan. The set is a marriage, but work
Category

Mid-20th Century North American Mid-Century Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Stainless Steel

Pair of Original Vintage Server Salad Utensils by Herbert Krenchel
By Herbert Krenchel
Located in Chicago, IL
Pair of vintage server salad utensils by Herbert Krenchel dims are of the spoon.
Category

Mid-20th Century Danish Mid-Century Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Plastic

Sterling Silver Vintage Modernist Hallmarked Salad Servers or Serving Pieces
Located in North Miami, FL
This pair of vintage sterling silver hallmarked salad servers or serving pieces are very modernist
Category

1970s Peruvian Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Sterling Silver

Vintage Modern Salad Servers Tongs Red Iron Bark Wood and Brass
Located in Chula Vista, CA
Vintage Modern Salad Servers Tongs Red Iron Bark Wood and Brass Red Iron Bark 10.5 Long x 2 H x 3
Category

Late 20th Century American Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Brass

Pair of MCM Teak Salad Servers by Jens Quistgaard for Dansk
By Dansk, Jens Quistgaard
Located in San Diego, CA
A nice pair of MCM teak salad servers by Jens Quistgaard for Dansk, circa 1970s. The servers are
Category

Mid-20th Century Malaysian Mid-Century Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Teak

Vintage Silver-Plate Hallmarked Salad Servers or Serving Pieces Pair Of
Located in North Miami, FL
This lovely set of vintage silver-plate salad servers or serving pieces are hallmarked with crowns
Category

1960s American Mid-Century Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Silver Plate

Danish Modern Teak Wood & Stainless Steel Banded Salad Servers, a Pair
Located in Philadelphia, PA
A pair of long handled salad servers of Danish design, from the Scandinavian Modern Mid-Century era
Category

Mid-20th Century Danish Scandinavian Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Stainless Steel

Georg Jensen Ltd. 925 Silver Late Art Deco Pyramid Pattern Salad Servers
Located in Braintree, GB
Georg Jensen Ltd. 925 silver late Art Deco Pyramid pattern salad servers Made in Denmark
Category

1930s Danish Art Deco Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Silver

Pair of Vintage Salad Servers in Curved Wood and Stainless Steel
Located in San Diego, CA
Simple and elegant stylized set of salad servers made of stainless steel and curved wood handles
Category

Mid-20th Century American Mid-Century Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Stainless Steel

Silver-Plate Sculptural Salad Servers or Serving Pieces Vintage Pair Of
Located in North Miami, FL
These amazing and sculptural hallmarked hand wrought silver plate serving pieces or salad utensils
Category

1980s Canadian Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Silver Plate

Rare Pair of Solid Teak Salad Servers by Jens Quistgaard for Dansk
By Dansk, Jens Quistgaard
Located in San Diego, CA
Rare pair of solid teak salad servers by Jens Quistgaard for Dansk, circa 1950s. The set is in
Category

20th Century Danish Scandinavian Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Teak

Pair of MCM Walnut and Sterling Silver Salad Servers Made in Italy
Located in San Diego, CA
Pair of MCM walnut and sterling silver salad servers made in Italy, circa 1970s. The set is in very
Category

Mid-20th Century Italian Mid-Century Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Sterling Silver

Danish Modern Sterling Silver Fork and Spoon Salad Server Set by Cohr
By Carl M. Cohr
Located in Philadelphia, PA
A good, period Danish Modern sterling silver salad set by Cohr. With grape, leaf, and flower
Category

Mid-20th Century Danish Scandinavian Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Sterling Silver

Pair of Danish Modern Solid Teak Salad Servers Designed by Quistgaard for Dansk
By Dansk, Jens Quistgaard
Located in San Diego, CA
Great design on these set of solid teak salad servers designed by Quistgaard for Dansk, great
Category

20th Century Thai Scandinavian Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Teak

Three Steel with Enamel Herb Krenchel Krenit Ware Bowls with Salad Servers
By Herbert Krenchel
Located in Ferndale, MI
Three steel bowls lined with black white and green colored porcelain enamel . Krenit ware bowls designed by by Herbert Krenchel for Torben Orskov.
Category

Mid-20th Century Danish Mid-Century Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Steel

Hand Hammered Silver-Plate Looped Serving Pieces Or Salad Servers With Brass Dot
Located in North Miami, FL
These lovely hand hammered silver plate salad servers or serving pieces have an elongated loop in
Category

1990s American Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Silver Plate, Brass

Large 27cm Horn Salad Cutlery servers set by Carl Auböck attrib., Austria, 1950s
By Werkstätte Carl Auböck
Located in Kirchlengern, DE
Article: salad cutlery set Design: attributed to Carl Auböck, 1950s Producer: attributed to
Category

Mid-20th Century Austrian Mid-Century Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Brass

MCM Stylized Set of Salad Servers in Sterling Silver and Enamel by N.M. Thune
By N.M. Thune
Located in San Diego, CA
Simple and elegant stylized set of salad servers and tongs made of sterling silver and enamel by
Category

Mid-20th Century Norwegian Scandinavian Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Sterling Silver, Enamel

Danish Teak Salad Bowl and Servers by Richard Nissen, 1960s, Set of 3
By Nissen
Located in Esbjerg, DK
bowl comes with a salad serving set also from Nissen. Its very rare to find a full set.
Category

1960s Danish Mid-Century Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Teak

Sterling Silver Mid-Century Salad Set
Located in Brooklyn, NY
materials (i.e., wood, glass, leather) and created some of the most beautiful pieces. This salad set fuses
Category

1950s Mexican Mid-Century Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Sterling Silver

11pc Mid Century Arrowsmith Mahogany Sterling Silver Salad Bowl Tongs Lighter
Located in Dayton, OH
Mid century eleven piece Arrowsmith salad serving set featuring turned mahogany bowls with sterling
Category

1960s Mid-Century Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Sterling Silver

Glazed Ceramic Aubergine Eggplant Server Set, 1960s
Located in Barcelona, ES
to serve fruit salads and would be perfect for your parties and celebrations. Enjoy fruit salad, bar
Category

Mid-20th Century Italian Mid-Century Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Majolica, Pottery, Ceramic

Modern Krenit Large Enamel Salad Bowl Herbert Krenchel Torben Ørskov Denmark
By Torben Orskov, Krenit, Herbert Krenchel
Located in Miami, FL
of Krenit Bowls and Salad Server Spoon & Fork.
Category

1950s Danish Scandinavian Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Metal, Enamel

Danish Modern 7 Krenit Salad Bowls Herbert Krenchel Torben Orskov Denmark 1950s
By Torben Orskov, Herbert Krenchel
Located in Miami, FL
. Please view our other listings of Krenit Bowls and Salad Server Spoon & Fork.
Category

1950s Danish Mid-Century Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Enamel, Metal

Sheffield English Stag Antler Handled, Sterling Silver Capped Table Servers, S/3
By Sheffield
Located in Philadelphia, PA
spoon, and a spoon and fork of a similar pattern, perfect for salads. A beautifully made set, heavy
Category

Mid-20th Century English International Style Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Sterling Silver, Stainless Steel

1950s Danish Melamine Servers by Henning Koppel for Georg Jensen
By Henning Koppel, Georg Jensen
Located in Sagaponack, NY
A set of salad spoons retaining the original makers mark.
Category

1950s Danish Mid-Century Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Resin

30% OFF Tiffany & Co. Sterling Silver 180-Piece Provence Flatware Set w/ Servers
By Tiffany & Co.
Located in New York, NY
'' in length - 12 salad forks measuring 6 3/8'' in length - 12 cocktail forks measuring 6 1/8'' in
Category

20th Century American Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Silver, Sterling Silver

Wallace Sir Christopher Sterling Silver 88-Pc Dinner Flatware Set for 12+Servers
By Wallace Silversmiths
Located in New York, NY
motifs, consisting of: - 12 dinner forks measuring 7 5/8'' in length - 12 salad forks measuring 6 3
Category

20th Century American Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Silver, Sterling Silver

Carl Poul Petersen Sterling Silver Fork and Spoon Blossom Corn Flower Servers
By Carl Poul Petersen
Located in Montreal, QC
Pair of Carl Poul Petersen large sterling silver salad servers comprising a serving spoon and
Category

20th Century Canadian Post-Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Sterling Silver

Fontana by Towle Sterling Silver Flatware Set for 12 Service 82 Pcs Many Servers
By Towle Silversmiths
Located in Big Bend, WI
forks, 7 1/4" 12 salad forks, 6 1/2" 12 teaspoons, 6" 12 place soup spoons, 6 1/2" 12 hollow handle
Category

1950s Unknown Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Sterling Silver

Modern Krenit Spoon Fork Melamine Servers H. Krenchel Torben Orskov. Denmark 50s
By Torben Orskov, Herbert Krenchel
Located in Miami, FL
Fantastic set of Danish Mid Century Modern black Melamine salad serving spoon & fork utensils
Category

1950s Danish Scandinavian Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Acrylic

Extensive English Sterling Silver Flatware Service for 12
Located in Buchanan, MI
, three-piece carving set, two-piece salad servers, serving spoon and a three prong fork.
Category

20th Century English Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Sterling Silver

Royal Danish by International Sterling Silver Flatware Set for Eight, 52 Pieces
By International Silver
Located in Big Bend, WI
meat fork, 8 7/8". One sugar spoon, 6". One salad set, all-sterling, 9 1/8". One pie server with
Category

1930s Scandinavian Modern Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Sterling Silver

Tudor Scroll by Birks Sterling Silver Flatware Set 12 Service 140 pieces Dinner
By Henry Birks
Located in Big Bend, WI
-tine, 6" 1 Lemon Fork, 2-tine, 4 3/4" 1 Tomato Server, 7 1/8" 1 Salad Set with horn implements (spoon
Category

Late 20th Century Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Sterling Silver

Classic Rose by Reed and Barton Sterling Silver Flatware Set 8 Service 42 pcs
By Reed & Barton
Located in Big Bend, WI
, 5 3/4" 1 Salad Set, w/black nylon, 12" 1 Pie Server w/stainless blade, 10 1/2" 1 Nut Spoon, 5
Category

Mid-20th Century Vintage Glass Salad Servers

Materials

Sterling Silver

  • 1
  • ...
Get Updated with New Arrivals
Save "Vintage Glass Salad Servers", and we’ll notify you when there are new listings in this category.

Vintage Glass Salad Servers For Sale on 1stDibs

An assortment of vintage glass salad servers is available at 1stDibs. The range of distinct vintage glass salad servers — often made from metal, silver and sterling silver — can elevate any home. Vintage glass salad servers have long been popular, with older editions for sale from the 18th Century and newer versions made as recently as the 21st Century. mid-century modern, Art Deco and Scandinavian Modern vintage glass salad servers are consistently popular styles. Many vintage glass salad servers are appealing in their simplicity, but Gorham Manufacturing Company, Georg Jensen and Christofle produced popular vintage glass salad servers that are worth a look.

How Much are Vintage Glass Salad Servers?

Vintage glass salad servers can differ in price owing to various characteristics — the average selling price at 1stDibs is $7,650, while the lowest priced sells for $34 and the highest can go for as much as $72,195.

Finding the Right tableware for You

While it isn’t always top of mind for some, antique and vintage tableware can enhance even the most informal meal. It has been an intimate part of how we’ve interacted with our food for millennia.

Tableware has played a basic but important role in everyday life. Ancient Egyptians used spoons (which are classified as flatware) made of ivory and wood, while Greeks and Romans, who gathered for banquets involving big meals and entertainment, ate with forks and knives. At the beginning of the 17th century, however, forks were still uncommon in American homes. Over time, tableware has thankfully evolved and today includes increasingly valuable implements.

Tableware refers to the tools people use to set the table, including serving pieces, dinner plates and more. It encompasses everything from the intricate and elaborate to the austere and functional, yet are all what industrial product designer Jasper Morrison might call “Super Normal” — anonymous objects that are too useful to be considered banal.

There are four general categories of tableware — serveware, dinnerware, drinkware and, lastly, flatware, which is commonly referred to as silverware or cutlery. Serveware includes serving bowls, platters, gravy boats, casserole pans and ladles. Most tableware is practical, but it can also be decorative. And decorative objects count as tableware too. Even though they don’t fit squarely into one of the four categories, vases, statues and floral arrangements are traditional centerpieces.

Drinkware appropriately refers to the vessels we use for our beverages — mugs, cups and glasses. There is a good deal of variety that falls under this broad term. For example, your cheerful home bar or mid-century modern bar cart might be outfitted with a full range of vintage barware, which might include pilsner glasses and tumblers. Specialty cocktails are often served in these custom glasses, but they’re still a type of drinkware.

Every meal should be special — even if you’re using earthenware or stoneware for a casual lunch — but perhaps you’re hosting a dinner party to mark a specific event. The right high-quality tableware can bring a touch of luxury to your cuisine. Young couples, for example, traditionally add “fine china,” or porcelain, to their wedding registry as a commemoration of their union and likely wouldn’t turn down exquisite silver made by Tiffany & Co. or Georg Jensen.

It’s important to remember, however, that when you’re setting the dining room table to have fun with it. Just as you might mix and match your dining chairs, don’t be afraid to mix new and old or high and low with your tableware. On 1stDibs, find an extraordinary range of vintage and antique tableware to help elevate your meal as well as the mood and atmosphere of your entire dining room.

Read More

Ready for a Cinderella Moment? This Glass Handbag Is a Perfect Fit

Glass slippers might be the stuff of fairytales, but glass handbags? Artist Joshua Raiffe has made them a reality, and they're far less delicate than you might imagine, but just as dreamy.

With Dansk, Jens Quistgaard Delivered Danish Simplicity to American Tables

When a visionary Copenhagen designer teamed up with an enterprising Long Island couple, Scandi-style magic landed in kitchens and dining rooms across the United States.

Hostess Extraordinaire Aerin Lauder Shares Entertaining Tips and Auction Picks

The arbiter of good taste, who has curated a collection for 1stDibs Auctions, invites 1stDibs inside her family’s Hamptons barn for a firsthand look at her welcoming style.

Handmade with Lab-Grade Glass, This Decanter Holds Your Favorite Cocktail Concoctions

Artist Simone Crestani conjures the fascination you remember from Chemistry 101.

28 Cheerful Home Bars, Where Everybody (Literally) Knows Your Name

Simple or sophisticated, equipped with console, cart or custom cabinetry, these stylish bar areas deserve a toast.

Meet the Celebrated Hostess Whose Magical Tabletops Enhance Every Occasion

For Stephanie Booth Shafran, entertaining guests is about opening her heart as well as her home.

How to Identify Real Capodimonte Porcelain

Early examples by the Italian manufacturer can be hard to come by, but the best later pieces possess the same over-the-top charm.

How Noguchi Elevated Ashtrays to Objets d’Art

Smoking might have fallen out of fashion, but these ashtrays have enduring design appeal.